Mobile satellite spectrum, once the most neglected and unprofitable of communications bands in the US, are now at the center of plans to expand mobile broadband capacity and boost competition. But as in previous times when there were bubbles, and over-ambitious ventures, around the MSS spectrum, the road to new services for US consumers is a rocky and highly political one. This is highlighted by the ups and downs of satellite TV major Dish Network’s attempts to become a wireless kingmaker. It has insufficient spectrum to create a high capacity network of its own, but enough to make it a strong candidate for a disruptive alliance ‘ with Google, suggest recent reports. But it needs the right FCC rules to make its plans to be an LTE-Advanced operator viable ‘ and though it received signs this week that the agency is likely to green-light its plan, it claims the restrictions threaten to make it non-competitive.
Such is the turbulence of this mobile satellite space. The first great hope for harnessing underused MSS bands for terrestrial LTE came with the LightSquared venture, now fighting its corner from bankruptcy protection after over-enthusiastic supporters of a disruptive LTE proposition failed to take account of the GPS community’s interference claims. That issue put paid to LightSquared’s hopes of a permanent waiver from the FCC, allowing it to run terrestrial-only LTE (as well as satellite or hybrid services, as permitted by its licences).
Dish Network, which acquired MSS spectrum from two other bankrupt MSS operators, has frequencies further from GPS, and moved to center stage once LightSquared was thwarted. It is at the heart of all kinds of reported adventures which could shake up the US market ‘ a wholesale system to support many service providers, as envisaged by LightSquared itself; an LTE-Advanced platform to integrate with its own TV offerings and provide innovative multiscreen options; or most radical of all, an alliance with Google to abet the search giant’s latest attempt to become a wireless operator.
First, it has to get what it believes to be the right conditions for its plans to thrive. This week, the FCC moved ahead with proposing rules to allow Dish to build LTE-Advanced in its frequencies. However Dish was not grateful for the relatively quick decision ‘ given the FCC’s need to be very cautious after its enthusiasm for LightSquared came back to bite it. Instead it lashed out at restrictions which would affect up to 5MHz of its spectrum (dubbed AWS-4 these days), saying the proposals were “significantly flawed’ and could ‘add years to a process that has already lasted 20 months’.
The FCC did not actually publish details of its latest proposals which, together with a separate plan to auction the H Block in the PCS band next year, would free up about 50MHz of spectrum for mobile broadband. However, its comments make it likely that it will approve terrestrial-only services in Dish’s 40MHz of spectrum in the 2GHz AWS-4 band, apparently green-lighting the TV provider’s plan to launch LTE-Advanced by 2016.
However, it indicated it would place technical rules on the spectrum to prevent interference with the PCS H Block frequencies, which will be sold off next year, and in which Sprint has expressed particular interest to boost its LTE capacity and add to its already fragmented patchwork of 4G spectrum (Sprint is refarming PCS and iDEN spectrum for 4G, and could also integrate the plentiful 2.5GHz frequencies of its Clearwire joint venture, a process that is likely to be accelerated if Japanese cellco Softbank gets approval to acquire a 70% stake in Sprint. However, it does not have significant holdings in AWS or 700MHz, the main bands being used for LTE by its three main rivals).
The FCC’s rules to avoid interference between AWS-4 and PCS H Block are likely to shift Dish’s spectrum at 2000-2020MHz upwards by 5MHz, taking it to 2005-2025MHz. Dish has argued against such a move, saying it would delay roll-out of its network and present problems with getting mainstream devices. It heated up the language of its opposition, saying in a statement: “While the FCC would grant full terrestrial rights, its proposal to lower our power and emissions levels could cripple our ability to enter the business. Until we know how to manage issues like interference from the H Block, we may have to put on hold activities like radio design and network build-out while we wait for the H Block rulemaking and another 3GPP process to be completed.”
It added that the likely FCC rule would effectively disable 25% of its uplink spectrum and ‘impair another 25% of that spectrum’.
