Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 October 2005

BellSouth-Sprint deal could signal a major change of course for RBOCs

When Verizon agreed to buy MCI and SBC to take over AT&T, there would have been a pleasing logic had BellSouth, the third of the senior regional Bell operators (RBOCs), decided to make a play for the only remaining national long distance operator, Sprint’s long lines business. With Sprint’s former interest in spinning off the wireline unit faded, in the light of the new business model it has formulated in the wake of its own merger with Nextel, BellSouth has done the next best thing and signed a pact to use Sprint’s system to deliver business data services outside its own territories. This is more than a convenient pact ‘ it epitomizes the shifting balance of power among the major US telcos, with Sprint Nextel poised to exploit its unique combination of infrastructure assets to take the role of kingmaker among the Bells; and the Bells themselves, forced to compete against each other for the first time outside the cosy warmth of their allotted territories, casting about for the partnerships that will help them do that in the converged market.

Under the Sprint-BellSouth deal, enterprise customers will be offered data services that use the BellSouth private IP backbone in its own territories and then move on to the Sprint MPLS system elsewhere. The services will be targeted at companies with multiple locations that need to integrate different access technologies at the various offices. Now BellSouth will offer a managed solution regardless of customer location, increasing its addressable customer base and allowing it to compete with similar large business offerings from AT&T and MCI (soon to be part of its fellow RBOCs’ portfolios of course).

This is just one instance of the RBOCs starting to creep out of their own lands and compete head-in with one another, a change being driven partly by fears of antitrust probes but mainly by the need to expand their revenue bases as traditional businesses come under margin pressure. We can expect their neutrality pact to break down in other areas too, even in local access markets, where they have the new opportunity to use broadband wireless in their 2.3GHz holdings to offer last mile services even where they have not laid copper and fiber.

Surely one casualty of this new competitiveness, medium term, will be the Cingular ownership? Both SBC and BellSouth need to put mobility at the center of their convergence strategies in order to maximize the value of their service bundles and deliver the fabled mobile triple play. Yet it will be increasingly hard for them both to use Cingular as the vehicle for that strategy, if they are competing with each other for the same business and even consumer markets. SBC has made no secret that it would like to buy out BellSouth’s 45% stake (Department of Justice and FCC willing of course), or at least, presumably, to have a partner with fewer conflicts of interest (while Verizon would also like full control of its successful wireless arm, at least its partner Vodafone does not compete with it, and also brings the huge advantage of a level of skill in running mobile operations that no US carrier can even begin to match).

BellSouth could look to acquire T-Mobile USA, but it requires major investment in 3G upgrades and has limited spectrum. Surely it is not beyond the bounds of possibility ‘ again, regulators willing ‘ that a more ambitious deal could be done, with BellSouth forming a venture with Sprint for use of the mobile and broadband wireless networks as well as the long lines? Such an agreement already looks like an attractive option for the Cinderella of the Bells, Qwest, which has no mobile network, the least promising of territories for triple play, and failed in its bid to acquire MCI. But BellSouth would be a more lucrative partner for Sprint Nextel, and a more powerful one in increasing its power in the overall telecoms market, and so its value (and such a partnership would not be damaged by the fact that Sprint’s visionary CEO, Gary Forsee, was formerly vice chairman of BellSouth and retains strong links.)

The killer aspect of Sprint’s business model has proved to be its MVNO strategy, which involves it leasing capacity on its CDMA network to virtual operators such as Virgin Mobile or Time Warner Cable. This has been the single biggest factor in Sprint’s financial transformation under Forsee. The simplest logic of a potential BellSouth deal, then, would be to extend the MVNO model to all Sprint Nextel’s networks, allowing other carriers to hire capacity on the long lines and the planned broadband wireless network as well as the cellular system.

There are many arguments why Sprint Nextel should pursue this strategy to its logical end of defocusing on the Sprint brand, and own-delivered services, altogether and becoming purely a carrier’s carrier. Sprint’s infrastructure has massive potential value because it supports the highest value aspects of the converged services chain ‘ enterprise, mobile and wireless triple play, with none of the millstones of legacy local connections to support (except for its relatively small local lines business, of which more later). By leasing this to other carriers, it can avoid the costs of customer acquisition and support and offer partners a modern and multi-network platform that is unique in the US and so can command high revenue rates.

All this without having to worry about the local loop ‘ surely a situation many telcos, struggling to upgrade their last mile networks under increasing pressure from VoIP and other challenges, would kill for. Sprint can lease its national and international wireless and wireline networks to cablecos and DSL operators because it does not have the conflict of interest with its own local services that Verizon or SBC would have. It can sell off its local lines business for additional clarity, plus cost savings. It can become the wireless element of a cableco’s mobile triple play or the long distance aspect of a local operator’s bid to go national.

