Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 October 2007

AT&T’s 700MHz purchase could turn US mobile TV market on its head

AT&T’s sudden move last week to buy the 700MHz spectrum that is held by Aloha Partners for $2.5bn places a new value on video broadcasting connectivity and sets a precedent for the 2008 US auctions of further allocations in this beachfront band.

While analysts began moaning that the price was too high, and claiming that this was the end of non-MediaFLO mobile TV in the US, our instincts are that AT&T may well be buying this spectrum as a reward for HiWire’s demonstration that DVB-H really works, rather than sidelining the spectrum for something else (HiWire is a joint venture between Aloha and SES, which has been trialling DVB-H mobile TV). If so, AT&T will be positioning itself to work with a TV technology that is better aligned with its UMTS network than MediaFLO, to which it had previously committed.

The purchase price, of course, does not reflect the money that Aloha spent on the licenses, but the increasing value of 700MHz spectrum and a two-year lead in building out a mobile TV and data delivery network across the US. When we said to Aloha a few weeks back that they might get an offer from Qualcomm, to add the spectrum to their existing MediaFLO channel, Aloha told us: ‘Qualcomm is unlikely to pay us what it is worth,’ a statement now clearly justified.

This all assumes that this purchase is at least partly about mobile TV ‘ and we would indeed expect AT&T to drop its MediaFLO relationship in favor of a network that it builds itself using DVB-H. If that proves to be the case, then DVB-H has delivered a body blow to MediaFLO, halving its likely uptake, and weakening its grip on both the US and therefore on any other market that might have been convinced it was the up-and-coming mobile broadcast TV technology.

We could never see Aloha building out in this spectrum, which would probably have cost somewhere close to $500m across the US, and always felt that its mobile TV trials in Las Vegas were all about convincing someone that it had the whiphand in terms of spectrum over MediaFLO. Qualcomm acquired a single 6MHz channel, compared to the two that are owned by Aloha, and despite claiming that it can mount 20 channels in this bandwidth, Aloha’s spectrum was always going to offer something close to double that, depending upon who you believe. Qualcomm insists that its technology offers faster channel change, more channels and better in-building penetration compared to DVB-H; however some mobile TV experts insist that the two standards vying for supremacy in mobile TV are far more similar than different, and only last week chipmaker Siano showed a two-second channel change when working with DVB-H, directly in line with MediaFLO claims.

We have previously likened MediaFLO in value to the combined US satellite radio operations, showing that if MediaFLO could retain exclusive deals with AT&T as well as Verizon for the delivery of a US-wide mobile TV network, then it might come to be worth more than $10bn. Overnight that potential has at least halved, if not fallen away entirely ‘ although AT&T is still likely to go ahead and use MediaFLO for a short time at least, while its new network is being built out.

It is also likely that AT&T will use at least part of its new spectrum to get a headstart in LTE, something Verizon Wireless is also likely to do if it gains its own licenses in this band in the January auction. Though the technology will not be commercially standardized at this point, let alone in a 700MHz profile, this would be valuable spectrum to trial the technology that is likely to underpin the pre-4G roll-outs of both leading US cellcos. And of course AT&T has got its hands on a swathe that is not encumbered by any open access or other FCC restrictions.

Regardless of future uses such as LTE, in the short term AT&T will reap real benefits from doing mobile TV in 700MHz using DVB-H. It will not have to pay MediaFLO royalties to Qualcomm nor convince CDMA licensees that it was worth developing a MediaFLO/UMTS phone, just for AT&T. (An AT&T U-turn could certainly make the creation of UMTS/MediaFLO devices and services less likely in other parts of the world too). Licensing for AT&T to use MediaFLO would be expensive, since Qualcomm has said openly that it will bundle its license free to existing CDMA customers ‘ a practice which is also under scrutiny in the US, Europe and Korea by antitrust regulators. Those operators would be pretty upset if Qualcomm cut a sweet deal with AT&T.

One factor that may have been influential in the signing of the Aloha deal could have been the legal action brought by Nokia against Qualcomm over the MediaFLO standard, claiming that much of the technology was derived from DVB-H. If the Finn has any success in claiming royalties from Qualcomm over this technology then that cost may have been transferred directly to operators and handset builders.

Whether AT&T can stop developing for MediaFLO instantly or not will depend upon the exact wording in its contract. This announcement, in the long term, puts AT&T directly up against Verizon in the mobile TV stakes, and its eight-channel Vcast TV is looking pretty anaemic compared to what AT&T might build now. Its only chance is to make hay while the network is being built, and grab as much of MediaFLO that it can get from Qualcomm, either all the available channels or buying the entire network outright.

However just because Verizon decides that it needs more mobile TV coverage does not mean that Qualcomm would be happy to sell off the US MediaFLO network. It has trials around the world in places as diverse as the UK, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Japan and Malaysia and wants to convince more of the global heavyweights to at least try out MediaFLO. Most of those trials have stronger local DVB-H or other technology trials that have been in place longer, and there is no certainty that MediaFLO will win any other customers outside of the US.