There is a strong element of griping in Dish’s response. It must realize, in the wake of the LightSquared fiasco, how sensitive interference issues will be. These are increasingly becoming a brake for LTE spectrum progress in all developed markets, because as regulators cast around for new 4G capacity, they are forced to release bands which are very close together, by conventional radio thinking. New cognitive radio and ‘seek and avoid’ techniques are making this more practical, but most operators know they will never again be able to assume they can get clean spectrum in one or two bands, and with few rules attached ‘ instead, they will have to create the capacity they need by knitting together a patchwork of frequencies, many of them sub-optimal according to received wisdom, and many encumbered by rules to protect nearby incumbents. An extreme example is seen at AT&T, which has snapped up WCS (2.3GHz) spectrum to supplement its LTE reserves, despite having to work with nearby satellite radio incumbent SiriusXM on compromises to avoid interference with those services. AT&T is also using new supplemental downlink techniques to turn the one-way, unpaired TDD spectrum in 700MHz, which it acquired from Qualcomm, from trash to treasure (or at least a useful piece of additional capacity in its generally FDD 700MHz network). Here, AT&T is showing the kind of resourcefulness, flexibility and ability to negotiate with the FCC, which will be essential to a successful high capacity 4G strategy in future.
Dish could learn from this, because demanding perfect scenarios and whining about others’ concerns is not looking constructive. Even the device issue is less serious than it claims. In the fragmented world of LTE spectrum, where almost any frequency will be snapped up to add capacity, the device ecosystem is having to adapt to a highly multiband world. Of course, some bands are more universal than others and will command higher volumes and better economics in device chips, but by 2016, when Dish hopes to go live, the vendors will be very used to accommodating almost any frequency combination at affordable cost ‘ and software defined radio technology will have moved on to help.
Many analysts thought Dish should be looking on the bright side of the FCC’s latest comments. “Even if today’s order is approved, the core value of Dish’s spectrum remains mostly intact, as the vast majority of the utility of Dish’s spectrum is associated with its downlink, which remains untouched,” wrote Stefan Anninger of Credit Suisse in a research note.
Another analyst, Thomas Seitz of Jefferies, focused on the value of the spectrum, writing: “In our view, even if the FCC were to require Dish to make concessions for getting the terrestrial waiver, it nonetheless validates the value of Dish’s spectrum. In aggregate, Dish has 40MHz of AWS-4 spectrum nationwide that it had acquired under bankruptcy proceedings for about $3bn in mid-2011. We believe the value of the spectrum would be about $7bn, or $15 per Dish share.”
The value of the spectrum is important to Dish’s shareholders and its financing capabilities, though the firm has repeatedly denied claims that it acquired the MSS frequencies purely as assets to trade later, and insists it wants to build a new network for the US ‘ probably with a partner ‘ as long as the FCC will make it commercially viable.
Gerard Hallaren of Janco Partners put it more strongly in his own research note, writing: ‘Yesterday, Dish learned the FCC was likely to free 40MHz of ATC spectrum it obtained in purchasing bankrupt satellite operators ICO and Terrestar. Dish paid $2.4bn for this spectrum that, once fully cleared by the FCC, will likely be worth $7bn to $8bn. Instead of complimenting or thanking the FCC for the implied ruling, Dish’s press release complained the solution would delay its network roll-out. This is after complaining that the FCC was rushing it to build the network. We think Dish’s reaction is like Brer Rabbit begging not to be thrown in the briar patch.’
The FCC’s proposals seem to be strike a balance between letting Dish go ahead, and bringing the PCS H Block ‘ which many had expected to be left out of the spectrum map ‘ into play, probably to boost Sprint against the big two carriers. However, the far more interesting aspect of the shadowy Dish plans, of course, is who it will partner with. It has indicated it will need more spectrum capacity, and one option in future may be to tie up with LightSquared itself, should better solutions be found for allaying GPS fears. A less complicated choice would be a spectrum sharing deal, joint venture or even merger with an existing cellco, which would give Dish much needed channels, device partnerships and experience for the mobile market. Verizon and AT&T would be out on competition grounds, but Sprint has often been regarded as a likely future partner. This could be even more powerful once Softbank takes control, though the T-Mobile/MetroPCS combination would also be a candidate.
But much depends on how disruptive Dish aims to be of the existing US mobile norms. It has said it will use its network partly to add services for its own TV base, but has also hinted at supporting wholesale partners and possibly pushing forward the model advocated by Clearwire and LightSquared ‘ a more flexible approach than the rigid contracts of conventional MVNOs, instead supporting a wide range of service providers, which can target very specific services and target user bases. This idea was talked up by Clearwire, though imperfectly executed because of the dominance of Sprint. However, in the WiMAX operator’s early days, it was enough to attract investment from Google, which has sometimes proposed a completely on-demand approach to licensing spectrum and network capacity. This would allow even small service providers to use a wholesale network ‘ perhaps at certain times of day ‘ and pay per usage.
