A takeover of BellSouth by AT&T – much discussed last year in the run-up to the merger of AT&T with its new Bellco owner SBC ‘ looks like becoming a reality earlier than many had expected, with a deal on the cards for about $67bn (plus assuming $17bn of debt). In the current regulatory environment in the US, it is, amazingly, likely that the deal would go through with relatively few conditions, creating a two-horse race (plus Qwest) with Verizon in the triple play market.
For AT&T’s aggressive CEO, Ed Whitacre, the strategy is obvious. Taking over its fellow Bell operator is the ultimate extension of the process of consolidation that has reversed the break-up of the AT&T monopoly of 1984 and brought together the original seven regional Bell operators. Acquiring BellSouth means that the company’s wireless joint venture with AT&T, Cingular, will be wholly owned, and the mega-operator will have greater reach to compete with the cablecos, which are increasingly working as a collective in some markets. In particular, it will be easier to address fixed/mobile convergence with Cingular under one ownership, and will reduce the territory where AT&T will need to invest in alternative access technologies in order to gain a national footprint for its converged triple play plans.
The catalyst for all the consolidation of the past three years in the US has been the rising importance of the mobile arms in the telcos’ growth and profits, and in particular the recognition that services delivered uniformly over fixed and mobile access networks will carry greater value and higher margins, than single-network offerings. The problem for the Bellcos is that, on the fixed side, they only have networks in a particular region. This means only a percentage of their cellular customers can have the converged offering ‘ a fact that gives Sprint Nextel, with its plans for a national, virtually wireless-only triple play ‘ its main competitive opportunity. One option, which the smallest of the four, Qwest, is pursuing, is to move into new regions using alternative access such as WiMAX, but this entails additional capex on top of the current huge plans to instal fiber.
An enlarged AT&T will have a stronger footprint and greater economies of scale as a purchaser of equipment ‘ and the merger would almost certainly spark consolidation among key Bellco suppliers too. Its new identity could certainly strengthen the nascent enterprise activities of Cingular by integrating them fully with AT&T’s business services, in the same way that Verizon is doing with MCI and Verizon Wireless. But how much stronger will it really be in the mass consumer market as that moves towards the converged triple play? Fears of an over-strong telco sparking price increases are justified but are not significantly worsened by the merger of AT&T and BellSouth, since the separate Bellcos did not really compete with each other anyway, even once the rules changed to allow this (indeed, they have faced investigations recently about whether they are operating in collusion to avoid competing with each other and driving down their collective margins). For alternative triple play access providers, such as Sprint Nextel, the cablecos and emerging wireless-based players like Clearwire, it will not necessarily be harder to compete with an enlarged AT&T than with AT&T plus BellSouth.
Indeed, while it will always be hard to compete with the Bellcos at all, because of their installed base and control of the wireline network, the opportunities are growing, and may even be helped short term by the fact that AT&T and BellSouth will be distracted by the merger, coming so soon after the AT&T-SBC transaction. And the regulator will be forced to look kindly on new technologies and operator types that could keep the Bells in check and ward off a return to monopoly-style practises. The main balance to those practises will come from the cablecos as they increasingly unite their efforts ‘ as shown by the joint venture with Sprint Nextel to add broadband wireless to their platform, and a new initiative called CableRoam to extend that concept further (see inset). But more disruptively, there is the threat of the internet model eating away at the Bellcos’ market share and profits. The combination of Google and Earthlink, using wireless networks to deliver low cost services funded by advertising, is just the most famous of a wide range of new-look providers aiming to offer consumers something cheaper and more modern than the Bell services, without the massive infrastructure costs the telcos are incurring by moving towards fiber.
This, of course, is the heart of the debate, as it has been in Europe and other regions too. If the large telcos invest the billions to create a next generation network, should they have to allow others to reap the benefits for free? This is not just about access to the local loop any more. It is about the open internet, and how the telco networks will be used to access services such as free VoIP that directly take away telco revenues. The cellcos have been grappling with this problem ever since they put a browser on the mobile phone and started to break down their walled gardens, and the same issues face the wireline networks.
The solution suggested by AT&T chief Whitacre, to charge companies like Google for offering their services on the network, goes against the whole notion of the open internet, a notion that increasingly underpins business and consumer behavior and any threat to the right of all citizens to access any internet site could push even the FCC out its of current compliance. In fact, such a strategy, while preserving revenues short term, would be the most dramatic shot in the arm for Bell competitors, driving the applications that most attract consumer spending, such as search engines, to make partnerships with alternative network owners, particularly in the mesh and broadband wireless fields, making those systems more attractive to consumers. The recent achievement by EarthLink’s upcoming MVNO, Helio, of an exclusive deal with the massively popular MySpace site shows how attractive content and applications deals will drive success in future, even for smaller players.
This conundrum is not solved by AT&T becoming larger, though it does at least give it full control of the Cingular jewel. What would help to address this intractable dilemma would be splitting access and distribution. The consolidation of the US telcos shows that competing in wireline telecommunications is about convergence and massive scale. Broadband is becoming a utility and utilities need broad coverage to be economically sustainable. But the profit from broadband networks will increasingly come, not from access fees, but from the applications that ride on top of the link, particularly those that can take advantage of both fixed and portable/mobile networks.
In this situation, and assuming moves to end net neutrality will not be acceptable to regulators, there are two stark choices for a major network owner. One is to accept there can be no walls around the content garden, but make that garden so attractive, through ease of use and range of services and content, that users choose to linger anyway, even at additional cost. This involves content partnerships and has not been a core skill of the Bell operators, and the greatest risk to that model is that it can be emulated by operators with new or virtual networks, which may prove equally successful at creating a unique and appealing customer experience, but with a far lower cost base.
