Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 May 2015

Cars, not smartphones, must drive 5G thinking

One of the essentials to make 5G a success will be to adopt different starting points when considering real world requirements. Futuristic devices, notably autonomous cars, may be far more useful in defining next-generation standards than smartphones or even embedded IoT devices, argue many stakeholders, because their network usage patterns are so different.

Huawei director Ryan Ding believes the control of self-driving vehicles must be a key element of the 5G platform, since this will push requirements for low latency, high speed, real time management and peak reliability to the limit.

Ding said, in an interview with Global Telecoms Business, that a car going at 60 miles per hour will cover about one inch per millisecond, and the wireless system cannot lose sight of a single inch, if danger is to be avoided. For vehicle-to-vehicle (V2V) and vehicle-to-infrastructure (V2I) communications, latency will need to be reduced from the 10 milliseconds envisaged for the next wave of LTE, particularly the IoT-focused LTE-MTC specifications. That latency level will work for connected but human-driven vehicles, but fully autonomous cars will need 1ms, as well as data rates up to 10Gbps. Current LTE latency is about 140ms, suitable for humans but not for many always-on things.

And of course, the network will need to be designed to support far larger numbers of end points – up to 100 billion is Huawei’s ‘big figure’, up from about 30bn which may be connected around 2018 by ‘4.5G’. This is Huawei’s marketing term for the LTE-based standards emerging for the IoT, not just MTC but the so-called ‘clean slate’ platform, Cellular IoT. The Chinese company hopes to spearhead this around the low power connectivity technology it acquired with Neul, and has Vodafone’s support for its project. Ding said the company is already working with a large auto manufacturer on M2M technology, and they are “still discussing whether we should announce it”.

Huawei is determined to play a prominent role in LTE-based M2M platforms as well as in 5G, to increase its influence over standards, patents and resulting commercial products. At the formation, last week, of the ITU’s new focus group on 5G network standardization requirements, Wen Tong, head of 5G R&D at Huawei, said: “5G will power a wide range of new user experiences, but the bottleneck remains the speed of the network. Everyone in the ICT ecosystem needs to work together. This is the most important condition for us to realize 5G.”

Before the industry can develop systems for self-driving vehicles, it needs to sort out some far shorter term issues of technology and spectrum. One important argument concerns the upper 5.9 GHz band, earmarked in the US for DSRC (dedicated short range communications), which the FCC wants to open up for WiFi too.

The car industry is pitched against the broadband business in this area, as Congress seeks to pass a reworked ‘WiFi Innovation Act’. This would pave the way to open up the higher end of the 5 GHz band (5850-5925 MHz) for unlicensed broadband technologies like WiFi. However, the 5.9 GHz band is already the home of ITS (intelligent transportation systems) for car safety. The FCC allocated the 75 MHz of spectrum for DSRC – an ITS technology that supports direct V2V and vehicle/infrastructure (V2I) communications – back in 1999 but carmakers have only recently started to plan commercial deployment. Some countries, notably Japan, have been implementing DSRC-type systems since 2009.

The Act was introduced in February in the Senate and is supported by a companion bill in the House of Representatives. The legislation, originally proposed last summer, has been modified but has the same goal – to get the FCC to test the feasibility of opening up this new bandwidth for WiFi. However, carmakers are concerned about possible interference with vehicle safety systems, which are seeing rapid uptake.

Moves towards an accommodation are being led by Cisco, which is working with the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers (AAM) and the Association of Global Automakers (AGA) to initiate tests of a ‘listen, detect and avoid’ protocol, designed to avoid WiFi interfering with car safety transmissions in the 5.9 GHz band.

The aim is to provide the FCC with empirical evidence to determine whether the protocol would be sufficient to support licence-exempt WiFi use without a detrimental effect on incumbent DSRC operations. The tests are developmental and would be based around a Cisco-proposed technology. Testing will start in the coming weeks in labs and then move onto field trials, with the first round of feasibility testing to be completed by the end of the year, according to an FCC filing.

The timeline must not slip – General Motors has committed to deploying DSRC vehicle-to-vehicle (V2V) technology in its Cadillac CTS vehicles from 2016, notes the filing.