This ‘spectrum as a service’ approach would be hugely complicated to bring to reality, but it could be pioneered in a more modest way on a greenfield wholesale LTE network. This could be why Google is rumored to have its eye on an alliance with Dish, which would integrate the former’s fiber holdings ‘ valuable for backhaul and converged services ‘ with the latter’s mobile assets. According to The Wall Street Journal, the two companies are in talks, though these are at a very early stage, so may come to nothing.
Dish chairman Charlie Ergen said in an interview last week that some of the potential partners included companies ‘who would like to be in the industry’ but do not currently have a wireless business. And certainly, if the company does not launch until 2016, it will need a highly differentiated business model to make any impact on the major cellcos, which will have national coverage and their own LTE-Advanced upgrades by then.
For its part, Google has played with being a wireless operator for years, investing in various ventures which proved to be damp squibs ‘ metrozone Wi-Fi, WiMAX (via Clearwire) and even a threat to bid in the US 700MHz auctions. But in the US, it does have major fiber holdings, plus huge influence via Android and its web services, so its latest experiments are always closely watched.
A deal with Google would bring cash to the Dish venture, but it would be a partnership of two firms with no current RAN infrastructure or experience of the mobile business (though Google’s fiber would be a potentially important asset for backhaul). And we have always been deeply negative towards Google’s periodic attempts to become an operator in its own right. There have been numerous rumors over the years about its ambitions to become a carrier in its own right, in order to control the mobile user experience and advance its agenda of extending web access (and its own services) to everyone, while supporting hundreds of service providers on a wholesale network. All these remain important elements of the Google strategy, but will be best achieved by working with the operators and ensuring that they cannot avoid supporting the Google experience, applications and business model on their networks. As wireless access becomes embedded in non-phone devices, in the Kindle model, Google is quite likely to create its own MVNO to support its widening device activities but there is no need to own a network in order to provide a Nexus gadget with inbuilt connectivity. Indeed, this is a more effective way to marginalize the carriers’ brand than going head-to-head with them in their own territory and would also allow Google to control the user experience and the process of upgrading to new Android releases ‘ key areas of conflict with cellcos.
But again, an actual network is not required to change those rules. In fact, many of Google’s apparent moves to become an operator, particularly its politicking around the 700MHz auction, have really been moves to put pressure on conventional operators or to test new technologies ‘ not to turn into a fully fledged cellco. We believe it will be the same this time, though the search giant will certainly be keen to promote an alternative operator which it could ‘help’ by partnering closely on Android and web services ‘ which in turn would influence the device ecosystem in Dish’s favour. But while an alliance would be probable and beneficial, and could even extend to some financial or fiber terms, Dish will have to look elsewhere for a full network co-owner.
Globalstar petitions FCC:
Also in the mobile satellite area, MSS phone operator Globalstar has petitioned the FCC to give it permission to use its spectrum for terrestrial mobile services too. It is proposing two separate but complementary terrestrial offerings over its exclusively licensed ‘Big LEO’ spectrum. Oonen would be an LTE service over its whole footprint, and the other would be a TLPS (terrestrial low power service) in its 2.4GHz spectrum. The latter would be a far quicker project to deploy while the former would be a longer term plan rather like Dish’s.
Globalstar is asking for rule changes to allow the provision of TLPS within its spectrum at 2483MHZ.5-2495MHz (AWS-5) and adjacent unlicensed ISM (Industrial, Scientific, and Medical Equipment) frequencies at 2473MHz-2483.5MHz. The company said that using this combined 22MHz of capacity for TLPS would alleviate congestion in existing 802.11 ISM channels (Wi-Fi), increasing available Wi-Fi capacity in the US by one-third. If Globalstar gets permission, it says it will build out 20,000 free TLPS access points in schools, colleges and hospitals, and will provide its mobile satellite services free of charge to its customers in any federally declared disaster area.
