Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 May 2008

China and India gear up for 3G at last, and foreign firms poised to cash in

The two highest growth mobile markets, India and China, could both issue 3G licenses within a year, creating a huge opportunity for equipment makers and, depending on government decisions, for external operators. China has published its long awaited plan for restructuring its telecoms industry, creating three converged carriers in place of the current two mobile and two fixed majors. Each will gain a 3G license, which the government says will be issued once the restructuring is complete, which is likely to be around the turn of the year. Meanwhile, India’s 3G and mobile broadband auctions are slated for later this year, but are still being delayed by political battles over whether non-Indian companies should be allowed to bid.

As expected, the new-look Chinese telecoms sector will involve the merger of China Mobile with China TieTong Telecoms (formerly China Railcom); and the division of cellco China Unicom between the two fixed line operators, with its CDMA assets going to China Telecom and its GSM business to China Netcom. China Telecom could pay anything between $5bn and $10bn for the Unicom CDMA assets but will gain a 3G license ‘ with which it is widely expected to deploy TD-SCDMA or W-CDMA, not CDMA2000, given the apparently limited future lifespan for the CDMA family. China Mobile’s share price was hit by the new competition from two converged players, which should be more powerful than the old challenge from second placed cellco Unicom.

At least one of the three national carriers will deploy the homegrown TD-SCDMA technology, in a 3G roll-out that could be worth, across all three operators, $75bn over the next few years. Even if full licenses have not been awarded in time for the Beijing Olympic Games, there will be early stage TD-SCDMA networks in place in the capital for the event, though of course these will be unusable by most visitors, especially from abroad. Chinese vendors Huawei and ZTE will be looking for a windfall, but all the equipment majors have formed partnerships with Chinese companies and invested in R&D in TD-SCDMA, as well as pushing the international platforms, to try to gain a portion of the Chinese 3G spend.

Over in India, the mobile world is waiting eagerly for auctions of 3G and mobile broadband spectrum, due to be held in parallel this year. This could potentially support ambitious 3G/4G roll-outs that could help the vast country make a significant move towards data services and broadband, riding on the back of its massive growth in GSM usage, and starting to counterbalance its woefully low penetration of fixed telephone and broadband lines.

But there are always huge amounts of politicking and bureaucracy between the telecoms visions that Indian authorities undoubtedly have, and the auctions and rulings that will make these a reality. So last week, the Minister of Communications and Technology, A Raja, said the government would announce plans for rolling out 3G with the next two months, but could not throw light on one critical issue to the world’s carriers, whether the auction will be open to external bidders. Operators like AT&T have already expressed strong interest, should this be the case.

Raja told a news conference: “We are creating a framework for the mobile wireless policy and at the same time trying to simplify the spectrum issue. We are in an advanced stage of discussions with representatives from the Department of Telecom, TRAI (the regulator), finance, commerce and the IT ministries as to whether the auction should be open to global bidders or restricted to existing Indian operators.” This issue has been rumbling around for two years, since TRAI decided spectrum should be auctioned rather than given away in a beauty contest.

The regulator, which engages in regular political battles with the government department, wants to limit auctions to national carriers in order to avoid a global bidding war, but the government favors opening the sale up, both to encourage new competition and services in India and to raise more revenue. The finance ministry backs foreign bidding as long as the operators meet eligibility criteria and foreign direct investment guidelines. New international bidders would have to form joint ventures with Indian partners. Previous Indian spectrum auctions in 1995 and 2001 were open to international bidders.

While they wait for 3G and beyond, the cellcos are busily expanding their GSM networks to meet burgeoning consumer demand. BSNL, the state-controlled carrier, recently invited a new round of bids for a huge contract, after Nokia Siemens walked away from its share of the deal late last year, because it had been undercut by Ericsson (under pressure from the Indian government to reduce BSNL costs) to the extent it no longer believed the deal would be profitable. Ericsson then declined to take up the NSN shortfall at that price. Such is the urgency to increase GSM capacity that BSNL has awarded a $90m ‘stopgap’ contract to Motorola to tide it over while it waits to award the new deals. It already has a similar deal with Nortel, which will instal two million lines by year end, while Motorola will provide 2.3m lines in the southern region. The Ericsson portion of the original contract is for 13.5m lines, while BSNL requires at least another $27m to complete the expansion project that has been delayed by the Nokia Siemens pull-out (though NSN is still likely to rebid in the new round of negotiations). Motorola was disqualified in the first round for technical reasons (and took BSNL to court) and so will hope that its winning of an interim deal means it will have a better chance in the rebid.

