Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 October 2005

Baby Bells step up convergence plans as a new breed of CLEC emerges

The major US carriers are starting to put flesh on to their next generation network plans, and their decisions over the coming months will help to decide the balance of power among the various technologies on offer and their vendor supporters, as well as giving clear indications of whether the incumbent Bell operators really may be vulnerable to new challengers.

Those with the most to win or lose among the platform makers are probably Qualcomm/CDMA and Motorola. While CDMA is assured of two major EV-DO Rev A roll-outs, by Sprint and Verizon, Qualcomm now needs to gain carrier sign-up for its broader platform, including its OFDM plans and its mobile television architecture FLO. And Motorola, faced with the eventual loss of its largest customer, Nextel and the iDEN network, needs to replace that business, preferably with a a major contract with Sprint Nextel ‘ one of the motivators behind the vendor’s aggressive devotion to mobile WiMAX as a complement, or even an alternative, to 3.5G.

The stakes are just as high for the Bell operators, especially with major telecoms reform underway. They are currently making a particularly important set of choice because they are no longer looking at cellular strategies in a vacuum but as part of a move towards convergence with the fixed line operations, and an attempt to use bundled services to stave off new challengers from the VoIP, cable and broadband wireless sectors. Competitive providers are grasping technologies like WiMAX and broadband over powerline as a new chance to chip away at the major operators’ cabal, with Clearwire’s alliance with Bell Canada and Covad’s recent acquisition of NextWeb (see separate item) just two examples of how challengers are mobilizing themselves after a long depression.

What is even more threatening to the major Bell operators ‘ Verizon, SBC and BellSouth, with their cellular joint ventures Verizon Wireless and Cingular ‘ is the prospect of a well established operator taking on the role of agent provocateur. They may have neutralized the threat of long lines giants AT&T and MCI taking wireless into the last mile – assuming SBC’s acquisition of the former and Verizon’s of the latter go through ‘ but fresh from its own merger, Sprint Nextel stands independent and dangerous. Not only will it build, alongside CDMA EV-DO, a parallel broadband wireless network in its 2.5GHz spectrum, which could attack the Bells in the last mile and offer mobile/fixed broadband bundles from one cost effective network; but it also has the potential to exploit its often forgotten local business to disruptive effect.

The local telephone division is to be spun off from Sprint Nextel, which may reduce its power somewhat ‘ a real threat to the Bells would have come from combining this business with the broadband wireless last mile activities to create a national, multi-network offering. However, there is still the opportunity for Sprint to partner with its former unit, once spin-off has been achieved, or for Sprint Local to work with other allies to increase its competitive edge. An obvious scenario could be a merger with the weakest of the Bells, Qwest, which is hoping to use WiMAX to improve its ability to offer broadband triple play in its difficult western terrain and potentially to break out of its territory. Another candidate could be the fixed line unit of the fifth US cellco, Alltel, which plans to sell this off soon.

Sprint Local has only 5% market share, but with heavy focus on high growth markets in Florida and Nevada, and it generates high levels of cash and has upgraded its network almost entirely to support VoIP. Alone, or preferably with a partner or two, it has sufficient weight to prod the Bells into action. Verizon, BellSouth, Qwest and SBC are already the subject of legal action alleging that they act as a cartel, agreeing not to compete against each other in their home markets and to exclude other competitors.
This week, a federal appeals court allowed an antitrust lawsuit against the four Bells to proceed, overturning a dismissal of the suit by a lower court. The complaint alleges that the telcos, which control 90% of US local phone services, conspired not to compete against one another in their respective geographic markets for local telephone and high speed Internet services and to prevent competitors from entering those markets. This alleged conspiracy has driven a number of competing local exchange carriers out of business and forced consumers to pay higher rates, states the suit.

But market forces, in the shape of some real challengers, could have a more immediate effect on the Bells’ behavior than the slow process of lawsuits, goading them into more creative approaches to their customers and real competitive behaviour, even using their own broadband wireless holdings to go after new territories. And Sprint Local could be a catalyst, with a strong balance sheet and no interest to stay confined to its current territories. An alliance with its former parent’s broadband wireless outfit ‘ if permitted ‘ or with Clearwire could give it a rapid way to break out of those borders and offer national VoIP.

