Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 April 2008

CTIA: Nokia pins hopes on US WiMAX despite Xohm delays

Nokia has more reason than most companies from the 3G community to want WiMAX to succeed, at least in the US. In most other territories, the Finn would probably welcome a universal shift to LTE via, or in parallel with, HSPA+, since its strength in UMTS makes WiMAX almost as much of a sideshow as it is for Ericsson. But in the US, Nokia has consistently failed to gain significant market share, and while the migration of CDMA giant Verizon to LTE will be a major new opportunity, in the meantime, Nokia’s chance of a quick boost Stateside comes from its close ties with Sprint for the WiMAX-based Xohm (likely WiMAX mushrooming ahead of LTE in India, one of Nokia’s most successful territories, is another good reason not to plow Ericsson’s ‘only one technology is necessary’ furrow). So delays to, and uncertainties over, Xohm are deeply unwelcome at Nokia, and it used last week’s CTIA super-show in Las Vegas to sound some positive noises for WiMAX, notably with the unveiling of its first commercial device, the N810, a product that will, once again, test the delicate balance of power between Nokia and Intel.

The WiMAX version of the N810, which is the fifth model in Nokia’s Internet Tablet range ‘ its only one without cellular connections, with previous iterations sporting Wi-Fi ‘ will run initially on Xohm, though it will be launched for the general market as WiMAX spreads, and Nokia will no doubt be looking to would-be Xohm partner Clearwire, which recently deployed its first mobile networks. The Internet Tablet was cited as one of the main reasons why Sprint made the surprise choice of Nokia Siemens as its third infrastructure partner for Xohm ‘ it was just Nokia at the time, but for the joint venture with Siemens, a breakthrough in the US is as vital as to the Finnish parent.

Nokia has stolen a march on fellow Xohm suppliers Samsung and Motorola ‘ Moto has yet to produce a commercial mobile device for Sprint; and Samsung, though it was the first phonemaker to roll out WiMAX handsets, mainly for Korean forerunner Wi-Bro, has not given Sprint a true smartphone yet. Its main product is the Mobile Intelligent Terminal, an ultra-mobile PC with five-inch screen.

Many more devices will follow, but the hoopla with which Nokia launched the N810 in Las Vegas was not just about promoting its own hopes for WiMAX and Xohm. It also believes that the tablet will tap into a broader zeitgeist in advanced mobile services, as placed at the top of the agenda at CTIA in the wake of the 700MHz spectrum auction ‘ the concepts of open access and PC-style freedom and unfettered internet services, a seachange in wireless that Sprint hopes Xohm will lead.

The original Nokia Internet Tablet showed the Finnish company recognizing ‘ despite its long history and stake in closed cellular devices and services ‘ that there was going to be a parallel trend among operators, established or disruptive, towards the open mobile internet. Linux, open IP connections and unrestricted browsing rather than Symbian OS, closed circuit switched networks and walled gardens ‘ and Nokia has been determined to take its share of that market, and in doing so, possibly even reduce the power of the cellcos to dictate terms to their phone suppliers. The latest model supports WiMAX and Wi-Fi, and comes with 4.13-inch touchscreen, retailing at about $440. It runs on Wi-Fi until WiMAX is detected.

As such, it has moved into internet services (see separate item) and taken on a slew of new competitors ‘ even as its traditional rivals flounder both in the traditional cellphone sector and in open devices, it is having to fend off the mobilizing activities of the PC internet community, led by Google, Intel and Microsoft. While Google remains almost entirely set against Nokia, the Finn has softened once-hostile relationships with Microsoft and has made some overtures to Yahoo, while its positioning vis-‘-vis Intel has always been complex. Will the Internet Tablets and their successors set Nokia up to compete head-on with Intel’s vision of the Ultra Mobile PC – an evolution of the conventional Wintel model, though with Linux options ‘ or will the two companies work together to define the key device architecture of next generation wireless, at the expense of mutual rivals like Qualcomm? Attempts at d’tente, such as a short-lived venture for 3G laptop card modules, have floundered on the persisting conflicts of interest, but both companies would almost certainly face their considerable challenges in the mobile internet together rather than apart ‘ and the N810 indicates how this might happen, since WiMAX models will actually be based on an Intel chip.

