Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 April 2006

CTIA: Vendors eye AWS spectrum auctions, WiMAX jockeys for position

With the largest auctions of US spectrum for years due to start in two months, the equipment vendors used the CTIA show last week to show off their offerings for these bands to prospective bidders. The FCC is to auction licenses in the AWS band (90MHz in 1.7GHz to 2.1GHz) this summer and in the 700MHz, former analog television spectrum, in 2009. While the cellular equipment makers were pushing implementations of their key products for AWS, the WiMAX community was also heavily active at the show, even though neither of the new bands is an official profile for 802.16.

However, if a major holder of either AWS or 700MHz licenses were keen to use WiMAX, it would almost certainly spur the WiMAX Forum to create a new profile, and vendors would make non-certified variants of their equipment in the meantime. Such an outcome would increase the total licensed spectrum in use for WiMAX in the US ‘ currently limited to the major operators’ 2.5GHz and 2.3Ghz holdings ‘ and would put 802.16 head-to-head with Qualcomm, which already owns a national 700MHz license for mobile TV. This band is one that has been of great interest to the WiMAX community for several years, because of its ability to support long range signals and penetrate obstacles, and therefore provide good, cost effective coverage in rural areas.

The Intel agenda would also be well served by a portion of the spectrum being license-exempt, this stimulating public access services using WiMAX. There has been considerable lobbying from various sources for an unlicensed 700MHz option. For instance, Microsoft funds a site called WirelessUnleashed, run by four spectrum licensing gurus including Kevin Werbach, which campaigns for greater unlicensed bands below 1GHz. There is support for their view in many quarters, such as Reed Hundt, former chair of the FCC, a firm advocate of opening up lower frequencies for broadband wireless, and allowing at least 30MHz of the 700MHz band to be license-free. “We can lower the costs of wireless broadband in one fell swoop by 50% within months, if this committee will say to the whole wireless broadband industry we need to be designing new spectrum for today’s analog UHF channels,’ he told a Senate committee in 2004.

In terms of real equipment, though, the CTIA focus was on AWS and on WiMAX for the current licensed profiles in 3.5GHz and 2.5GHz, including the first sightings of commercial 802.16e equipment. The certification of this standard, which supports mobility, is due to start in the third quarter and some suppliers are gearing up to offer pre-certified products, in anticipation of large carrier interest in the platform.

For the AWS band, the biggest launches were from Huawei, Siemens and Nortel, all of them also heavily committed to WiMAX and to creating a generation of equipment that will support different wired and wireless networks flexibly and integrate them under the software umbrella of an IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS). Huawei released its new generation UMTS base station for the AWS band; Siemens announced US availability of its WayMAX @vantage product tailored for 1.7GHz and 2.1GHz; and Nortel introduced several new UMTS solutions for the 850MHz and AWS frequencies.

Siemens is being most aggressive about adapting WiMAX-like technology for AWS, and showed off WayMAX@dvantage ‘just in time for operators to take advantage of the soon-to-be-released federal allocations of broadband wireless spectrum at 1710-1755MHz and at 2110-2155MHz’, as it put it.

Siemens supports Cisco’s Wireless Integration Platform for authentication, subscriber management and back end services for mixed technology wireless deployments. The WayMAX@vantage adapts to a range of channels, from 1.75MHz to 14MHz and up to 64QAM modulation. Among its carrier-class qualities, it optimizes system parameters for different applications’ traffic demand and user positions within a cell, and can assign different priorities to different user groups.

Siemens, like many large vendors, is looking to WiMAX mainly as a complementary technology for DSL and 3G, and aiming to sell complex multi-network converged systems including services. Its broadband wireless access portfolio includes a modular base station solution based on GERAN and UTRAN standards, which will ultimately allow for the integration of all mobile communication technologies into this MBS system, from GSM and EDGE to W-CDMA and HSPA, right through to WiMAX and Flash-OFDM.

Finally, Nokia’s Services group announced a suite of consultancy services to help auction participants create business cases for the AWS spectrum brand. Services include site engineering consulting.

These will be valuable as the potential bidders make their last minute decisions ‘ which will be eagerly watched by the WiMAX vendors. In particular, if T-Mobile ‘ which is in bad need of new spectrum ‘ fails to win significant AWS spectrum for 3G, it may be more likely to consider a 700MHz network using a broadband wireless technology. And a non-cellular operator winning an AWS or 700MHz license could accelerate the creation of WiMAX-like equipment for these areas of the spectrum.

