Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 September 2005

Complex alliances will let north America take broadband wireless lead

One of the key factors that spelt doom for the broadband wireless access experiments of the late 1990s (Teligent, Winstar, Firstmark et al) was a complete misjudgement of the balance between rapid roll-out ‘ for early mover advantage ‘ and cautious use of investors’ money. Most operators erred wildly on the side of the former, without really testing whether the market was ready for their services, or whether their chosen technology could actually deliver them. Teligent, for instance, spent $1.3bn in a year building its US network but only signed up 35,500 customers by the time it filed for bankruptcy in 2001.

Second time around, many of the price/performance problems of the LMDS band networks used by those start-ups have been addressed through standards-based, lower frequency WiMAX-type technologies, and in business model terms, most of the service providers are taking a more careful approach to build-out. But once providers move out of highly localized markets and aim for success on a national or even international scale, and particularly once they start to eye portable and mobile services, they can no longer think too small, for fear of being swept away by more ambitious rivals. This dilemma is spurring a large number of deals whereby telcos, whether large or small, form often unlikely alliances to pool spectrum and roll-out costs and so achieve rapid expansion while offsetting some of the risks.

This started among smaller WISPs and has spread to midrange ones seeking to create national networks from fairly modest beginnings, often in countries with high average income but vast rural areas such as Australia, Canada and the US (see box). Now it is spreading to larger players, notably the Bell Canada-Rogers joint venture in Canada, Inukshuk Internet, under which the two wireline rivals will pool their broadband wireless spectrum holdings and build-out costs (although not their route to market, since each will use 50% of the network capacity to sell own branded services that could compete directly).

The best example of using partnerships to achieve a weight beyond what it could do alone is Clearwire, which is acting as a bellwether for the pre-WiMAX market in many ways because of its scale and the fact that it is headed by legendary wireless entrepreneur Craig McCaw. It is balancing cautious real world roll-out with lofty medium term goals and ambitious alliances, particularly with the major carriers that are leading the charge to broadband wireless in north America ‘ with Inukshuk Internet itself (see inset and Wireless Watch September 16 2005), and potentially with Sprint Nextel, which is mandated by the FCC to create a broad-based service in its national 2.5GHz spectrum by 2008.

These three interlocking ventures have the opportunity, resources and vision to change the face of north American telecoms, increasing access options in underserved areas and creating a new service choice for premium markets such as business travellers and ‘power consumers’ seeking a mobilized triple play of voice, video and high speed data . Sprint Nextel has already indicated that it aims to use its 2.5GHz network to create a challenge to the incumbent DSL/fiber/cellular telcos, in particular the Regional Bell Operators Verizon, SBC and BellSouth, and as those companies become increasingly wireless driven, it will move in the opposite direction, using its two wireless networks to deliver fixed as well as mobile services.

Sprint Nextel will have something of a balancing act to achieve to ensure that its broadband wireless offerings, once mobilized, do not cannibalize its CDMA EV-DO revenues, but so far it seems to have the parallel plans well differentiated. The pre-WiMAX network may be used to offload some heavy duty traffic from CDMA, and to increase the choices available to Sprint’s important base of MVNO partners, as well as for directly branded fixed or portable access services.

For Bell Canada and cableco Rogers, the balance will be somewhat harder to draw, not least because the two operators are fierce rivals in other markets, and have other service revenues to protect. Although the early focus seems to be on western Canada, which has vast rural regions and is dominated by Bell arch-rival Telus, the network will spread beyond that and will need to be carefully differentiated from, or integrated with, DSL and cable services to prevent cannibalization. However, though this will be a delicate process, in developed markets the operators that can make real money from broadband wireless will be those that can incorporate it in bundles with DSL, cable or satellite services in order to add a portable and, in future, mobile aspect, enhancing the core wireline offering to boost customer retention and average spend.

The other bonus that the broadband wireless network could bring Bell and Rogers is the ability indirectly to draw revenue from non-Canadian users. Bell Canada has already taken a step towards this by agreeing to provide and host the VoIP services for Clearwire in the US (and also is preferred VoIP supplier in other territories). This agreement, signed earlier this year, when Bell took its first investment in Clearwire, gives the start-up an enterprise class voice platform and brings Bell a business outside its native country.

Now it can add roaming fees. By roaming with Clearwire ‘ and perhaps in future with Sprint Nextel ‘ Inukshuk enables its subscribers to access a pan-north American network, and this could be extended further through Clearwire’s other agreements, notably with associated company MVS in Mexico and through its expanding European holdings. This will also be a benefit that Clearwire will be able to offer its own customers, and one that will be highly unusual among start-up broadband wireless providers.

