Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 February 2006

China eyes world market for TD-SCDMA but technology flawed even at home

With the stalemate in Chinese 3G approaching resolution, the country’s government remains committed to supporting its own flavour of 3G, TD-SCDMA, even though this approach has undoubtedly slowed roll-out of next generation mobile services in the country. China is seeking to create its own standards in many areas, in order to become more technologically self-sufficient and to reduce its royalty payments to the west, but it also aims to start to push its platforms abroad, and is eyeing markets where 3G has not yet been built out as potential territories for TD-SCDMA.

Romania is the first non-Chinese operator to test TD-SCDMA, and a broader geographical base would certainly improve the economics of the platform, attracting a wider choice of vendors, and their R&D budgets, to accelerate development of a network that has lagged severely behind its other 3G counterparts, W-CDMA and CDMA2000 EV-DO. Last month, China announced that TD-SCDMA was now certified as fit to be rolled out in 3G commercial networks, a likely signal that its regulator will soon set a date for 3G auctions. These have been delayed many times, partly to ensure that TD-SCDMA was ready for 3G deployments when they came.

It seems probable that some licenses will be reserved for the Chinese technology, though others will be offered in a technology neutral manner. Operators have been trialling W-CDMA, but these tests have now been ordered to be suspended until TD-SCDMA trials can take place, in the second quarter. The eventual auctioning of 3G, later this year, is likely to see China Unicom being broken up and three licenses being issued. Current thinking is that fixed line carrier China Telecom would get Unicom’s GSM network and combine it with a TD-SCDMA system, while the second fixed line carrier, China Netcom, would acquire Unicom’s CDMA network and also gain a 3G allocation, as would the largest wireless operator, China Mobile. Mobile could deploy W-CDMA, TD-SCDMA or both.

China Telecom would then be awarded the TD-SCDMA license first to give it a headstart, since the technology is immature and ‘doesn’t have an ecosystem of vendors and the economies of scale that W-CDMA and CDMA EV-DO offer,’ wrote analyst George Notter last week. Unicom has been scaling back its investment in CDMA, in particular, in anticipation of possible break-up. Its largest supplier is Lucent.

For all its international plans, the Chinese government is still hobbling its own operators by insisting on a single technology, just as other regions, even Europe, are accepting that neutrality is essential to enable operators to choose the best platform for their particular business model and terrain, and so to support the widest possible variety of services. For instance,

And TD-SCDMA lags two years or more behind W-CDMA, especially in the vital area of handset design. The technology – which is approved by the 3GPP standards body – combines old-style TDMA technology with time division duplexing (TDD), which allows for the use of unpaired spectrum. This is an advantage in areas where spectrum is in short supply or large areas need to be covered cost effectively and is one reason for the enthusiasm of the Chinese authorities. Other benefits of TD-SCDMA are a low cost base and a reputation for performing better than its rivals in dense urban areas. China has allocated 155MHz of frequency to develop and promote the standard.

However, despite these advantages, the results of trials so far have been disappointing, and some argue that there are other, more developed TDD technologies, with a clearer roadmap to the ‘3.9G’ network, LTE, which will converge the TDD and FDD systems anyway. For instance, Japan has allocated spectrum for TD-CDMA, the time division strand of the W-CDMA standard.

Chinese operators may be all but forced to adopt a technology with a difficult business model. According to a new report from ABI Research, adoption would be ‘just a first step for TD-SCDMA, even in China, the technology’s hometown’. Analyst Junmei He said: ‘Due to the high population of PHS service users among low end subscribers and the decreasing price of both GSM terminals and service prices, it will be challenging for TD-SCDMA to attract voice service subscribers. At the same time, it appears unlikely that TD-SCDMA can achieve quick success by offering high speed data services, because demand for such services will remain low in the short term.’ In particular, the new mobile operators ‘ China Telecom and China Netcom, which will have to use the Chinese platform ‘ will have to devise creative models to take on existing, smaller cellcos, which are still likely to be allowed to build out W-CDMA and CDMA2000.

International mobile operators will also be jostling to take advantage of the possible technical shackles that Telecom and Netcom will have in the short term by backing players with more developed networks. Vodafone, Telefonica, Hutchison, Deutsche Telekom and Telstra all have equity or strategic relationships in China and other players such as Craig McCaw are also active.

It seems, therefore, that China is determinedly committing to a compromise solution, at least for its national operators, in order to keep control of its own technological heritage. Of course, its market is large enough to attract the key vendors in its own right, but it is also keen to set TD-SCDMA alongside the other two 3G platforms as an international choice ‘ an outcome that could fragment the world communications picture even more than the second generation divide between GSM and CDMA, and even play into the hands of a currently harmonized alternative, WiMAX. However, Wang Jing, secretary of the TD-SCDMA Forum, says this is ‘not just a business for China, it is a business for the world’, with his eyes in particular on the African and smaller Asian economies that have not yet considered 3G, and where he claims the spectral efficiency and flexibility of the Chinese platform will be attractive for rural coverage and low income populations.

Whatever the international potential, the Chinese market is the key and the world’s vendors are scrabbling to take a position. The uncertainty over whether China would, after all, insist on TD-SCDMA has presented them with a dilemma over how far to invest in a platform that could either underpin 3G in the world’s largest potential market, or sink without trace.

The main western vendors taking an interest so far have been Siemens ‘ which was initially responsible for devising TD-SCDMA – Philips and Nortel, and more recently Alcatel. In June 2005, Nortel agreed to work with China Putian to research, develop and manufacture 3G equipment and products there, focusing on either T-SCDMA or W-CDMA. China Putian is a strong advocate of TD-SCDMA and has already worked with Nortel on field trials sponsored by the China Ministry of Information.

Siemens and Philips have already taken a risk on the eventual victory of this standard and earmarked large development budgets for it – €60m per year in Siemens’ case, in addition to the €150m it has already spent with its development partner Datang. In May 2003, Philips said it would not re-enter the CDMA chipset market, but would put its efforts into TD-SCDMA, arguing that, if it does take off in China, other countries will adopt it too.

The vendor most exposed by the uptake of TD-SCDMA is Qualcomm, since the Chinese authorities are insisting that their technology bypasses the US chip giant’s famous CDMA patents, a claim Qualcomm disputes ‘ but it could land in lengthy, expensive and highly politicized battles to try to enforce its claimed intellectual property. Its risk is doubled in China by the expected squeezing out of CDMA2000 equipment by W-CDMA and TD-SCDMA.