Verizon Wireless is one company that remains undecided about its bidding strategy, in public at least. It said it would join one of the two auctions but probably not both. ‘We will do one or the other; it’s very unlikely that we will do both,’ said Denny Strigl, CEO of Verizon Wireless, at CTIA. He added that the company feels it is in a good spectrum position until about the end of this decade, with roll-out of CDMA EV-DO Rev A its next priority.

As well as Siemens, Motorola and Alvarion made the biggest WiMAX splashes at CTIA.
Motorola unveiled the first of its MotoWi4 WiMAX products and demonstrated IP telephony, signalling that it will target 802.16e at the triple play from day one, but also focusing on the critical early application for its initial target market, low cost fixed and nomadic services in underserved areas. Often seen as the preserve of 802.16-2004, this sector can also be well served by ‘e’ provided the subscriber equipment is sufficiently low cost, and it gives a future path to more complex mobile services. Indeed, Motorola is right to target this market early on, rather than aiming straight for the large carriers that are its heartland, since early 802.16e standards will not have all the capabilities of subsequent iterations, and the underserved market has more pent-up demand and shorter purchasing cycles than the major operators.

Dan Coombes, chief technology officer of Motorola Networks, said: “While WiMAX has been touted for its ability to deliver advanced applications, there is a significant market need to provide basic connectivity.”

This first 3.5GHz product, called Ultralite, will be followed by the Diversity and Smart Antenna ranges, each providing a higher level of functionality. Motorola envisages some operators taking a low risk start in WiMAX with Ultralite and then, as subscriber numbers rise, moving these base stations to rural or suburban areas and introducing the smart antenna-enabled systems to urban regions, which will require the greater spectral efficiency of the more sophisticated products. Although the later base stations will come with their own CPEs, which will feature the benefits of smart antennas, the older Ultralite units will also work with newer base stations to avoid operators having to swap them out en masse.

Motorola stresses its experience in delivering end-to-end carrier systems and, like Siemens, will often look to integrate WiMAX with DSL or another wireless network using IMS. Many MotoWi4 shipments will be in conjunction with a carrier class IP core based on IMS, said Motorola.

Alvarion, which has sometimes been accused of being behind the game in terms of 802.16e, demonstrated its new 4Motion product for the standard, even though it has not yet submitted its current BreezeMAX range, based on the fixed 802.16-2004 platform, for WiMAX Forum certification.

4Motion uses many elements of BreezeMAX, but offers a full end-to-end solution for personal broadband, which will be essential to go after the large carrier market. It incorporates QoS mechanisms, mobile IP core components, support for IMS (IP Multimedia Subsystem), plus subscriber terminals, an OMC and back end interfaces. Some of these elements have been developed internally or come from the mini-cellular base station unit, interWave, others are coming from unnamed partners. The all-IP core will be crucial for integration with other carrier networks and IMS.

Like most planned 802.16e implementations, the hardware includes software defined radios for future updates; performance enhancement through both the smart antenna techniques included in the official profiles (beamforming and MIMO); dynamic bandwidth allocation and scalable OFDMA physical layer.

A smaller vendor also betting that WiMAX profiles will be created for AWS and 700MHz is SOMA Networks, which has introduced the FlexMAX Wireless Platform for 802.16e, which claims to offer an end-to-end systems approach geared to multimedia and the triple play.

SOMA will offer FlexMAX products in both FDD and TDD versions, covering the full range of licensed frequency bands for both current and expected future profiles, namely: 700MHz, 1.7/2.1GHz, 2.3-2.7GHz and 3.3-3.8GHz bands. Current WiMAX-ready products are software upgradeable to the FlexMAX platform. Many smaller vendors ‘ Airspan is another good example ‘ gain differentiation by offering products in bands that have not had sufficient volume to attract large suppliers, but they will face a dilemma over whether to continue to support these products without official WiMAX support, at least until a broader set of profiles emerges. The WiMAX Forum’s own dilemma, of course, is to support operator needs in different bands while preventing the standard becoming so fragmented that the benefits of standards-based volume economics are lost.

Further analysis from CTIA in next week’s Wireless Watch, including a focus on Wi-Fi/cellular convergence and on CDMA roadmaps.