BSNL has signed up a few hundred thousand new subscribers per month in recent times, which is dwarfed by million-plus additions by rivals like Bharti Airtel and Reliance, but this has been largely down to its shortage of capacity, especially in the south. As it starts to gain its new lines, BSNL claimed 1.89m adds in March, in a nationwide total of adds that exceeded 10m. But in April it fell back again to less than 500,000 adds. Its GSM network has capacity for 36m users, and it ended April with 36.68m. By contrast, Bharti added 2.4m in April to total 64.3m users.

The Indian government recently set BSNL a target of achieving 30% mobile market share by user numbers within the next five years, compared to its current share of 18.4%, just over half of Bharti’s.

The privately owned Indian cellcos are also in a state of turmoil as they position for 3G and beyond, as well as for GSM expansion, and they are also looking to boost margins and global influence through foreign ventures, even as external organizations look to partner with them for a share of the Indian market. Reliance Communications has been using WiMAX, submarine cable and other technologies to drive its ambitions to be a global services provider, and is now in talks with South Africa’s MTN, the biggest cellco in south-Saharan Africa, about possibly creating a $66bn telecoms group to focus on major emerging markets. This would be a major blow to the hopes of established western and Japanese mobile carriers to get early headstarts in emerging economies and expand their influence there. Reliance’s larger rival Bharti Airtel was in talks with MTN but pulled out at the weekend. MTN is valued at $38bn and Reliance at $28bn, but combined their valuation would be similar to that of NTT DoCoMo. Reliance Communications’ chairman Anil Ambani, one of India’s richest men, said a deal with MTN could “provide investors, customers and the people of both companies a global platform for exponential growth”. MTN had 68.2m subscribers as of March, compared with Reliance Communications’ 48m. MTN would be likely to take a 51% stake in a venture, and maintain its brand, whereas Bharti had wanted to take control of MTN and submerge its brand. Also, foreign holding in Reliance was considerably lower than in Bharti, a factor that was a possible roadblock for Bharti’s attempted deal. Foreign ownership of Indian telcos is capped at 74%, and Bharti is 30.5% owned by SingTel.

Videocon:

One of India’s new operators, Videocon, which gained its license in January, is set to begin rolling out its mobile network in mid-August. The company received licenses covering all 23 of India’s telecom circles, through its Datacom Solutions subsidiary. So far, Datacom has received spectrum in Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Orissa and Andhra Pradesh.

Venugopal Dhoot, chairman of Videocon Industries, says the new operator plans to begin offering services in the Chennai circle, which now comes under the Tamil Nadu license. He has a target of reaching 50m subscribers over the first five years. India had close to 270m wireless subscribers at the end of April, and the government expects operators to reach 500m customers by 2010.

Indian carriers are promoting shared network infrastructure to help them expand their mobile network coverage and boost revenues from leasing out tenancy on their mobile towers. Renting out infrastructure from other operators will allow Datacom to roll out its network more quickly than if it was building it from scratch.

Videocon has been approached by several overseas firms looking for a partnership or acquisition in India and Dhoot said the company has appointed Morgan Stanley as an advisor on possible deals. Possible partners include AT&T, Deutsche Telekom, Qatar Telecom, Batelco of Bahrain, Zain and Dubai’s Etisalat. Etisalat and Qatar Telecom (Qtel) have approached Videocon over the possibility of a mobile tie-up in India, Dhoot said in a Reuters report. The former has said it is willing to spend up to $4bn in the Indian market, by acquiring a company or a license. It is also in talks with small regional operator Spice Telecom, as well as other larger Indian players.

The main activity of the Videocon group is making consumer goods such as televisions and washing machines and it has ventured into mobile phones, planning to create own-branded devices to drive its carrier services. It has openly expressed interest in buying Motorola’s handset operations.