Roaming will be possible between Clearwire and Inukshuk (and MVS) as soon as the networks are built, since they are using the same mobile broadband equipment, from Clearwire-owned NextNet. Once this is migrated to support the mobile WiMAX standard, probably later in 2006, there will also be roaming opportunities with other WiMAX operators, including, potentially, Sprint Nextel, which has not yet made its choice of equipment, or BellSouth, which is deploying a Navini-based network in some of its territories. Clearwire has been getting closer to Sprint Nextel for months, amid talk that they are negotiating a spectrum pooling arrangement not unlike the Canadian one. This would enable them to combine their resources to take on the US Bell companies, rather than dividing them between building two competitive systems, which in an immature market could be destructive, especially since Sprint Nextel also needs to pay close attention to its merger and to the build-out of CDMA EV-DO.

At the least, McCaw’s close historic ties with Nextel, and the need for both Sprint Nextel and Clearwire to achieve national coverage as quickly and cost effectively as possible, should help facilitate a roaming deal at an early stage, certainly once portability is fully supported and a reasonable number of territories are equipped (Clearwire is currently live in 17 US markets, mostly tier two cities or suburbs in the west, midwest and south east, with seven more to be added in the next few weeks. Sprint Nextel will not start deployment until next year and is currently conducting trials, while Inukshuk has a couple of markets live in Ontario and British Columbia).

It is too early to judge how successful Clearwire will be as a consumer brand but it is already clear that it will have a disruptive effect, by creating a start-up with a viable chance to compete with some far larger wireline or cellular incumbents, and that it is creating alliances that increase its value far beyond its commercial size. Its level of funding – $600m to date is the most conservative estimate, including a reported $100m from Bell Canada, a debt offering of $260m minimum, and a major injection from Intel ‘ is impressive for a start-up; and its joint development agreement with Intel not only serves to keep NextNet technologically up to date but also draws Clearwire into the increasingly powerful mesh of deals the chip giant is creating for its WiMAX ecosystem, with close R&D partners including Sprint Nextel itself, AT&T, Nortel and others. As such, and by offering non-US players like Bell Canada a door into new markets, Clearwire is punching well above its weight and amassing huge value for its business, even if the eventual aim is to sell it as McCaw Cellular was once sold to AT&T.

Clearwire is building up its partnerships in smaller ways too, in its stealthy way. It has various affiliates, particularly holders of spectrum in the 2.5GHz bands with which it has leasing or investment deals (it is also starting to form such alliances with holders of European 3.5GHz licenses). For instance, it is affiliated to HITN (Hispanic Information & Television Network), which holds 2.5GHz EBS licenses in many tier 1 US markets and received about $7m of Clearwire stock last year in return for a sharing deal. Clearwire has subsequently leased some of this spectrum to Sprint, and in return has leased capacity in some of its tier two markets from the larger player, adding fuel to the speculation that a more sweeping deal may be on the cards now that the Sprint Nextel merger is finalized.

Key to Clearwire’s attempts to roll out at relatively low cost is access to the ITFS spectrum, originally allocated for educational and religious broadcasting. These frequencies are often held by smaller players ‘ such as schools and churches ‘ than the MMDS licenses in the same 2.5GHz band, and may be acquired or leased for lower cost, although all this spectrum has now been recast under the BRS label (see inset). Clearwire is also able to leverage its NextNet equipment and this often appears to be its first route into potential spectrum partners in the US and elsewhere, with a string of NextNet users joining its web of alliances in return for favorable infrastructure deals. They include WatchTV, which controls 33 channels of ITFS and MMDS in Ohio; Speednet, whose licenses cover 500,000 households in north and central Michigan; and Gryphon Wireless, which uses ITFS channels in Nebraska. Clearwire itself, originally a Florida-focused WISP, was also an ITFS holder before being acquired by McCaw. Another possible partner may be WebSky (see inset).

McCaw has purchased ITFS and MMDS spectrum in many areas but where it is not available, has said he will enter leasing deals with the holders, often regional or local broadcasters. McCaw therefore has the chance to repeat what his previous venture, Nextel, did in sub-1GHz bands, amassing a patchwork of underused and undervalued spectrum to create a national network by stealth and at relatively low cost.

