Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 February 2006

Cellcos assemble mobile answer to PC internet experience

If you can’t beat ’em, join ’em ‘ Vodafone is heading the list of major mobile operators embracing the major players from the PC/internet world that have threatened to disrupt the conventional cellular business model. Companies like Google, Skype/eBay, Microsoft and Yahoo have promised a full PC experience ‘ complete with open internet access and flat rate pricing ‘ on mobile devices, and have thrown down the gauntlet to cellcos reluctant to give up their walled gardens and complex tariffs. The cellcos are responding as they did with Wi-Fi hotspots ‘ faced with the prospect of Google or Microsoft promoting, and even building, networks out of the control of the licensed operators, they are acting quickly to neutralize the threat. This will entail often unwelcome changes to their models and margins, but at least it will keep the mobile internet world under cellco control.

Vodafone, then, used the 3GSM event to announce alliances with Google and Microsoft, and to outline ways that it can fend off third party VoIP; while Hutchison cosied up with Skype and Microsoft bolstered its own mobile search arsenal. Several large operators teamed to make their instant messaging interoperable and so steal a march on PC-based solutions, while Nokia hedged its bets with an increasing focus on VoIP that could open it up to a new breed of customers, or enable it to address the cellcos’ grudging internet telephony plans.

Search is one area where the mobile internet experience has suffered by comparison with that on the laptop. Vodafone is seeking to increase its share of users’ online minutes by teaming with Google to create new mobile services. Often portrayed as an enemy to the cellcos because of its interest in municipal networks to expand usage of its software ‘ and its advertising revenues ‘ Google is in fact agnostic to the platform, as long as internet searching increases. Vodafone will integrate Google’s capability into its consumer service, Vodafone Live!, providing simultaneous search both on Live! and the wider web.

Also on the search front, Microsoft acquired Motion Bridge of France ‘ which numbers T-Mobile, O2 and Orange among its customers – to enhance its own mobile capabilities in this area, but it was Vodafone again that provided the more important boost to the software giant’s mobile plans, adopting Microsoft’s new push email platform, as did T-Mobile and Cingular. The push email market is vital for any operator looking to play in the large and small enterprise sector, since this is usually the first application adopted in a mobile enterprise strategy. Service providers like Vodafone are keen to ensure that they are the key supplier of email, rather than a vendor like Nokia, and the world’s largest cellco already has deals with other software houses such as Visto in this arena. But the Microsoft agreement is significant because it shows an increased willingness by Vodafone to endorse Windows Mobile as a business smartphone platform ‘ it once said it would not support the operating system, and Microsoft has struggled for recognition among the largest carriers.

In another blow for RIM BlackBerry, Vodafone and Microsoft will collaborate to develop and launch Windows Mobile Email from Vodafone in Europe. This is based on Windows Mobile 5.0 and incorporates the Messaging and Security Feature Pack, which includes Direct Push Technology and enhanced security features. Vodafone will target the offering at small and medium businesses, initially in the UK, France and Germany.
Carriers are far more ambivalent about VoIP than mobile email, since circuit switched voice remains the vast bulk of their business. Some operators are embracing VoIP and its associated flat pricing in a bid for market share, the latest being Hutchison, which has signed an agreement with Skype. Hutchison’s European mobile divisions will start bundling Skype’s new client for Microsoft Windows Mobile 5.0 with a range of its high end smartphones and flat rate data tariffs. The move marks the first time that a major world carrier has taken the plunge and encouraged third party VoIP usage.

Vodafone, by contrast, believes it can beat VoIP at its own game by taking advantage of the extreme cost efficiency of circuit switched voice delivered over the 3G network to offer flat rate, low cost services while eating into, but not decimating, its margins ‘ something it is already doing in Germany with its cheap homezone tariff. Also, Vodafone CEO Arun Sarin told the 3GSM attendees that the company would look to offer large mobile data bundles in the future to counter the potential threat from VoIP. He said: “As an industry we will morph into the VoIP space over time.”

Finally, instant messaging is also seen as a key consumer and enterprise internet application and the cellcos are keen to take a slice of this pie too, by making their fledgling offerings more attractive through interoperability and aiming to make them as pervasive as the huge revenue generator, SMS. Vodafone, China Mobile, Telefonica Moviles, Orange and T-Mobile International are among the 15 operators trying to create a parallel value stream to their lucrative SMS businesses with seamless PC-style IM.

Whether mobile VoIP becomes dominated by the cellular operators or remains a challenge to them, Nokia is convinced it will drive increasing device sales and is determined to address either customer base. It has already been the most aggressive of the handset makers in announcing IP handsets, even some without any cellular radio, despite the potential threat to its core customer base. At 3GSM, Nokia introduced its 6136 phone with Unlicensed Mobile Access technology for Wi-Fi/cellular convergence and its increasing interest in VoIP will accelerate the shift of large volumes of voice traffic from traditional cellular networks and put further pressure on mobile voice tariffs. Nokia’s CEO Jorma Ollila told the 3GSM conference that “internet voice is going mobile’ and would support lower voice fees for consumers and businesses. Hardly a welcome message for the cellcos on which Nokia is increasingly keen to reduce its dependence.