The fact that so far Verizon has only offered an eight-channel service, despite the fact that Qualcomm insists that MediaFLO can handle 20 channels in a 6MHz slice of spectrum, allows rivals like T-Mobile, and Sprint, both of which have taken a long hard look at the technology, as well as Alltel, a chance to buy into the existing mobile TV multiplex in the current spectrum. If Verizon takes all the capacity or buys the network outright, those companies can no longer be courted, a fact that will harm Qualcomm’s global efforts.

AT&T could even turn the screw and offer any new DVB-H mobile TV service that it creates to other UMTS carriers such as T-Mobile, or even to CDMA rivals such as Sprint, but of course that’s very unlikely. As much as AT&T wants to disadvantage Verizon, it does not want to help out another rival. It may deem killing off the Verizon Vcast TV more important than other rivalries, although from its deal with Apple over the iPhone, it is more likely to keep it as an exclusive, building out against the day when Sprint’s network has 4G capability through its WiMAX build-out, and threatens to steal customers.

Build-out of a DVB-H network, when carried out at breakneck speed, will still take 18 months in the top US markets and although planning can start prior to the deal completing, which would save some time, not so much as a single transmitter can be put in place until AT&T is sure that it is allowed to buy the Aloha spectrum, which could take 6-9 months to clear.

The next issue is to ask who will supply the infrastructure equipment, software and devices that will sit on such a network, and the first idea that comes to mind is the iPhone. Apple has shown that strategically, anything that prevents its devices from being solely reliant on iTunes for content is anathema to its senior management. But one of the neat things about the iPhone is the amount of onboard storage that AT&T could easily, at least partially, convert to a digital video recorder for TV. Apple is already tied to an exclusive there, so why wouldn’t it add the $10 bill of materials required to turn the iPhone into a DVB-H receiver?

Failing the iPhone, Motorola has DVB-H devices on sale in other parts of the world, while Samsung and LG would readily create a UMTS DVB-H device (though perhaps not so readily one for CDMA). Nokia is the global leader in the devices, but its implementation is understood not to work with the existing multiplex that HiWire has built. But that could soon be changed and lead to a solid opening within AT&T for some of the sexier new Nokia devices such as the N95 and N73.

While US transmitter company Harris, and rival Thomson Grass Valley, might be favorites to pick up huge contracts at AT&T, the incumbent at the Las Vegas trial is German Rohde and Schwarz along with DMT, another European transmitter builder. Also, suddenly, the rest of the mobile TV community, including specialist chip players DiBcom, Siano and local start-ups like NewPort Media, along with Texas Instruments, will all have a shot at providing core chips to device makers, with even Qualcomm making a chip that offers both MediaFLO and DVB-H.

If Verizon Wireless does find itself without any further suitable spectrum, and tied to a service that can at best offer 20 TV channels, up against an operation that can do twice that, it will be forced to look at other technologies to see what it can do to keep up. Alcatel is setting up a satellite DVB-SH broadcast from a satellite owned by ICO Communications, a Craig McCaw-controlled operation, which we have assumed will align with Clearwire and potentially Sprint. That realistically leaves Verizon having to construct more channels using some form of cellular multicast, devoting a small piece of existing spectrum, temporarily at each base station, upon request. The protocol which manages this within CDMA networks comes from the 3GPP2 standards body and is called Broadcast Multicast Services (BCMCS). This is being used in experiments in Japan by KDDI, but has little following elsewhere. However Qualcomm might be able to harness 10-15 mobile TV channels within the chip circuitry designed for EV-DO Rev B, as it has done on its HSDPA chips with the equivalent MBMS protocol for UMTS networks.

The 700MHz auction:

Amid all the legal challenges surrounding the 700MHz auction, the FCC has delayed the event by a mere eight days, from January 16 to January 24. The auction has to be completed by January 28 and the rules still call for open access provisions on the C Block, despite attempts by Verizon Wireless and others to change this.

The regulator said: “This change of the previously announced start date for Auction 73 will provide interested parties with additional time after this announcement of competitive bidding procedures to develop business plans, assess market conditions and evaluate the availability of equipment for new 700MHz band services,” the FCC stated. Bidders must apply for the auctions between November 19 and December 3. The FCC plans to hold a mock auction a week before the official one.

Meanwhile, the public safety community is laying the foundations to partner with the winner of a national wireless license. The Public Safety Spectrum Trust has filed an application with the FCC to become the licensee that partners with the winning bidder of the commercial/first responder hybrid license in the 700MHz auction.

The PSST board of directors is comprised of representatives from the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials, the Association of Public-Safety Communications Officials-International, the Forestry Conservation Communications Association, the International Association of Chiefs of Police, the International Association of Fire Chiefs, the International Municipal Signal Association, the National Association of State Emergency Medical Services Officials, the National Emergency Number Association and the National Sheriffs Association. The PSST selected Cyren Call as its adviser for negotiations with the eventual commercial license holder of the nationwide 10MHz.

The PSST, a non-profit entity, issued a statement of requirements for bidders seeking the D Block license that includes 10MHz of spectrum adjacent to a separate swathe of 24MHz allocated for public safety communications alone.