Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 November 2012

Charges hit results at Vodafone and DT, hiding strong data growth

Impairment charges and writedowns on troublesome subsidiaries hit the results of two European giants, Deutsche Telekom and Vodafone, as both continued to grapple with the eurozone criss despite good growth in data services.

The German giant posted a net loss of €6.9bn in the third quarter, blaming a massive €7.4bn impairment charge at T-Mobile USA, which disguised some more positive underlying signs.

CEO Rene Obermann said in his statement: ‘Anyone seeing only the clear net loss is overlooking the fact that our operating business is completely on track. Unlike many of our competitors, we offer reliability.’

The charge relates to the planned acquisition of regional US cellco MetroPCS, as required under IFRS accounting standards. Excluding that charge, Deutsche Telekom saw net profit fall by 28.3% year-on-year to €0.9bn. The telco claims that, on a like-for-like basis, its adjusted net profit was ‘stable’ (last year’s figure was inflated by factors associated with the failed plan to be acquired by AT&T last year).

While the US arm continues to introduce instability to DT’s performance, group revenue was flat compared to the 2011 quarter, at €14.7bn, while adjusted EBITDA was down 2.6% to €4.8bn. Free cashflow increased by 37.4% to reach €2.3bn.

Over the water, T-Mobile’s organic performance was a ‘mixed bag’, said DT. It did add 160,000 net new customers in the quarter, but all the growth came from the low value prepaid sector, while the operator lost 492,000 contract customers. The latter figure ‘was better than in the second quarter, but is still unsatisfactory,’ said the firm.

It put some of the blame for the swing to pay-as-you-go on consumer anticipation of the iPhone 5 launch ‘ on other carriers’ networks. TMo is migrating her 3G network from the oddball AWS spectrum to PCS, which will allow it to obtain its own iPhone at last, and it is already supporting unlocked Apple devices in regions where it has made the change. It will then deploy LTE in the vacated band, in line with Verizon’s and AT&T’s plans to use their AWS spectrum for 4G.

Having an iPhone will only make a difference if TMo has a differentiated offering on the device, in terms of price, quality and/or services. Its recent track record suggests it is most likely to major on price, certainly until it catches up with competitors in LTE build-out. Even with additional spectrum assuming the MetroPCS deal goes through next month, it is unlikely to be rivalling Verizon’s LTE until 2014 at the earliest. And the purchase of a flat rate carrier will only intensify the shift to prepaid ‘ with its low margins and high churn rates ‘ as the bedrock of TMo’s business.

In fact, churn increased by 2.3% in the quarter. DT’s US subsidiary reported a 5.9% year-on-year decrease in revenue to $4.9bn and adjusted EBITDA down 14.2% to $1.2bn, impacted by higher spending on advertising.

In Germany, DT suffered a 1.3% fall in revenue to €5.7bn and adjusted EBITDA dropped by 2.5% to €2.4bn. Within that, mobile revenues slid by 0.5%, a better pattern than in recent prior quarters. ‘This is the first sign of success on the way to winning back market leadership in mobile service revenues,’ the company said in a statement.

Deutsche Telekom made €2bn worth of debt repayments in Q3, reducing its net debt by more than 10% year-on-year to €39bn ‘ slashing debt dominates the priorities of the large European telcos amid the eurozone crisis, which has restricted access to credit. The firm said that, despite that crisis, it is able to access the bond markets ‘at very favourable conditions’ as a result of its solid balance sheet and stable performance. Despite the debt reduction program, capex in the quarter was up by 1% year-on-year to €2.2bn.

Meanwhile, Vodafone fell into a first half loss after a huge writedown of £5.9bn ($9.38bn) on its southern European units, as the eurozone crisis continues to weigh on its performance.

The UK-based multinational took the writedown on the value of its Spanish and Italian subsidiaries, as it reported a pre-tax loss of £492m for the six months to September 30, reversing a year-ago profit of £8bn.

However, shareholders were delighted by news that they would receive a dividend from the Verizon Wireless joint venture, in which Vodafone has a 45% stake. The JV will pay out $8.5bn (£5.4bn) to its two owners by the end of the year, its second dividend this year, following one of $10bn in January. For several years, Vodafone shareholders have become increasingly angry at the refusal of Verizon Wireless to pay dividends, as it reserved its cash to pay off debt and invest in expansion. Vodafone expects to receive £2.4bn of the total and will use part of it to start a £1.5bn share buyback program.

However, such consolations could not detract from the crisis in southern Europe, and CEO
Vittorio Colao said: ‘Our results reflect tougher market conditions, mainly in southern Europe’, which places a heavier burden on growth in emerging markets. Colao was cautiously bullish about this objective though, pointing to the group’s ‘attractive and growing exposure to emerging markets’, such as India and Turkey.

And the poor results were not entirely down to the writedowns ‘ overall organic revenue also slid while net debt rose. Much of this was also blamed on southern Europe though ‘ in that region, revenue fell by 17.5%, including an 8.2% decline due to the euro weakening against the pound. The economic crisis is intensifying price competition and in Spain, Vodafone lost customers after a failed attempt to axe handset subsidies. However, it did see improved revenue from data services, even in Spain and Italy, as the user base shifts towards smartphones.

Organic service revenues were down 0.4% year-on-year overall, because of a 9.8% drop in the southern Europe division, while the northern Europe unit delivered growth of 1.5% and the emerging markets organization grew by 5.2%. In the second quarter, service revenue decline was somewhat worse, at 1.4%, with southern Europe down by 11.3% and lower growth in the other regions. EBITDA for the group fell by 2.9% to £6.6bn in the first half though adjusted operating profit was up 8.5% to £6.2bn. Group revenue was up 0.2% to £21.78bn on an organic basis.

Vodafone said it saw continued strong growth in data revenue, up13.7%, and emerging markets, especially India, which in Q2 delivered growth of 11%, Turkey, up 18% in the quarter, and the Vodacom venture in South Africa, up 4.6%. In Europe, smartphone penetration is now 30.7%, with 45.5% of European mobile service revenues now in-bundle. Although the enterprise unit saw revenue decline slightly (by 0.4%), there was ‘strong growth’ in Vodafone Global Enterprise, M2M and Vodafone One Net, ‘offset by macroeconomic challenges in country level enterprise units’. Vodafone is engaged in a cost reduction program and says it is targeting £300m in opex cuts in Europe during the 2014 financial year.