Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

29 November 2012

Big guns in wireless patents roused from slumber

The wireless patent war which has dominated headlines this year has been mainly focused on the technologies which crept into the mobile world in the middle of the last decade and rewrote all the rules ‘ IPR connected to software, user interfaces and design. That is unsurprising, given that the patents battles are just an aspect of the Apple-Google fight to control the mobile experience. But inevitably, the war between Apple and Android has inflated the value of most wireless patents, including those which underpin less visible, but still fundamental, technologies in the handset. The traditional wireless giants, which still own the bulk of this essential IPR, are also under huge commercial pressure, so they are starting to become far more aggressive in looking for revenues from their patent mountains.

Holders of standards-essential patents are more constrained in how they can charge for their IPR, which is governed by Frand (fair reasonable and non-discriminatory) guidelines (though the definition of this is one of the issues being disputed in many cases, and by standards bodies and governments). But their patents are usually impossible to avoid in implementing core technologies like Wi-Fi, CDMA or LTE, and firms like Nokia and Ericsson have a major advantage over the newcomers in this particular respect. The gorilla of the mobile IPR business model, Qualcomm, has not entered into the fray as yet, probably because it has all the licensing deals it needs and because many of the antagonists are also its customers. But the others are increasingly on the move, and anyone who doubts their ability to shift the IPR balance of power again should remember the relative ease with which Nokia won a lucrative settlement out of Apple when the two firms agreed an end to litigation last year.

Apart from that signal triumph, Nokia has not figured prominently in the handset patent wars, perhaps because that Apple win, at the start of the current wave of lawsuits, may have scared off other would-be attackers. However, the Finnish firm has stated its intention of making more money from its patents, and pursuing royalties more aggressively. Earlier this year it filed suit against RIM, HTC and Viewsonic, in the US and Germany, and it is now requesting a California court to enforce a product ban on RIM offerings supporting Wi-Fi.

Nokia’s claim followed a nine-day arbitration process between the two rivals, seeking to settle a dispute over 802.11 patents. This took place in September in Sweden, whose Stockholm Chamber of Commerce acted as a neutral party. That process threw up various conclusions, including one that RIM was ‘not entitled to manufacture or sell products compatible with the WLAN standard without first agreeing with Nokia on the royalty to be paid for its manufacture and/or sale of subscriber terminals compatible with such standards’.

Most of RIM’s devices, of course, implement 802.11 Wi-Fi, in which Nokia claims essential IPR. The Finnish vendor now wants the US court to enforce that arbitration ruling by preventing RIM from making or selling the offending gadgets, until royalties are agreed.

According to IDG, which obtained a copy of of the court filing, such a request is made only when two parties have agreed to arbitration, but then one side does not fulfil the resulting agreement. Nokia’s document says that, when companies enter arbitration with the Stockholm Chamber of Commerce, they agree that any decision will be ‘final and binding on the parties’ and the loser should ‘carry out any award without delay’. It added: ‘RIM and its US subsidiary nevertheless continue to violate the award and breach the underlying agreement.’

Both Nokia and RIM declined to comment.

Nokia’s action has its roots in a cross-licensing agreement it signed with RIM back in 2003, which was amended in 2008. In 2011, RIM went to arbitration, arguing that the licence extended beyond cellular essentials, but the tribunal disagreed and supported Nokia’s claim that the BlackBerry maker was in breach of contract.’

Nokia and RIM are also engaged in a separate battle over the former’s US and German lawsuits, which cite 45 patents and also target HTC and Viewsonic. These Nokia patents relate to many aspects of the smartphone user experience including app stores, multitasking, navigation, conversational message display, dynamic menus, data encryption and retrieval of email attachments. Unlike the other action, most of these patents are not standards-essential but ‘ like most of the IPR with which Apple is attacking rivals ‘ relates to software and user interface. This means these patents are not governed by Frand (fair reasonable and non-discriminatory) licensing rules.

Nokia’s arch-rival Samsung is also a major standards-essential patents holder, though its main IPR base is in newer systems like LTE. However, as one of the traditional mobile players which has successfully transitioned to the new smartphone age, it is a target for just about everyone. While its battle with Apple drags on, it has now been hit by a suit from another of the 3GPP standards IPR giants, Ericsson. The Swedish firm, which like Nokia has said it plans to pursue revenues from its intellectual property mountain more aggressively, claims almost two years of negotiations with Samsung have failed to end in agreement. Samsung previously licensed Ericsson’s patents in 2001 and renewed in 2007, but the latter says that further renewal talks failed although it offered Frand terms.

The GSM and UMTS standards were dominated by Ericsson, Qualcomm and a few others, giving those firms a market advantage, especially in bartering over cross-licensing deals with competitors. Those companies remain major holders of patents essential to LTE, but the shift to an OFDM technology has weighted the IPR balance further towards Asia, in particular Samsung and the Chinese majors. Samsung may have felt it could push for a better deal in the new rounds of licensing talks with Ericsson, since it has more essential IPR of its own to trade.

Whatever the background, Ericsson is on the offensive, though it will be looking for recognition and revenues from its patents, rather than to cripple a rival, Apple-style. Last year it filed suit against another rising Asian IPR powerhouse, ZTE, but the two firms came to agreement in January. The latest dispute covers patented technology which is essential to several telecoms and networking standards used by Samsung’s products, said the Swedish giant’s statement, as well as other Ericsson patents.