Whatever the long term role of Clearwire, the activities of Inukshuk and Sprint Nextel are highly encouraging for north American telecoms and could help the region take a lead in broadband wireless that it failed to achieve in cellular, and that is being matched in scale only in Korea. Both these are major projects with serious funding. Sprint Nextel has to create a service that can address at least 30m Americans by the end of the decade, while Inukshuk will spend an estimated Can$200m ($170m) over three years on bringing broadband wireless coverage to two-thirds of the Canadian population (about 22m people), addressing 40 cities and 50 rural communities. This is serious investment and from companies that understand how to create a triple play service, and places the ball firmly in the court of the other large telcos, that are holding on to 2.3GHz, 2.5GHz or 3.5GHz spectrum but being slow to activate it. All eyes will be on the next moves in from Telus, SBC, Verizon and BellSouth.

INUKSHUK

Inukshuk was set up in 1999 by Microcell ‘ subsequently acquired by Rogers ‘ mainly to address e-education and access markets in the remote northern territories of Canada including Inuit communities. In 2004 it formed a joint venture of the same name with Allstream and NR Communications ‘ an investment company run by long time McCaw associate Nick Kauser ‘ to create a NextNet-based broadband wireless network across Canada. Allstream later sold its one-third share to the other two for $8.1m, a sum that now seems paltry, and in March Bell Canada joined the party by taking a 50% share in NR alongside its VoIP and investment deal with Clearwire.

Last week Bell gained equal rights with Rogers in the venture by buying out Clearwire’s remaining holdings in NR. The two telcos will now jointly build and manage the new network and will pool their wireless broadband spectrum holdings into the joint venture, aiming to cover more than two-thirds of the population within three years. Rogers said it will contribute its entire spectrum holdings in the 2.3GHz, 2.5GHz and 3.5GHz bands to the venture, while Bell Canada will offer its holdings in the 2.3GHz and 2.5GHz bands. Inukshuk already holds about 98MHz of 2.5GHz spectrum across Canada.

Inukshuk will operate the network on a cost recovery basis, with Bell Canada and Rogers each having the rights to use 50% of the network’s total transmission capacity. Sales, marketing, customer service and billing functions will be handled by the respective operator.

Earlier this year, the Canadian regulator assigned 306 wireless licenses in the 2.3GHz and 3.5GHz bands to 12 companies by auction. Top bidders included Telus with 130 licenses, Bell Canada with 55 licenses and Rogers Wireless with 40 licenses. Telus has not announced firm plans for the spectrum.

SPECTRUM SHARING

Pooling of spectrum assets and network building costs will be a common pattern as operators look to roll out broadband wireless services quickly but with limited risk. This is especially true in countries with large underserved areas to cover and high average income, because they have significant pent-up demand for broadband. The best example of this is Australia, where broadband penetration is among the lowest in the developed economies.

A new boost for broadband wireless roll-out came this summer with a spectrum swap between two operators, Austar and Unwired Australia, designed to deliver interoperable services in both metropolitan and regional Australia. Like the Rogers-Bell deal, though on a smaller scale, this pact calls for the two companies to pool spectrum resources, although they will build two separate, but roaming, networks.

Under the agreement, Austar will trade a portion of its 2.3GHz license to Unwired, in which Intel recently took a stake, in return for part of Unwired’s 3.5GHz license, and the license boundaries will be redrawn with new licenses issued. Unwired will also make a cash payment to Austar of $15m. As a result, Austar will hold 2.3GHz and 3.5GHz licences in areas that roughly align with its current subscription television market in regional Australia, while Unwired will hold the 2.3GHz and 3.5GHz licences for the majority of metropolitan Australia.

Both companies will use flavours of WiMAX in their bands, with Unwired choosing Navini Ripwave, which will be migrated to mobile WiMAX next year.

Austar CEO John Porter said: ‘By rationalizing our spectrum holdings into our regional markets, Austar will be in a position to develop plans to launch a broadband service, which is a logical extension of our core business. We have spent the last 10 years building a business that specializes in dealing with regional Australian needs, from our television service to mobile and dial-up internet services. Wireless broadband is ideally suited to regional markets.’

Unwired chairman Peter Shore said: ‘The beauty of building WiMAX-compliant networks is interoperability. As the networks are rolled out, Unwired would be able to sell a national service to all regions where Austar builds its network, in addition to its own city network and services, enabling Unwired wireless broadband customers to roam seamlessly from city to country and vice versa.’

Unwired has raised a Aus$15.7m loan to finance the spectrum swap deal, which it says compares with the $50m it would have cost to acquire a national 2.3GHz license, which would have included rural areas that it is not interested in targeting. It has also received a Aus37m injection from Intel.