The second choice is to become a carrier’s carrier like the backbone providers of the wired internet. As in other utility sectors such as transportation, the owner of the network and the service operator become separate entities with completely different models and competitive pressures.
Logically, this could drive the Bell operators to own a national utility that they then rent out to access providers, which can handle negotiations with content companies and other applications to target their service to a particular user base. This targeted marketing is a feature of the MVNO model in the cellular world, with which mobile network owners look to generate more revenue from their underused systems by leasing capacity to virtual operators, which are typically highly focused, through differentiated handsets and content, on a specific consumer base.
The broadband wireless players are taking the same tack, with Earthlink, Clearwire and others building networks that will then be leased to WISPs. The Bell operators need to look at the same model ‘ not grudgingly allowing rivals on to their access systems and charging inflated fees for the privilege, as they have to date, but seeing this as a way to generate higher value from their infrastructure build-out while reducing their cost of customer acquisition and their sensitivity to revenue seepage to the internet applications.
A larger AT&T will undoubtedly prompt reaction from Verizon and the cablecos. The latter, like the satellite broadcasters, are increasingly eyeing partnerships with broadband wireless and cellular network owners to bring interactive and wireless facilities to their core offerings. Since most of the cellcos are controlled by Verizon and AT&T, this puts Sprint Nextel in the pivotal role in terms of building a defense against the RBOCs, and also opens promising opportunities for Clearwire, EarthLink and others investing in Wi-Fi and pre-WiMAX networks.
A united and therefore more competitive Cingular will certainly push Verizon to step up talks with Vodafone about buying the UK company out of their Verizon Wireless joint venture, a major growth engine (though another smart move could be for the two partners to merge themselves ‘ see separate item). Verizon could also boost its wireless arm by purchasing Alltel, the largest regional wireless operator in the US, which has a market value around $25bn and competes with Cingular in many regions.
Qwest, increasingly the dwarf among the Bells and with no wireless arm, could also become a target for AT&T since it would complete its geographic footprint, and has a market cap of only about $12bn. Qwest has been experimenting with WiMAX and other technologies that could give it the ability to expand its footprint and offer fixed/wireless convergence. However, since it lost its bid to acquire MCI (to Verizon), it has looked more unattractive, especially with its heavy debt load, and any potential acquirer could wait for it to lose further value. Qwest is looking to diversification for survival. CEO Richard Notebaert said recently that he might consider acquiring, for example, an IT firm or corporate web hosting firm, in order to sell more services to businesses rather than staying focused only on telecoms. Another option could be to acquire a cable company.
More interesting will be the reaction of the cablecos, which could well start on their own round of consolidation. Time Warner, the second largest US cable operator, will share Adelphia’s 4m subscribers with Comcast later this year as part of a deal that is widely expected to be the precursor for future acquisitions, possibly of Cablevision or recently privatized Insight Communications.
The cable industry, whose major players already have a joint venture with Sprint Nextel and which have considered launching wireless services under a common brand, is now looking further towards wireless integration with an initiative called CableRoam.
According to documents from cable trade group, CableLabs, the initiative would allow the industry to offer wireless broadband and wireless VoIP over various technologies such as municipal Wi-Fi meshes, WiMAX and home-based wireless networks. CableLab’s director of advanced digital technologies, Peter MacCormack, confirmed that the trade group is exploring the new initiative, but that no final plans had been made regarding its fruition.
‘Whatever technology we specify in the future, we want to make sure that all of these wireless architectures can work together in the most efficient and cost-effective manner,’ he said.
Whatever the original network, this will be the key goal of all service providers as the US market consolidates. Combining different new and old technologies in order to generate maximum value and most efficient cost of delivery from the system as a whole will be the key to success, as well as using a multi-technology network to deliver richer and more targeted applications. The Bell companies may find their huge investments in fiber put them at a disadvantage in some business models compared to more agile players armed with low cost wireless build-outs, or combinations of cable and wireless with attractive internet content partners. Acquiring BellSouth will give AT&T increased scale, but it could also double the risks that it faces in the access world, and this could drive it back to a wholesale model to generate the greatest value from its core asset, its DSL/fiber infrastructure.
THE DEAL
Post-merger, the AT&T territory would extend from California to Florida, north to Illinois and south to Texas. Combining the two companies’ current market capitalizations, AT&T would have a market value approaching $150bn, over 50% greater than Verizon’s.
This would be the largest in a string of acquisitions since Ed Whitacre took the helm at SBC (now AT&T). These also include Pacific Telesis, Ameritech and Southern New England Telecommunications.
It is possible that this latest merger plan would face greater regulatory opposition than the great deals of the past two years – Verizon-MCI, Sprint-Nextel, Cingular-AT&T Wireless and SBC-AT&T. Recent comments by AT&T and BellSouth executives about introducing higher charges for internet content providers have raised concerns about open access for consumers to all internet sites. And the addition of Robert McDowell to the FCC may make it a tougher place for the Bellcos – a veteran telecom lawyer, he currently serves as assistant general counsel at Comptel, which represents smaller telephone companies and was a vocal opponent of the AT&T and Verizon mergers last year.
Under the terms of the proposed deal, shareholders of BellSouth will receive 1.325 shares of AT&T common stock for each BellSouth common share. Based on AT&T’s closing stock price on March 3, that equals $37.09 a BellSouth common share, or nearly an 18% premium over BellSouth’s closing stock price. The total equity consideration is valued at about $67bn.
Whitacre will serve as chairman and CEO of the new company. His contract expires in November when he turns 65, but AT&T said the board asked him to stay on until March 2008 to shepherd the acquisition and he agreed to do so. BellSouth’s chief Ackerman will stay for a short time until his own retirement.