With the rise of a rejuvenated class of CLECs, plus Sprint Nextel, looming, the Bells are currently staying ‘ legally or not ‘ within their territories, looking for growth from new service bundles enabled by convergence and fiber, and from their mobile ventures. Cingular, the BellSouth-SBC mobile joint venture, is the most advanced of the US carriers in terms of fixed-mobile convergence, with a plan that carries strong echoes of British Telecom’s Project Fusion. Like BT, Cingular will initially use the Unlicensed Mobile Access (UMA) technology, which uses Wi-Fi or Bluetooth for hand-off between fixed and cellular lines, to offer integrated services with a single handset across its parents’ wirelines, as well as its own cellular and wireless Lan networks. In phase two, it will move to full implementation of an IMS (IP Multimedia Subsystem), to support cost effective and flexible roll-out of multiple IP-based services, transparently across all its networks and access devices. However, this requires a major upgrade at the core and so will only be practical once Cingular finishes implementing 3G across its network by late 2006.

Cingular’s convergence program is likely to provide a boost for at least two of the four main vendors behind Fusion ‘ Alcatel, which is already a major supplier to SBC and BellSouth; Motorola, the most advanced in terms of UMA implementations; Lucent and Ericsson. All but Ericsson have spotted ‘ like the converged operators ‘ a way to make virtue out of the necessity of supporting their depressed wireline activities, by taking a lead in converged services. Even Ericsson, though more ambivalent, is stepping up its wireline initiatives to avoid being left in a cellular-only niche. Cingular recently joined the Bluephone consortium, formed by these suppliers to create the BT Fusion technology.

If other large carriers choose to adopt Fusion as a template platform rather than reinventing the wheel, the Bluephone group will have gained a very powerful headstart in convergence that should also stand them in good stead once the full-blown IMS deployments start in earnest in 2007. WiMAX will also be an important part of this picture for operators that will include broadband wireless in their mix, such as BT and Sprint Nextel, and Alcatel and Lucent have already demonstrated WiMAX in an IMS.

Cingular’s approach strengthens the notion that UMA will be the primary convergence platform during the run-up to full IMS, and may expand its functionality and remit sufficiently that, in some cases, it will actually delay the deployment of IMS by making the requirement less urgent. The role of UMA will depend on market conditions, however, notably the level of uptake of Wi-Fi and the scale of fixed-mobile line substitution (see diagram). Others will remain committed to an early roll-out of IMS, including Sprint Nextel itself, which in its determination to use convergence as a springboard to leapfrog the Bells, claims it will be the first to launch a full IMS system in the US, next year.

Verizon’s convergence strategy is less clear and its financial priorities lie with its fiber to the home roll-out and aggressive upgrade of its CDMA EV-DO network for Verizon Wireless, the highly successful cellular venture with Vodafone. As such, it seems in the short term that Verizon is more interested in making its separate wireline and mobile operations the most advanced in the US individually, than in converging them at an early stage. There are many risks attached to the fiber strategy, since Verizon aims to deliver the high speed connection right to the home or kerb in many areas, unlike SBC, whose Project Lightspeed will still require another technology for the last few hundred meters at least ‘ which with the rapid improvements in wireless and DSL access technologies, should prove a competitive and cost effective route.

Few would criticize Verizon Wireless’ hi-tech plans though, as the company looks well placed to snatch back the market lead it lost when Cingular merged with AT&T Wireless. It is delivering a host of new mobile services over EV-DO, and soon EV-DO Rev A, which will also support full IP applications such as VoIP, even before a full IMS is required. Unlike its wireline co-parent, Verizon Wireless is balancing the huge investment in network upgrade with a wealth of immediate revenue streams generated from creative applications that use the current systems rather than having to wait for the new ones.

