Chase Carey, chief executive of US satellite broadcaster DirecTV, delivered a one-liner at last week’s Cable Show that could represent a serious body blow to WiMAX in the US, and in particular to Craig McCaw’s Clearwire and its suppliers. Carey said that his company, the largest US direct-to-home satellite provide, will try out broadband over power lines (BPL) in selected cities later this year, putting paid to the notion that a WiMAX partnership was the only viable route for the satellite providers to gain a return path and start to move into a quad play.
A test would be carried out later this year in one of the top 50 cities in the US and would need to cover an area of at least half the city, Carey said. Until he made this comment, by far the most likely way for DirecTV to take its one-way pay TV service, and turn it into a two-way triple play, was via a deal with Clearwire. There is no question that such a deal would have been the making of McCaw’s new baby. He recently signed a deal with AOL to get that provider’s marketing muscle behind the Clearwire wireless broadband push, but would have loved even more to get the DirecTV marketing engine on his team.
So either DirecTV really believes that BPL – which delivers broadband internet access over conventional power lines – is the way to go, and has a secure economic model; or it just could not come to terms with Clearwire. Our own view is that DirecTV could reduce churn so dramatically by offering a triple play, that its savings would have paid for the US roll-out of Clearwire. With that understood, DirecTV would have sought ownership or part ownership, or eventual control, of Clearwire – which may have been a sticking point, despite McCaw’s history of selling companies to giants with an urgent need for his innovations.
Gaining a real foothold in the US triple play using BPL would take a long time, because DirecTV would need to bring enough power companies to the table, signing up those which were ready to take on what some see as a risky technology. By picking up deployment costs DirecTV, however, could provide the comfort they needed.
In the US, powerline works by using the mid-voltage circuits that span a city. The high voltage segment acts as a backbone and the low voltage elements reach too few homes to be used for the final delivery platform, as they are in Europe. In large apartment buildings in Europe, termination equipment can feed up to 500 homes with single or multiple 200Mbps links, bringing broadband straight out of the plug socket with the right adaptor. But in the US, where the average number of homes on a low voltage segment is about 15, the economics of that kind of deployment are not viable. But the mid-voltage segment reaches within 200 feet of every US home and Wi-Fi can make the last hop from the power pole to inside the home. The broadband backhaul can be a wireless fiber, line of sight link to multiple high points in the power network.
Companies like Amperion in Lowell, Massachusetts are perhaps the favorites for picking up a deal with DirecTV, while smaller operations like Ambient have been testing similar systems at Con Edison. Amperion’s existing installations might be used to trial services such as VoIP, broadband internet, and interactivity with TV programming.
If DirecTV does take the BPL route, it will dent the gloss of one of the brightest scenarios for WiMAX – the WiMAX/satellite hybrid (important not just to the wireless community but also the US hybrid satellite providers such as MSV). In mid-2005, whn Israeli start-up WiNetworks revealed that it was in talks with both DirecTV and EchoStar about the provision of key technology to allow WiMAX and a DVB-S signal to coexist on the same cable, running from a hybrid dual purpose antenna. Since then, we have been waiting for the direct-to-home companies in the US and elsewhere to come up with a WiMAX DVB-S hybrid. But in the absence of a major win in the US, other DTH suppliers around the world have been reticent to be the pioneers in this market. So if DirecTV adopts BPL, it will also hit companies like WiNetworks.
This is why a throwaway line from Chase Carey is not that at all. He will have mentioned broadband over power line with the very clear intention either of changing expectations about the way DirecTV will develop, or helping in current negotiations.
Although satellite DTH operators are the only pay TV market in the US that is growing (unless you count the fledgling efforts of Verizon and AT&T in IPTV), the marketing effort is huge, with churn rates of 1.9% per month, meaning that out of 14m customers, DirecTV has to find over 2m new subscribers a year just to stand still. It is widely believed that a triple, or even quadruple, play would reduce this churn to under half of what it is today, saving billions each year in marketing, deployment and customer premises equipment costs.
Carey is still understood to be considering adding this broadband component alongside rival EchoStar rather than going it alone, and may even develop a multi-tier strategy, using satellite, WiMAX and power in different areas. The BPL aspect would almost certainly use the UPA standard based around OFDM over power lines, with thousands of tiny carriers modulated between 2MHz and 34MHz on a power line, each delivering part of the overall data. This makes it easy to allocate some of the carriers to one function and some to another, making quality of service simpler to put in place.