Nokia has been extending its processor supply chain lately, but adding Intel is a major departure, and one that adds a large dose of credibility to the PC giant’s often uncertain mobile strategy. It is very valuable for Intel to have gained a firm contract rather than just a development partnership, since it has looked at risk of creating a market where, in the early stages at first, other chipmakers would reap the revenues. More broadly, the Nokia win sets out the strategy that stands the best chance of reshaping the wireless industry in the internet image, with the chief representatives of the PC and the cellular heritage coming together to create a new breed of devices that will be optimized both for broadband web services and for mobility.

Nokia will use Intel’s Baxter Peak chipset for handhelds, and last fall Intel, Nokia and Nokia Siemens also announced an interoperability agreement that will ensure interoperability between Nokia Siemens’ WiMAX networks and Nokia devices based on Intel chips. The original, Wi-Fi N810 was unveiled last October, with its main advance on the previous 710 and 800 being context awareness, allowing users to connect with contacts based on their current location and availability. Significantly, given that the open internet strategy is most vital in the US in the short term, the 810 shipped first in the US, breaking the Nokia norm of launching first in western Europe and east Asia. Anssi Vanjoki, head of Nokia’s multimedia business unit, called the 810 the ‘third milestone in a five-phase journey toward a fully connected, mobile web 2.0 computer’.

Nokia’s infrastructure joint venture, Nokia Siemens, is also deepening its ties with Sprint as it seeks a stronger foothold in the US via new technologies. Sprint is to use NSN’s recently acquired Apertio One-Network Directory Service for a single real time common subscriber database for Xohm ‘ designed to address the customer service and targeting issues that have so plagued its CDMA business of late.

NSN also announced LTE products for the 700MHz and AWS (1.7GHz/2.1GHz) bands, using the flat Internet-HSPA network architecture, which will ease software-based compatibility with existing HSPA systems and migration to future networks. NSN is also providing a migration path from CDMA.

For all the aggressiveness of Nokia around WiMAX and openness, the company remains dependent on Sprint Nextel keeping up the impetus behind Xohm, to achieve its aims of a new and real US revenue stream. Yet Sprint appears to have delayed the full-scale roll-out of Xohm, despite a string of soft launches, and of course the much anticipated joint venture with Clearwire, for all its commercial sense, is still at the talking stage, possibly looking for funding from the cablecos, Intel and/or other parties (see Wireless Watch April 1 2008). Sprint Nextel was using CTIA to try to maintain excitement around its open access, 4G vision, which has always been genuinely convincing and ahead of the half-hearted open efforts of Verizon and AT&T, but which is mired in the doubts surrounding Sprint’s commercial future.

In his keynote at CTIA last Tuesday, CEO Dan Hesse said that “we expect a two-year time to market advantage” with the Xohm network over LTE deployments from Verizon and AT&T (see separate item), but while on paper that may remain true, there is a world of difference between the confidence levels surrounding Xohm, given its latest delays, and the aggressive CTIA statements of the leading two telcos, talking up their own LTE plans for 2009-2010.

“Our commercial launch will not be in April,” Sprint spokesman James Fisher said. “We’re in the soft launch in Baltimore, Washington DC and Chicago. We are making good progress on the soft launch.” He claimed delays were not related to technology but ‘logistical elements’ ‘ which may be a euphemism for sorting out funding and the joint venture, though some were also pointing to shortage of backhaul capacity, something Sprint has been complaining about, particularly when lobbying the FCC for new spectrum and rulings, for some time. Sprint officials would only say ‘later this year’ when pushed on a date for hard launch, and add that 10 devices were expected to be available at that point. Even the greatest cheerleader for Xohm and open WiMAX, Sprint head of 4G Barry West, would not be drawn on dates, though he said he was ‘upset’ it was not live yet, and also said backhaul for the true broadband speeds of WiMAX was ‘an issue’. Sprint aims to defocus on T1 leased lines and rely on fiber or high performance microwave links, but is short on both spectrum and funds for these more expensive options.

Such problems are familiar to cellcos and, if Sprint can sort out better funding, should be relatively easy to address. But the operator remains in a holding pattern that it can ill afford, given the new aggression of its larger rivals around LTE, and the need to revive confidence in the genuinely visionary Xohm project before it is stifled by the problems of its parent. Cultural and economic factors mean it is unlikely that Nokia, for all its interest in the success of WiMAX in the US, would invest directly in Xohm to ensure the market materializes, but it will certainly be lending its weight in other ways, and its enthusiasm will be important psychologically to those interested parties, such as cablecos, that may be mulling a financial stake in the broadband wireless venture.