‘Ericsson has over 30,000 patents and more than 100 licence agreements with all major players in the industry. Ericsson has tried long and hard to amicably come to an agreement with Samsung and to sign a licence agreement on Frand terms. We have turned to litigation as a last resort,’ said Kasim Alfalahi, chief intellectual property officer at Ericsson, in a statement. The complaint was filed in the District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, the district where Ericsson’s US headquarters is located.

Samsung hit back at the lawsuit, claiming Ericsson demanded that it pay ‘significantly higher royalty rates’. ‘We have faithfully committed ourselves to conducting fair and reasonable negotiations with Ericsson over the past two years, but this time Ericsson has demanded significantly higher royalty rates for the same patent portfolio,’ a spokesperson told TotalTelecom. He added: ‘We cannot accept such extreme demands. We will take all necessary legal measures to protect against Ericsson’s excessive claims.’

A year ago, Ericsson told shareholders of its intention to monetize its huge patent portfolio more effectively, a strategy also being pursued by other equipment majors facing a squeeze on product revenues, such as Alcatel-Lucent. At that point, Alfalahi was in effect promoted, reporting directly to CEO Hans Vestberg rather than to the CTO and charged with the new IPR activities. Ericsson says it is a net receiver of royalties but aims to boost those revenues above the SEK4.6bn level generated in 2010.

Similar moves have been seen at Alcatel-Lucent, which has a separate subsidiary for managing some of its patents, and has recently been looking to sell off others to generate cash. It also aims to pursue revenues more aggressively and on Tuesday, it came to court in California to pursue claims against Apple and LG.

The patent infringement claims date back to December 2010, when a subsidiary of ALU, Multimedia Patent Trust, sued the two handset makers for allegedly violating patents covering video compression technology, which allows for more efficient multimedia storage and transmission. On Apple’s front, ALU is attacking the QuickTime video system, which is included in most of the firm’s devices, including the iPhone, iPad, iPod Touch, MacBook and iMac. It is alleging violation of three patents. ALU also cites nine LG handsets with built-in video software and a Qualcomm chip, as infringing two patents.

Many such cases never get to trial, but Multimedia Patent Trust is no stranger to pushing its claims as far as the courtroom. It is most famous for successfully suing Microsoft in 2007, getting a $1.5bn jury verdict, though that was later overturned, leading to a settlement in January of an almost decade-long fight.

In these mobile cases, the ALU unit wants ‘reasonable royalties’, plus damages based on the date it says the firms could have negotiated a licensing deal ‘ it says that is March 2005 for Apple and June 2009 for LG, according to jury instructions filed on Monday and reported by Bloomberg. According to filings with the court in San Diego, a financial expert the ALU unit estimated that licensing negotiations could have resulted in Apple paying a $195.9m royalty and LG a $9.1m fee. However, US District Judge Marilyn Huff has ruled that some of the economic assumptions made by the expert were wrong and the calculations must be adjusted.

Both smartphone makers have rejected the claims and also pointed out that the technology is only a small element of products which contain many hardware and software components.

Samsung/Apple latest:

Samsung is on an aggressive streak in its patent war with Apple. It has publicly said it has no interest in negotiating with the iPhone maker ‘ but has won access to the terms of the Apple-HTC settlement, so if it changes its mind, it will know the frame of reference. No sign of that yet though ‘ the Korean firm, tipped by one analyst to top 60m smartphone sales this quarter ‘ has expanded one of its lawsuits to cover Apple’s latest iPad and iPod models.

The new devices are the iPad Mini, the recently upgraded fourth generation large-screen iPad, and the fifth generation iPod Touch. Samsung has asked a federal district court to add these gadgets to an existing lawsuit, which targets older versions. The new claims focus on the same patent as the original ones. The filing states that ‘all Apple products including a built-in speaker and an external audio output port’ infringe this patent. Samsung had previously moved to add the iPhone 5 to the case, and the court agreed to that on November 15, so these new amendments are likely to be accepted too.

It is important to vendors that they can add newer models to their cases to maximize commercial risks to their antagonists ‘ the slow pace of the litigation process is mismatched with the rapid product launch cycle, and by the time judgements are made, they can affect only obsolete devices.

Apple then hit back at Samsung’s latest filings, adding several more of its rival’s devices to its US hitlist. It wants to include the Galaxy Note2, the Galaxy S3 with Android 4.1, and the Galaxy S3 Mini, claiming they all infringe the same patents already cited in its federal case.

This tit-for-tat case may not be heard until 2014. It is in the same court as the one that handed down the landmark $1bn damages judgement against Samsung, which is now under appeal. However, it is a separate case, focusing mainly on software and user interface patents, rather than design patents, which were controversially at the heart of the former fight. The shift to software IPR could bring Android leader Google more directly into the fray. Its own handset arm, Motorola Mobility, is the other major handset maker still standing out against Apple (and Microsoft) in Android related patent cases. This case is being overseen by US Magistrate Judge Paul Grewal in the federal court in San Jose, California.

Over the water, a Dutch court ruled in Apple’s favor on Wednesday, ordering the ban of certain Galaxy models ‘ older products which use an Apple-patented method for scrolling through images in a photo gallery using a touchscreen. According to the court, the gadgets included in the judgement are any Galaxy versions 2.2.1 and higher but without Samsung’s updated ‘blue flash’ gallery technology. Samsung must pay Apple €100,000 euros each day it violates the ruling and must disclose how much profit it has made from the infringing products since late June 2011. That will be the basis of a later ruling on what percentage of that profit Apple should receive.

Last month, another Dutch court ruled that Samsung did not violate another Apple patent, on pinch-to-zoom features.