In the latest war of words between Broadcom and Qualcomm, the former has called on the Bush administration to let stand an International Trade Commission (ITC) ruling against Qualcomm for infringing a Broadcom power management patent.
“A presidential veto would weaken US efforts to strengthen intellectual property rights globally,” said Broadcom’s general counsel, David Dull, in a statement. “Overturning the ITC’s remedy for Qualcomm’s patent infringement would ultimately make it more difficult for US companies to defend their IP rights and complicate the administration’s IP policy initiatives.”
President George Bush has designated US Trade Representative Susan Schwab to review the ITC injunction, which threatens to ban imports of new handsets based on Qualcomm 3G chipsets, and decide whether to allow the ITC order to stand or to disapprove it. The 60-day presidential review period ends on August 6.
The companies continued to snipe behind the scenes, especially about a settlement offer of $6 per handset, made by Broadcom (see Wireless Watch July 2 2007). ‘For a long time we’ve said that their goal is to destroy our business,’ said Bill Davidson, a Qualcomm VP for global marketing and investor relations, in an interview with RCRnews. ‘The offer they made showed this. It was absolutely ridiculous. [The offer] made clear that there’s little chance for a settlement.’
‘Qualcomm has not offered one penny for the right to use the ‘983’ patent [cited in the ITC case] in their cellphones,’ retorted David Rosmann, a Broadcom VP for IP litigation, who claimed a $100m flat fee counter-offer from Qualcomm was not new, but came from earlier negotiations.