Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 December 2012

Cisco transformation continues with shift to software and the truly smart network

Cisco went through a major refocus last year, pulling back from end user devices, but against many expectations, did not offload its Linksys consumer networking division. Despite CEO John Chambers delivering strong results from his restructuring, it seems he may have another round in mind, and this time Linksys could be sold off.

According to Bloomberg, Cisco has hired Barclays to look for possible buyers for Linksys as it seeks to focus entirely on the infrastructure and software that drives broadband, rather than the end points. As well as fellow home wireless vendors, buyers could emerge from the TV industry, some analysts think, as consumer electronics firms look to integrate wireless facilities into their products to add value and support home media networks.

Cisco acquired Linksys for $500m in 2003 and has kept it at the top of the home wireless market as well as expanding its activities in small and medium businesses. However, it has become less interested in the consumer sector, shutting its Flip camcorder business as part of last year’s reorganization. That programme also included a target to cut 14% of the global workforce, or 11,500 staff.

Linksys has survived several rumoured attempts to kill it, rebrand it or integrate it more tightly with other units. For a while, it had put forward a vision of end-to-end IP, providing every element from giant routers to gadgets like the Flip camcorder (a 2011 casualty along with the Cius tablet and Umi telepresence offering). But amid suffering performance, CEO JohnChambers reverted to the key strengths in IP networks and infrastructure, with the services that ride on top.

In that context, Linksys kept its name but was repositioned somewhat, taking on the role of providing the home hub which would give Cisco control of the domestic environment without having to own the end points. Linksys, it emerged, would stop making devices and focus entirely on the network itself. The unit’s general manager, Brett Wingo, said the division would place its resources into its gateways and routers, but also adapt those products significantly to mirror the changes in the home network and to take a more strategic and high value role.

As users start to create multiscreen digital networks allowing them to view video and access data from many devices round the house, this will enhance the role and value of routers as they become the control center for these multimedia systems, incorporating new technologies like HD quality Wi-Fi. Linksys’ router R&D has been heavily focused on products which can detect all the connected devices in the home and their capabilities, in order to decide on the highest quality routes for different types of content. The next step is to expand their role further, making them the main intersection between the home WLan and the service provider network.

The Linksys box aims to become the common point for every gadget in the house to connect to the outside world, rather than the current situation where each gateway, internet TV and home control box has its own internet link. Routers are “sitting idle and not doing things a lot of the time, and you can have them do more and you can run more services on them,” Wingo said in the interview. “The hardware that’s capable of moving video around the house or displaying software onto a screen … those types of things can be done in the router in a lot of cases.” And there will be increasing integration with Cisco’s cloud services and its CloudConnect framework for managing the home network.

This strategy was logical and fitted well with Cisco’s approach to small and large enterprise segments and to femtocells. But the company may be looking to pull back from the home market altogether, say some sources, and leave the home hub role to lower margin rivals or to tablets, as part of the broad ‘Transformation Project’, led by SVP Angel Mendez, with a brief to “deliver greater productivity, agility, and growth” by realigning the product and services portfolio, and operational capabilities.

The success of Cisco’s reorganization so far, as seen in recent results, has freed up the vendor to return to its old form as a serial acquirer, and this week it snapped up its fourth company in a month, this time pouncing on nine-year-old policy management specialist Broadhop.

Broadhop’s Quantum Network Suite policy control systems for fixed and mobile networks, and the team behind them, will be integrated into Cisco’s service provider mobility group, reporting to Shailesh Shukla, general manager of the company’s software and applications division. Terms were not disclosed.

The buy adds another element to Cisco’s strategy to increase its carrier business and develop a multifaceted platform for operators, surrounding its traditional routers with technology for packet core, small cells, cloud services and other elements. These are being pulled together around the ONE programmable network platform, which will provide flexible control of the whole network via a range of tools and software.

Broadhop’s products, Cisco says, will give carriers the ability to personalize their networks and services, enabling users to purchase customized service packages. One of the key ways that operators hope to generate higher revenues from their mobile broadband networks is by delivering multiple tiers of service, with some customers or content providers paying a premium to have their data prioritized.

The two firms have already cooperated in the area of carrier Wi-Fi. Denver-based Broadhop’s traffic management and policy server has been deployed in more than 70 wireline and mobile networks around the world, to support different levels of IP service around different applications such as VoIP, or different user profiles. While some get priority access, others may be throttled when they hit certain levels of data usage.

Cisco is interested in the kind of advanced traffic differentiation Broadhop supports ‘ the networking firm gave the example of a mobile video-on-demand service where a customer buying a premium movie would receive faster rates and have the data prioritized over that of other users.