The latest US 4G developments:
The constant process of shifting spectrum assets, as the operators try to stitch together their patchworks in as rational a way as possible, continues in a far more modest way than the big deals such as Dish, Sprint/Softbank, Verizon/cablecos or T-Mobile/MetroPCS. Just this month there has been a string of agreements in LTE spectrum and networks:
US Cellular is to sell some of its major midwestern markets and spectrum to Sprint Nextel for $480m as it seeks to streamline its operations. The Tier two carrier will also cut the majority of its retail, engineering and business support workers after the deal closes. It will offload its Chicago, St. Louis and central Illinois markets, and three others in the Midwest, transferring PCS spectrum and around 585,000 customers, or about 10% of its base. Sprint will get an additional 20MHz of 1.9GHz spectrum in some of the markets, including Chicago, and 10MHz in St Louis. The move will make US Cellular smaller but more profitable and so better placed to go ahead with its delayed LTE roll-out. It will have 5.2m customers after the transfer, which highlights how the value of traditional 2G spectrum has increased now that refarming for LTE is becoming commonplace.
As Sprint closes down the iDEN service it acquired with Nextel, in order to refarm that spectrum for LTE, the remaining customers are being targeted by AT&T, which has announced its own version of the key service which kept subscribers loyal to Nextel, push-to-talk. AT&T has announced full availability of its Enhanced Push-to-Talk offering as well as new smartphones for the service. Sprint will switch off iDEN by mid-2013 and has been migrating users to its CDMA PTT alternative, DirectConnect. AT&T said its Enhanced PTT service will cost $5 a month when added to existing AT&T voice and data plans or $30 per month on its own. The service uses technology from Kodiak Networks, the main PTT alternative to Sprint’s. It will be preinstalled on a handful of handsets including the Samsung Galaxy Rugby Pro, the Samsung Rugby III, the BlackBerry Bold 9900 and the BlackBerry Curve 9360. Sprint has about one million CDMA PTT subscribers and 3m iDEN customers.
Cellular One has entered into an agreement with Verizon Wireless to participate in its LTE in Rural America program. Under the agreement, Verizon Wireless will lease its 700MHz Upper C Block spectrum in parts of Texas and its partner will construct and operate an LTE network serving customers of both cellcos and other LTE in Rural America participants. Cellular One customers will also have access to Verizon Wireless’ LTE network throughout the US.
Alaska Communications has also introduced LTE services to customers throughout Alaska’s urban areas in Anchorage, Fairbanks, Juneau, Homer, Kenai, Palmer, Seward, Soldotna, Wasilla and Whittier, in a 32m project.
Verizon Wireless expects to complete the sale of parts of its A and B Block 700MHz spectrum in the first half of 2013, something it agreed to do once it won approval for its AWS spectrum deal with four cablecos and Leap. AT&T was expected to make a bid but so far there have small fragmented deals rather than a big purchase. Verizon has so far sold two separate rural licences ‘ 10MHz in 12 northwest Texas counties to Panhandle Telecommunications, and 12MHz in four counties, also in Texas, to Nortex Communications. Prior to its cableco deal being green-lighted, Verizon said it had agreed sales to seven more operators covering 24 licences and these are still in the pipeline along with others under evaluation. AT&T may move for some of the most attractive assets Verizon is offering, such as 12MHz in Chicago and holdings in many other big cities including Los Angeles and New York. Another high value Chicago licence was already included in a swap with Leap.
AT&T has doubled the reach of its LTE network from a year ago and now covers more than 150m people across the US. It aims to reach 250m POPs by the end of next year and 300m by the end of 2014 and like Verizon ‘ which it still lags significantly ‘ its roll-out is ahead of schedule. Its 4G services are currently available in 103 markets. Verizon now covers 440 markets with LTE and 250m people, thanks to its earlier start. Sprint now offers LTE in 32 cities while T-Mobile will not start roll-out until next year. T-Mobile says it will cover 200m people by the end of 2013 using 10x10MHz of spectrum, though the MetroPCS spectrum will enable it to boost that to 20x20MHx in many markets. MetroPCS has already rolled out LTE to 97% of its footprint.
T-Mobile USA named former Clearwire executive Mike Sievert as its new CMO, placing him in charge of the brand as the cellco moves towards finalizing its merger with MetroPCS next year. TMo has been without a permanent CMO since Cole Brodman stepped down in May.
The FCC is seeking comment on LightSquared’s latest proposal to salvage its MSS L-band spectrum and deploy LTE. The bankrupt operator wants to share spectrum that is currently set aside for weather balloons used by the federal government. In exchange, it said it would permanently relinquish the 10MHz of spectrum that is next door to GPS receivers.
The FCC is to push forward a proposal that its chairman, Julius Genachowski, said would “enable new commercial use of 100MHz of spectrum in the 3.5GHz band, while protecting government missions that are vital to our national interest.’ The agency wants this federal spectrum to be shared for small cells.