One example is mobile television, where Verizon has achieved strong uptake of its television clips and specially created programming, delivered over the standard 3G network. Having proved the concept, it is now looking to invest in a dedicated mobile TV system in order to support more advanced offerings. This is a customer that Qualcomm might have hoped to attract for its recently launched MediaFLO platform, a network that the chipmaker itself will build in its own 700MHz spectrum to support cellco TV services, using the Qualcomm FLO broadcast technology. But despite its devotion to CDMA, Verizon is reported to be planning to use a rival TV approach, DVB-H (Digital Video Broadcast-Handheld), a standard that is gaining acceptance in Europe and is heavily backed by Nokia and, in the US, tower owner Crown Castle. The latter, like Qualcomm, has acquired spectrum (a 6MHz channel in 1.6GHz) across the US to support its chosen platform and the companies have been conducting extensive trials. Now it seems that will pay off with a Verizon deal that could also increase Nokia’s penetration of the giant cellco on the handset front, since the Finnish company will be a leader in DVB-H capable handsets and will look to this to improve its showing in the CDMA sector.

The other CDMA major in the US, Sprint Nextel, is expected to use MediaFLO, but with only one of the national US cellcos on its side, Qualcomm will need to step up its efforts to gain FLO customers in other countries ‘ something it claims is very feasible because FLO is not tied to CDMA. However, the expected Verizon choice of DVB-H has highlighted many of the issues that Qualcomm faces in convergence. Although it claims it will be able to provide a fixed/mobile platform using its OFDM technologies ‘ including recently acquired Flarion Flash-OFDM ‘ it remains firmly a mobile player, and one that lacks, because of its determination to plough its own technology furrow, the web of partners that could enable it to create a converged offering like Fusion.

Adapting its handset and infrastructure reference platforms to a converged model and so keeping the multi-network equipment makers on its side will be a tough challenge. Currently Qualcomm is addressing it by seeking to keep CDMA technically excellent, and expanding its functionality using OFDM, so that no vendor can exclude these technologies from its portfolio, even if they need to be offered alongside other networks. But as companies move towards supporting multi-network base stations and handsets, it will become vital for Qualcomm to take a friendlier line towards new licensees, many of which are working on converged platforms for GSM, WiMAX, WLan and/or fixed line but are deterred by the CDMA giant’s aggressive licensing policies from touching CDMA.

The ability to attract new licensees from outside the CDMA market and inside the convergence territory is the real issue, rather than pleasing the operators ‘ the claims that Verizon has chosen DVB-H to reduce its dependence on Qualcomm do not ring true, given that the famous CDMA royalty payments are borne by the vendors not the carriers, and the chip giant has made a speciality of listening to, and seeking to address, operators’ real world requirements.

It does, undoubtedly though, face many challenges in adapting to a world where cellular-only businesses are no longer the stars but are looking vulnerable. Its most important response for the CDMA community itself has been EV-DO Rev A, which contains the option of using IP Multimedia Domain (MMD), which supports IP applications and convergence across multiple access technologies including WLan and fixed line. This allows CDMA operators gradually to shift applications from circuit switching to IP without a massive upfront capital investment (although 3GPP2, the body that runs the CDMA2000 standards, is working on a parallel IMS development to that of 3GPP).

This is still a far cry from a platform that is adopted outside the CDMA base, and the real breakthrough for Qualcomm would come with a win for its OFDM technologies in a non-CDMA carrier ‘ an area where it will be fighting on a level playing field with the pre-WiMAX platforms (hence Qualcomm’s corporate aggression towards WiMAX, which it has taken to referring to as WhyMAX).

Such a breakthrough is unlikely to come in the US, despite Nextel’s 2004 trials of Flash-OFDM. The CDMA majors are the least focused on convergence at the current time, with Verizon focusing on putting its different systems ahead rather than integrating them, and Sprint Nextel lacking major wireline business. And the convergence giants are firmly wedded to UMTS combined with Wi-Fi, wireline and UMA, notably Cingular but also including T-Mobile. The new business opportunities in that group are open to the vendors that move ahead most rapidly with integration platforms based around UMA and IMS, not to those that would argue a change to the core infrastructure. With the Bells facing a level of challenge that they have not had to imagine for some years, combined with a massive ‘ some might say rash ‘ commitment to fiber roll-out, they will be nervous of plans that involve additional major capex, and eager to find options that will maximize the return on their existing investments in mobile and last mile networks. These options will revolve around new services, such as television and IMS-enabled applications, but they will need to be introduced quickly and creatively. If not, and regardless of how the antitrust lawsuits proceed, they will start to lose customers to Sprint Nextel and to the rising number of coalitions of smaller ISPs and CLECs, which are grasping converged networks and wireless broadband as their own chance to gain market share.