Bigger acquisitions may be on the cards for early 2013, especially in the areas which will underpin Cisco’s strategy going forward ‘ adding functionality to its main router platforms, particularly for carriers and for software defined networking (SDN); and pushing into the mobile operators’ gateways and even their access networks, via small cells, carrier Wi-Fi and Cisco-controlled controllers to keep the whole complex system together. These two areas are, Cisco believes, the way it can be the most essential vendor for mobile and converged operators, usurping that role from Ericsson without ever taking the Swedish giant on in its traditional strongholds such as traditional base stations.

“We have gone too long without any major M&A,” Chambers said during a recent analyst day in New York. He said Cisco has left money on the table, turning down a gain of possibly 1% in revenues by not expanding its reach more rapidly. “You will see us more active in the M&A side,’ he promised.

Already in the past few weeks the firm has acquired cloud-based enterprise network provider Meraki; Cloupia, which automates converged data center infrastructure; and Cariden, which makes network optimization tools for ISPs. Broadhop makes the fourth purchase in a month and the eleventh in 2012, with others including video content protection major NDS, the largest purchase of 2012, plus vCider (data center virtualization); ThinkSmart (Wi-Fi location); Virtuata (data center security); Truviso (network management); ClearAccess (provisioning mobile devices); and LightWire (routing and switching).

Many of these fit with Chambers’ aim of shifting the emphasis from router hardware to software and services, where the margins and the real customer control lie. Carriers and enterprises are harnessing virtualization, software defined networks and sophisticated management tools to create smart or adaptive networks, which respond dynamically to changing user and traffic patterns and can accommodate all kinds of hardware and devices.

Chambers told analysts that he plans to double revenues from software from $6bn to $12bn over the next five years, making this activity 25% of total sales ‘ which he aims to grow at 5% to 7% per year on a long term basis. The majority of engineering done at Cisco is already in software, the CEO continued, and this is then bundled with hardware or chips to add intelligence to IP networking gear. Software is being developed to add functionality and flexibility to the whole Cisco portfolio ‘ switches, routers, cloud platforms, data center gear, mobility, video and security. Examples are the IOS network operating system, the SDN program, Nexus OS, Star OS, Webex conferencing platform, Call Manager service, and IronPort and ScanSafe security offerings.

Cisco needs to accelerate these software and intelligence activities in wireless to tap into the boom in mobile traffic and the carriers’ urgent need to handle it. There are signs of hope here.
Wireless networking products were one of the highlights of Cisco’s fiscal first quarter results, announced in November, with sales up 38% year-on-year. That event saw the networking giant talking up plans to expand that business, riding the emerging trend for small 3G/4G base stations.

Cisco’s previous effort in cellular RAN, the acquisition of WiMAX vendor Navini, was a failure, but it is a major supplier of Wi-Fi gear to carriers; it is a strong player in the packet core; and has worked with femtocell specialist ip.access to supply AT&T’s extensive MicroCell build-out. All this positions it for an enhanced role in cellcos’ supply chains as they move towards denser networks of LTE small cells, and Cisco looks set to make its own kit here.

CEO John Chambers said the firm planned to make its own cellular small cells, building on its Wi-Fi platform and giving it a new route into major operator accounts. However, there are risks to this strategy, since Cisco will be pitching against major OEMs with which it often collaborates, such as Ericsson.

In response to an analyst question on the earnings call about the RAN business,Chambers said carrier Wi-Fi kit had brought in $100m in the fiscal year, but the quarterly figure had doubled year-on-year, convincing Cisco executives of the growth potential of this relatively small activity. He said: “We’re going to move into small cell, and then we’re going to combine small cell with [carrier] Wi-Fi, with 3G, with 4G, with our architectural plays.’ But he confirmed that Cisco had no plans to make larger base stations, steering clear of a fruitless showdown with Ericsson and Huawei, in a stagnating segment.

In the quarter to October, Cisco beat Wall Street forecasts with net income up 18% year-on-year to $2.1bn, including one-off charges of $500, a figure which vindicated Chambers’ aggressive turnaround program. However, the firm still needs to breathe new life into the core business on which it is still reliant, the heartland switch and router business. Sales here still fell by 2% in the quarter, despite the exponential growth in internet traffic, indicating an increasingly competitive environment that has forced Cisco to reduce its normally premium prices.

The challenges in the router space justify the increased emphasis on software to power truly intelligent wired and wireless networks, but even with Chambers’ aggressive targets, this activity will only reach one-quarter of revenues during most of this decade. New hardware products such as small cells will help boost revenue, though possibly not margin, while further exits from consumer devices and endpoints will help the profit balance. However, Cisco remains an IP switch/router firm at heart, and it needs to show its backers more progress in harnessing that base for all the trends ‘ all-IP, smart routers, distributed carrier networks, carrier Wi-Fi ‘ which are so important now, and should by rights play to Cisco’s strengths.