Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 August 2003

China runs first trial of GSM1x hybrid, and gives hope to 3G gear makers

The first handset trial of GSM1x, a version of the CDMA2000 standard for GSM operators, is taking place in China, making a significant step towards deployment of the network in various parts of the world.

The trial is taking place in Suzhou and being run with Kyocera handsets running on Qualcomm chipsets, by China Unicom, the second Chinese cellular carrier. The technology is an important one in the battle between CDMA ‘ which Qualcomm controls ‘ and GSM and their next generation variants. It allows GSM operators to maintain their investment and to implement most of CDMA2000’s functionality at lower cost than a full network replacement.

Although CDMA is expected to lose out to GSM ultimately, it has received a major new lease of life from the implementation problems of its 3G rival, W-CDMA, which is making CDMA2000 an attractive alternative, especially in countries where no firm decision has been made on 3G strategies, China being the critical one.

Asia is expected to be the main market for GSM1x, although there may be some US carrier interest too since CDMA2000 has proved quicker and easier to roll out than W-CDMA. However, there are drawbacks for GSM operators, notably problems with roaming agreements with ‘pure’ GSM networks, which account for almost 80% of the world total. And of course Europe is excluded from GSMx1 because W-CDMA is mandated by the European Union, although in a less regulated environment many carriers would have considered the hybrid as a way to get 3G implemented more rapidly than with W-CDMA, which is still beset with operational problems.

With China’s operators still considering their 3G options, a success for GSM1x here would be a major boost for Qualcomm and its CDMA2000. This would be particularly valuable as Nokia, in partnership with Texas Instruments and STMicroelectronics, steps up its CDMA efforts. Qualcomm no longer has the CDMA space to itself, but it does dominate the nascent CDMA2000 sector.

However, there are two other 3G standards in China, including TD-SCDMA, a third variant officially supported by the Chinese government, although final decisions on 3G policy are yet to be made ‘ licenses will be awarded in February 2004. TD-SCDMA is the least advanced of the three options and has not attracted interest outside China, but the companies that have done most technological work on it have intensified their focus on it. Philips has been working hard on the standard this year, and cites it as its primary 3G interest. This looked terribly like Philips backing the losing standard again, but of course, if China does go the TD-SCDMA route, the Dutch company will have a huge headstart in the world’s largest mobile equipment market.

The same thinking seems to be going on at Siemens, the inventor of TD-SCDMA, whose suffering cellular arm said this week that it will spend €60m a year to develop the 3G variant. It has already spent almost €150m on the technology over the past two years according to chief operating officer Lothar Pauly, and expects it to roll out in six months’ time, when China issues its 3G licenses.

Although the leading mobile operators in China are also showing interest in the other 3G standards, there is considerable pressure from the government to adopt TD-SCDMA, which could, if all operators took that choice, become the biggest 3G network almost overnight.

The Chinese authorities refer to TD-SCDMA as their homegrown variant, because it was co-developed with state-backed Datang. The government has been keen to have its own technology for next generation communications rather than using CDMA2000, which it regards as American, or W-CDMA, which it sees as European. It wishes to reduce its dependence on foreign suppliers for critical telecoms technology, and to give itself better bargaining power when purchasing network equipment. It has allocated spectrum for TD-SCDMA and encouraged an alliance of local companies to develop equipment, though they will all have to pay royalties to Siemens ‘ though Siemens says these will be lower than those charged by Qualcomm for CDMA2000.

However, the other two standards are more advanced and the biggest carriers will base at least some of their services on them, raising the real danger that TD-SCDMA will be stillborn, especially if there are significant roll-out problems. It does have some advantages over its rivals, notably that it uses available spectrum more efficiently and so is well suited to built-up urban areas, but it is less effective over very wide areas.

The troubled mobile network hardware suppliers know that the Chinese market is potentially large enough to create a turnaround on its own for those that position themselves most cleverly and, while local handset makers are starting to push into the dominance of Nokia and Motorola, at the equipment and chip end, the market is still wide open to the Europeans and Americans.

The scale of the market is illustrated by China Mobile’s latest figures ‘ with 129.1m subscribers, it is now the world’s largest cellular carrier, overtaking Vodafone, even though it operates in just one country and faces fierce competition from China Unicom. Its profits grew by 13% in first half of its fiscal year, with net income of $2.11bn on revenues up 39% to $9.26bn.

Ericsson has signed a $32m contract with the Guangdong arm of China Mobile, the country’s largest mobile operator, to expand its GPRS network across 22 cities in the province. This means that the capacity in the region will be 1.88m users by February 2004, the largest and one of the most advanced networks in China. Ericsson has worked with Guangdong Mobile for 10 years and will hope for significant further business as further data services and eventually 3G are rolled out.