Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 February 2006

Comment: Prepaid customers should reduce churn levels, not worsen them

Since the introduction of prepaid mobile phone services, these have exploded in popularity and driven a major expansion of cellphone usage in many regions. However, they have been regarded by large operators as a double-edged sword, because of the assumption that prepaid customers are intrinsically less loyal than contract subscribers, and therefore contribute to one of the cellcos’ most important economics metrics, churn levels. However, much of the fickleness of prepaid users may have resulted from a vicious circle of the operators’ making ‘ because these customers were less valued, they were given fewer and inferior services, with a negative effect on their loyalty and profit margin. Now a new survey confirms what major carriers have started to suspect ‘ that prepaid customers, if given a sufficiently attractive offering, are as loyal as, or even more faithful than, postpaid subscribers.

Such indicators are vital because churn is one of the most important issues facing cellcos. Increasingly they are placing hopes on fixed/mobile convergence, greater bundling and next generation services like television to keep customers happy, but there may be shorter term solutions closer to home, based on delivering better options to existing and reasonably contented prepaid customers. Churn is a massive bogeyman for mobile operators. In 2003, it cost European mobile operators €4.5bn in unnecessary expenses and €5.6bn in lost revenues, according to Analysys. This equates to roughly 8% of total mobile revenues. In 2000, churn levels in the European international majors – O2, Orange, T-Mobile and Vodafone – were 17-30%; now they are 30-35% per cent, driven by greater competition, especially from MVNOs, and higher overall uptake. It traditionally costs five times more to win a new customer than retain an existing one (although the reality can vary from two to 20 times depending on the market) and so churn is of vital importance, and the results of the new survey may offer some grounds for a new approach.

The study, commissioned by Nokia from GfK NOP, highlighted five essentials in deciding a customer’s choice of operator and loyalty towards it. These are calling plans, operator brand image, handset models and availability, network quality and cost. This suggests that operators focus too much on cost as a way to attract and retain customers, and this is particularly true in the prepaid world, where cost is assumed to be the major driver. Although it is obviously important, there are other reasons for customer to opt for prepaid, and the user with a really tight budget ‘ who may be of little interest to a major carrier anyway ‘ is likely to go for a no-frills MVNO offering. For the majority that are influenced by the other factors such as brand and handset type, it is important to bring prepaid offerings into line.

This will be particularly true in retaining customers. The Nokia survey found that the main factors driving users to change operator are network quality, service level agreements, billing accuracy, customer relationship management and any bureaucratic, contractual or technological barriers that might be put in the way of their moving to another supplier. For most, brand image and pricing plans are the least important considerations once they have made an initial choice of operator.

According to the research, the group most likely to churn consists of recent subscribers, under 35 years old, earning median or above average salaries and with a high monthly spend on mobile services, and the majority of these are contract subscribers ‘ the carriers key target for new, higher margin data and 3G offerings.

In order to exploit the prepaid base more effectively and increase these customers’ average spend, most cellcos will need to rethink their marketing, but also adjust their back end systems. Prepaid and postpaid services usually run on entirely separate delivery, billing and back office platforms and therefore it is hard to adopt uniform marketing and targeting techniques for both bases, or to mix and match prepaid and postpaid services within a single bill (a rising user demand, for instance for family accounts).

There is, then, increasing pressure for carriers to add a similarly broad range of services to their prepaid offerings as to their postpaid, but systems designed for prepaid often find it hard to support data services, while postpaid platforms lack the real time capabilities of their prepaid cousins. One solution is to adopt a fully converged system, but this is a very expensive option, although one that is being adopted by some players, especially in Asia-Pacific. There are many different approaches to convergence, and to managing all a subscriber’s services under one ‘logical’ account, but none of them are low cost or without risks and disruption.

However, key drivers of customer loyalty ‘ such as rich prepaid services and unified billing ‘ require converged back office platforms, otherwise, delivering attractive bundles and integrated bills, and combining different payment methods and different service types under a single account, all involve complex and laborious procedures that will raise opex, potentially to the point of negating the financial benefits of convergence altogether. At this stage, convergence will still meet the customer satisfaction objective, but will fail on financial metrics.

According to Forrester Research, in a survey of major US and European mobile operators conducted in 2004, 65% said they had delayed launching certain prepaid services for longer than they believed was good for the business model. For 71% of these slow movers, the main reason was that billing technology was unavailable or inadequate, or the move to convergent or even dual-mode billing was considered too risky and expensive.

However, the cost of not making moves to convergence may be even higher, especially in terms of loss of customers when other carriers leap ahead in offering creative bundling and unified billing, and in terms of being too inflexible to launch innovative new services and combinations at low cost. It is clear that the players in that 65% category were dissatisfied with delaying services, and the postponement may have hurt their competitiveness, a fear that is driving operators to bite the bullet and adopt convergent billing and CRM, and driving vendors to offer them simpler and more friendly ways to do this.

The market for convergent billing systems is set for strong growth for this reason. In Europe, Analysys estimates expenditure on such systems by cellular and combined fixed/mobile operators, will increase by 36% to $145m by 2010 (excluding integration services, hardware and inhouse effort). Such figures suggest that operators may be waking up to the fact that, while advanced 3G services may be slower to take off, and therefore have significant impact on ARPU, than they had hoped, there is a huge base of users that is currently being under-tapped and underestimated in terms of revenue potential. There will be more attention paid to satisfying these customers and adding to the services they can access, rather than the old obsession with converting them to postpaid contracts, a push that T-Mobile, among other majors, has admitted has largely been a failure.