The deal will create a national service and a viable challenge to incumbent telco Telstra. Wireless is expected to grow at three times the rate of broadband overall in Australia in 2005-6 and to account for over 10% of broadband lines by 2008, the highest in any developed economy.

US WISPS

Some WISPs are looking to take advantage of the scalability and falling costs of WiMAX to expand their networks quickly and seek to pre-empt the majors. Several US providers have embarked on major acquisition sprees, snapping up smaller players in underserved territories to try to cobble together regional or near-national networks where there is unmet demand for broadband and no immediate interest from the big names.

Two of the most aggressive are MobilePro and US Wireless Online. The former, an acquisitive chip designer turned WISP, made its twelfth acquisition in eight months recently, snapping up Evergreen Open Broadband, a wholesale WISP based in Boston, Massachusetts that will bring MobilePro relationships with regional and national ISPs, to add to its plans to create a nationwide patchwork network offering mobile, WiMAX and Wi-Fi services.

Evergreen will continue to recruit new partners as it becomes part of MobilePro’s Neoreach division, which is also bidding for about 20 citywide network contracts through recently acquired WazAlliance.

The company is building a far reaching network in underserved US markets, based on Wi-Fi and WiMAX. As well as its conventional wireless internet operation, it has a voice division, which holds CLEC licenses in 10 states and puts it in a position to offer bundled services, either directly or leased to a larger brand.

Other acquisitions in the past eight months have included 10 ISPs in seven states with a total of 70,000 internet customers ‘ including Shrevenet, Fiber Network, Web One, T1 Connect, Close Call, Clover Computing and US1. It has also signed purchase deals with Dallas-based CLEC CommSouth, Michigan CLEC Affinity Telecom and Houston ISP Crescent Communications.

US Wireless Online is to use Aperto’s recently announced PacketMAX WiMAX-ready equipment, to drive its expansion into new territories and VoIP services.

Like many operators, US Wireless will move gradually to WiMAX by deploying a mixture of proprietary and standards-based equipment that can coexist, and support the same subscriber gear. This enables it to start network expansion immediately, before certified WiMAX products are available, and has already started rolling out Aperto’s proprietary PacketWave systems in 5.8GHz unlicensed spectrum within its 3,000 square mile territory.

US Wireless Online will use PacketWave, and later PacketMAX, to deliver access services to government and enterprise customers and to backhaul its Wi-Fi networks, which are currently installed in 11 states. In the future, it expects to use WiMAX for consumer access too, when subscriber terminals are cheaper and to support new applications such as interactive gaming.

US Wireless Online aims to set up a national footprint through a string of acquisitions, a route that several ambitious WISPs are taking in the US, building their expansion plans on the promise of cost effective WiMAX-based broadband kit. It plans to migrate its networks to WiMAX over the coming year and to ramp up its voice activities after that move is complete because of the better economics of the new kit for launching VoIP services.

US Wireless Online claims it will be the first ISP to offer ‘coast to coast’ broadband wireless with voice and data, achieving this through further acquisitions. Its acquisitions this year have been Skyline Broadband of Fort Myers, Florida in August this year; iSkywire of Louisville, Kentucky in May; Verge Wireless of Baton Rouge, Louisiana in April; VoIPWorks, an enterprise VoIP developer and service provider, also in April; YYireless1.Net of Pittsburgh, in February; United Broadband Networks of Louisville, Kentucky in January; and Bluemile Wireless of Ohio, also in January. It has also signed a distribution agreement with Lightyear Network Solutions, a telecom reseller active in 27 states, and has agreed to another acquisition, of IPOutlet in Columbus, Ohio.

The WISP’s territories are currently in Alabama, Arkansas, Georgia, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, and Texas.

Executive chairman Jai Bhagat believes there is a window for independent WISPs in WiMAX before the market gets monopolized by the incumbents. He said in a recent interview: ‘If you look at telecom history, a lot of carriers start out, then you have consolidation and you’re left with three to four national players. We believe there is a window of opportunity in the wireless marketplace right now. There are a lot of WISPs out there that are not well funded. They’re looking for corporate support. We can provide them with not only financial but also sales and marketing and technology support.’

Its strategy is to price services somewhere between small business cable/DSL offerings and telco T1 services. The low end providers are asking $79 to $225 a month for basic business DSL service, while the telcos charge $500 to $1,000 for T1. USWO prices range from $200 to $300, depending on the market, for symmetrical 1.5Mbps service.

