China gives with one hand and takes away with the other. This is certainly true in the WiMAX world this week, with the mighty economy confirming that WiMAX will play a role in the technology infrastructure for the Beijing Olympics, at the expense of homegrown alternatives; but raising opposition to the inclusion of WiMAX in the list of approved ITU IMT-200 standards for 3G systems.
This would enable 802.16 to compete for deployments in bands round the world reserved for 3G, against other already approved platforms such as W-CDMA, CDMA2000, NextWave’s UMTS-TDD and China’s own TD-SCDMA. Although the chances of TD-SCDMA succeeding anywhere outside China look slim ‘ with the possible exceptions of some politically motivated deployments in a few smaller east Asian or African states ‘ Chinese authorities continue to put heavy weight behind promoting it, even to the extent of hostility to possible challengers like WiMAX.
WiMAX was included in the list of IMT-2000 standards in June, at a meeting where the ITU provisionally allocated the technology to the 2.5-2.69GHz spectrum range, which is due to be auctioned in various parts of the world, notably western Europe, in the next couple of years. The main hurdle still to overcome is to pass non-interference tests with other networks approved for that range, in which case WiMAX would also stand a very good chance of approval for the ITU’s IMT-Advanced list, which in effect defines 4G standards. This will be decided at the World Radio Conference in Geneva this October.
However, Wan Yi, director of the wireless and mobile department at the China Communications Standards Association (CCSA), has said in a statement that approval of WiMAX as a 3G technology would ‘unbalance’ the mobile industry, and that is has been politically driven by the US government in a bid to promote a US-dominated platform in a sector where American vendors have not always held the reins.
He told China Comms: ‘3G technology sits on a triangle of W-CDMA, CDMA and TD-SCMDA, and WiMAX would have a big impact on this triangular structure. Major W-CDMA and CDMA vendors are all opposed to it.’ In fact, the main opposition predictably comes from the only two majors to remain entirely outside the WiMAX fold, Ericsson and Qualcomm.
The WiMAX community remains guardedly optimistic about making inroads in the complex Chinese market. The WiMAX Forum has been working with the Chinese Academy of Telecommunications Research (CATR) to commercialize the technology, but this is at a very early stage, and to date, the Ministry of Information Industry has not allocated spectrum for 802.16e, nor announced plans to do so (fixed WiMAX has been used in some deployments in 3.5GHz).
The main hope for WiMAX in the short term rests with China’s urgent need to turn the 2008 Beijing Olympics into a major showcase for its hi-tech and communications capabilities. This need will push the authorities to approve any system that can deliver impressive results, and so far TD-SCDMA has been disappointing, as have other homegrown technologies, such as mobile TV, that were originally earmarked for use at the Games.
Hence, China Mobile was last week authorized to build a WiMAX network for the Olympics, while China Netcom had its license to build a wireless broadband network in Beijing cancelled. Netcom had planned to use one of China’s own alternatives to WiMAX, McWiLL (Multicarrier Wireless internet Local Loop (McWiLL), which is based on SCDMA technology in the 400MHz band. It was developed by Beijing Xinwei Telecom Technology and combines S-CDMA with an IP-based core network, using CS-OFDMA adaptive modulation, and boosting performance with dynamic channel allocation and smart antennas. Despite its spectral efficiency, it lacks proven track record or ecosystem, and the Olympic organizers now seem keen to supplement TD-SCDMA with lower risk wireless standards. The Beijing Olympics Organizing Committee has accredited China Mobile to provide WLan and WiMAX service for the Olympics.
Compared to previous Olympics, the 2008 Games will involve the widest adoption of broadband and mobility services in history, said Zhao Jidong, senior VP at China Netcom, the official fixed line communications provider for the event. “For us, the Beijing Olympics will be a true broadband event – no matter mobile or fixed – which allows end users to get information about the Olympics, anywhere, any time, and via any device.”
China still expects TD-SCDMA to take center stage in mobility, even if 3G licenses have not been allocated to operators by next summer. Earlier this year it extended pre-commercial testing of the homegrown standard to 10 cities from the original three. China Telecom and China Netcom are to expand their respective TD-CDMA networks in Baoding and Qingdao, and China Mobile will set up new networks in six other cities – Beijing, Guangzhou, Shenzhen, Tianjin, Shengyang, Qinghuangdao, and expand the existing one in Xiamen. The networks promise to be quite sophisticated. The Beijing network, for instance, will consist of more than 3,000 base stations.