Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 November 2012

Auction fiasco betrays continuing policy crisis in India

India’s 3G services are starting to see accelerated uptake and there are even some nascent 4G services based on TD-LTE, but the vast majority of the population still relies on GSM, and in some regions mobile penetration remains as low as 40%. The vast country’s 2G policy has been a disaster under successive governments, leaving operators struggling for capacity to meet rising demand, and consumers with poor quality of service.

The capacity crunch in simple 2G services was worsened by the corruption scandal that led the Supreme Court to revoke 122 licences, originally awarded in 2008, earlier this year. And while there was much discussion about how the second auction of this spectrum could be structured to make the Indian 2G market more profitable and competitive, in fact the government could not resist the lure of easy revenues and set high reserve prices ‘ with the result that almost 58% of the spectrum still remains unsold and unused, and the business case for a 2G-only model becomes ever more unconvincing.

Three of the five companies which did bid in the auction rerun, Vodafone, Idea Cellular and Bharti Airtel, already hold GSM and 3G spectrum (and 4G in Bharti’s case), and so were seeking additional capacity in key regions. This is a workable approach but does not further regulator TRAI’s goal of boosting competition. Some of the previous winners from the 2008 process, such as Russia’s Sistema, decided not to participate this time, and no new bidders emerged. Just two of those left with no GSM spectrum after the Supreme Court ruling, Videocon and Telenor, decided to try again and secured licences this time around.

However, 42.4% of the spectrum on offer ‘ in 1.25MHz blocks in the 1.8GHz band ‘ went unsold, including all the pan-India licences and those for the largest metro areas, Delhi and Mumbai. The government had hoped for the highest prices for these blocks, but operators said the base price had been set too high. For instance, the national franchises carried a reserve price of INR14,000, seen as commercially unfeasible in a market where ARPUs are ultra-low and higher value data services tend to run on the new 3G networks. There were also no bids for Delhi, Mumbai, Karnataka and Rajasthan. In total, 101 of the 144 blocks on offer were bought. The government is still to rule on the future of the CDMA spectrum, since all the bidders dropped out of that sale before the auction process began.

Cellcos have either decided to rely on other services ‘ and future auctions such as that of digital dividend spectrum ‘ to boost their presence in the two big cities, or have gambled on the spectrum going unsold, and having to be offered again at lower prices. Carriers such as Vodafone and Bharti are highly sensitive about spectrum costs, having been widely regarded as overspending in last year’s 3G sale. And at least those frequencies support new and higher margin services, while these new licences can only be used to improve capacity for the lowest ARPU GSM offerings on the planet (or, perhaps, retained for future refarming as 1.8GHz becomes a popular LTE band round the world. However, that would

All these factors meant that the sale of reissued frequencies ended after just two days of bidding, and with only 42.4% of the spectrum sold. That meant disappointment for the government, since the bids totalled INR94.07bn ($1.7bn), far less than the INR280bn targeted by the authorities and the INR400bn discussed by some of the more optimistic analysts.

The largest bidder was Vodafone, which secured 1.25MHz of top-up 2G spectrum in 14 operating circles. The operator said it had decided to bid ‘to secure additional spectrum in many circles where we have not received any new 2G spectrum since 2008. Our customers grew in that period from 60m to 153m today. Vodafone did not have its 2008 licences cancelled.

Telenor previously held licences within a joint venture called Uninor but has now changed its JV partner and under its new entity, Telewings, gained spectrum in six circles. It was the highest spender, bidding a total of INR40.18bn. It focused on states with low mobile penetration ‘ just 40% in many cases. All Uninor assets in the circles will be transferred to the new firm.

Like Telenor, Videcon won back cancelled licences in six circles and will pay INR22.22bn. Idea Cellular won back the permits it lost in seven circles, as well as a block of spectrum in an additional region, for a total of INR20.3bn. The largest cellco, Bharti Airtel, will pay out just INR86.7m for additional spectrum in just one circle.

The government now faces decisions about how to deal with the unsold spectrum, with one option to restage the auction with lower reserve prices.

It has not only failed in its revenue generating objectives, but in attracting new players. One of the big reforms in the process, announced in February, was the introduction of national licences. Previously, spectrum has always been awarded separately for each of India’s 22 operating circles, which has led to fragmentation and to companies having to sign complex roaming deals to gain national coverage ‘ even in 3G. But the high reserve price meant that change was denied the chance to reshape India’s services.

“We had indicated that there would be several circles that have no bidders. And that’s exactly what we have seen,” Rajan Mathews of the Cellular Operators Association of India (COAI) – the trade body which has led opposition to the high reserve prices – told The Wall Street Journal.

Another factor is likely to be uncertainty and dispute over TRAI’s proposed policies for refarming 900MHz and 1.8GHz 2G spectrum in future, for 3G or even 4G. The current proposals would allow cellcos to retain only 2.5MHz of their 900MHz spectrum at the time of licence renewal in 2014, while the rest would be reallocated with refarming in mind. But critics argue that this would disrupt 2G services in a band which is ideal for broad coverage, before the point where it will be practical to migrate a large percentage of users, especially in rural areas, to 3G. Nokia Siemens’ Asia and Middle East chief, Ashish Chowdhary, said in a recent interview with the Economic Times: ‘India’s spectrum refarming plan looks too ambitious and must not be implemented in a hurry as it could hurt the consumer by way of sharply higher call charges, triggered by escalating costs at the incumbent operator end.’ In other countries where some 900MHz spectrum has been withdrawn for refarming, such as France and Sweden, only a small portion was removed from existing holders, without disupting their ongoing operations. In other markets, like the US, operators are refarming their own spectrum and making commercial choices about how quickly to repurpose it. Operators believe they need to retain a minimum of 4.2MHz of capacity in 900MHz to ensure network quality. Chowdhary called on the government to engage in a broader consultation before finalizing its policy, since ‘spectrum refarming on the scale being proposed by DoT would entail a complete overhaul of networks, both in terms of replanning, redesigning and introduction of fresh elements. More so, since this involves taking away a majority of the airwaves in the efficient 900MHz band from operators and replacing them with frequencies in the 1.8GHz band. Such an exercise is bound to inflate costs at the incumbent operator’s end.’