It seems that Forsee and the former Nextel CEO, Tim Donahue, now executive chairman of the merged entity, do not want life to be so simple. The appealing logic of the above scenario is complicated by the company’s aim, stated clearly post-merger, to become a last mile access player itself. Its key weapon will be its 2.5GHz broadband wireless network, which has to built, as a condition of the merger, to reach 30m potential customers by 2009. It sees this network not just as another string to the MVNO business, or a parallel, high bandwidth system for the cellular service, but also as a means to create its own broadband access network quickly and relatively cheaply to take on the RBOCs and shift the telco balance of power in its own favour. Donahue said in a post-merger interview: “We will be able to build a new high capacity, high quality broadband network that can carry any content that any consumer wants to have’, and both CEOs stressed that the $71bn merger was not just about gaining cellular scale but about transforming the nature of the companies to make them into broad-based, multiservice operators with a role in the broadband, mobile triple play market that all the large operators are chasing.

Partners will be necessary to achieve this, since the RBOCs’ last mile networks, while in some ways a burden, are also their greatest advantage because they bring installed base. The cablecos and Clearwire have been the most important candidates for enabling Sprint Nextel to extend its access services rapidly, but tying up with one RBOC to wrongfoot the others could also be a bold strategy. The BellSouth enterprise services deal differs from a classic virtual operator agreement in being two-way ‘ Sprint can also use the BellSouth infrastructure. Extending that model could see both companies offering their own services over a combination of their two networks, local loop or mobile, balancing direct revenues against access fees. That could save Sprint from having to put immediate resource into building out WiMAX in the BellSouth lands (where the RBOC has its own broadband wireless network in the making), while BellSouth could use its local lines and WiMAX to get into the residential sector in its fellow Bells’ kingdoms.

If Sprint is serious about becoming a last mile triple play provider in its own right, it needs to hang on to its local lines business ‘ which has only 5% market share but significant geographical coverage ‘ to complement the WiMAX access network. We would question why it needs to do this, however, when its real advantages lie in its unique ownership of long line, mobile and broadband wireless networks on a national scale. These could underpin the expansion plans of numerous local players, without Sprint having to go into direct and bloody competition with the incumbent RBOCs in their residential markets. Sprint has the potential to take on all the RBOCs through deals with Clearwire, cablecos and other operators in search of a wireless option; or to tie up with BellSouth to take on the other two majors, notably by giving BellSouth an exit route from Cingular and access to a long lines network on favourable terms. Either route would enhance its revenues and influence and be relatively low risk. Venturing into the local access triple play market under its own brand and taking on all the telcos at once could be a step too far.

BOX

Meanwhile, BellSouth is looking for alliances of its own as it spreads its wings. While its new friend Sprint Nextel is suing VoIP provider Vonage for alleged patent infringement, the RBOC is widely rumored to be preparing an acquisition bid. Vonage is ostensibly preparing for an IPO, but is also considering acquisition as an exit route for its backers, with a likely valuation of $1bn-$1.5bn, according to analyst estimates (although the $2.6bn paid by eBay for Skype may have inflated that figure). Vonage could be a good buy for BellSouth, on the ‘if you can’t beat them, join them’ principle, giving it a well established residentialVoIP service that could eliminate the headstart grabbed by Comcast and Verizon. And BellSouth could certainly increase the value of the Vonage services by offering them as part of larger bundles.

The prospect of such a deal highlights that the time is right for the pure play VoIP providers to cash out and become part of larger groups or alliances that can position their services in a triple play bundle.

The situation is reflected in Europe, where a new report from Forrester Research predicts that incumbent telcos have been sufficiently proactive to retain control of voice services despite the rise of the pure play VoIP brigade. They are, indeed, safer in Europe than in the US because uptake of VoIP is far slower, and the major telcos, such as BT, have been quick to adopt transformational all-IP platforms that no independent could match.

Meanwhile, a subsidiary of Sprint Nextel has filed a patent infringement lawsuit against Vonage and another internet telephony provider, Voiceglo Holdings, which is part of theglobe.com Sprint claims these companies have infringed seven patents relating to voice over data packet technology developed by Sprint. The lawsuit, filed in a federal court in Kansas City, Kansas, seeks injunctions against Vonage and Voiceglo as well as unspecified damages. Voiceglo offers a software-based system that allows voice calls between computers and to regular telephones, similar to Skype.

Sprint spokeswoman Debra Peterson said the company had tried to reach an agreement for more than a year with both companies over the patents. She declined to say whether Sprint had reached agreements or received royalties for the patents with any other VoIP providers.

“We are not claiming to have invented voice over packet technology, but we do have patents that have facilitated the use of this technology, and we will take appropriate action to protect the use of these patents,” she said.

BOX

BellSouth has extended its FastAccess broadband wireless service, which uses the Navini pre-WiMAX mobile platform, to its first Florida center, Palatka. The offering was first launched in August in Athens, Georgia.

The service offers downstream speeds up to 1.5Mbps and will go live in additional cities in the south eastern states this year. Monthly service starts at $29.95 per month, depending on the speed selected and whether it is combined with BellSouth local telephone service.