2.5GHz BRS BAND

In June 2004, the FCC restructured the 2.5GHz ITFS-MDS band in the US to eliminate the use of interleaved channels and create three distinct band segments: high power operations, such as one-way video transmission; low power operations, such as two-way fixed services; and mobile broadband applications. The last two of these are clearly applicable to WiMAX.

In the old arrangement, the IFTS frequencies, originally allocated for educational broadcasting, were interspersed throughout the MDS frequencies, creating interference issues. Not only did ITFS break up the spectrum, but its location in the spectrum chart varied from market to market, making it difficult for carriers with multiple licenses to deploy a consistent network across multiple markets.

By grouping high- and low-power users separately, according to the FCC, interference is reduced. The Commission hopes that eliminating the interference that has plagued ITFS and MMDS services will spur development of “low-power, cellularized broadband operations’, and to reflect this, has renamed the band ‘Broadband Radio Services’ (BRS).

“The magnitude of today’s ruling is apparent when one considers that this band is double the spectrum that sparked the Wi-Fi explosion at 2.4GHz and equivalent to the entire spectrum devoted to terrestrial mobile, wireless services,” then-FCC Chairman Michael Powell said.

The FCC also increased the size of the MDS-ITFS band by adding 5MHz below 2500MHz, to bring the total band to 194MHz. This was to “provide room for future relocation of MDS channels 1 and 2 – presently in the 2.4GHz band’.

The ITFS frequencies were originally allocated to non-profit and educational organizations for one-way analog broadcasting of educational television programming. In the 1980s, the FCC allowed these groups to lease their excess capacity to commercial service operators, and in 1998 allowed two-way digital operation.

The appeal of ITFS is that many states already have broadcast networks in these frequencies, complete with towers, even though these are currently restricted to educational programming. Public broadcasting towers could provide national coverage, delivering television and broadband wireless services for a relatively low investment by the operator.

WEBSKY

Another possible associate is WISP WebSky, which is also signing up long term leases and spectrum swapping deals to increase its footprint in underserved markets in the US and elsewhere. Earlier this month, for instance, it snapped up2.5GHz leases in Pierre, South Dakota; La Grande, Oregon; Del Rio, Texas; and Las Vegas, New Mexico.

Although on paper a competitor to Clearwire as one of a handful of WISPs using 2.5GHz rather than unlicensed 5.8GHz for broadband wireless, it does use the NextNet equipment and it could create a complementary network for roaming and even a closer relationship. In the US it focuses on small cities and different markets to Clearwire ‘ its live services are in Key West, Florida; Ukiah, California; La Crosse, Wisconsin; Grand Rapids, Michigan; Hilo, Hawaii; Aspen, Colorado; and Vail, Colorado.

When McCaw launched Clearwire, WebSky CEO Douglas Haffer welcomed the move, saying: ‘For many years, these frequencies have been ignored, out of the mainstream, and funding for the build-outs have seen false starts. We think McCaw and Clearwire’s entry into this niche of the market will raise the visibility and move this sector to the mainstream and assist others like ourselves in funding of developing these systems.’

Like McCaw, though on a smaller scale, Haffer’s track record is in acquiring spectrum assets in broadband wireless and in the last wireless bubble, he did this in 40 markets for a company called World Wide Wireless.

WebSky, formerly called Telemais, launched its first network in southern Brazil. Although it aims to acquire further US licenses, its primary recent focus has been on international markets. It has recently become far less aggressive about its home country, leading to speculation that it may be working towards a network sharing or even merger deal with Clearwire. Internationally, it mainly works through joint ventures and has such agreements in Thailand and Indonesia, as well as licenses in Peru and Argentina.

In India, WebSky has created a joint venture with Worldwide Wireless India (WWWI) to design, build and run a network that could address 75m people. WebSky will provide the funding and will construct the system while WWWI will contribute its licensed frequencies in 3.5GHz spectrum, which cover nine large cities, including Mumbai (Bombay), Delhi, Calcutta, Chennai (Madras), Bangalore and Hyderabad. It has a similar partnership in Buenos Aires, Argentina with local operator Infotel Wireless.

In Lima, Peru the company will work with DigitalWay, which holds licensed spectrum, to provide a non-line of sight system piggybacking on the current LOS network in Lima. Digital Way expects most of its 4,000 internet customers to migrate to the more flexible system in the coming two years, especially with the promise of laptop-based and portable access options. WebSky has a definitive agreement in place to purchase a majority interest in Digital Way. Although the operator has licenses throughout Peru, it is currently providing services only in greater Lima. Under its new deal with WebSky, it says it will be more cost effective to roll out services to other areas. The first targets will be tourist center Cuzco.