Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 March 2013

Docomo blazes a trail for AAS, a key enabler of the HetNet

The further vendors and operators move along up 3GPP release ladder, the more antennas emerge from the shadows to become strategically important to the success of an LTE or LTE-Advanced network. MIMO arrays with more and more elements, and active antenna technologies for flexible multimode, multiband base stations, are increasingly vital, and operators are looking for standards work to be accelerated to ensure affordability and interoperability.

In the run-up to Mobile World Congress, NTT Docomo took the lead in showing off the way advanced cellcos will harness new antennas, while the NGMN (Next Generation Mobile Network) alliance supported standards for base station antennas.

Docomo was implementing technology in two critical areas of base station antenna development for mobile broadband ‘ support for more and more LTE bands, and support for emerging AAS (Active Antenna System) standards.

Supporting multiple bands is one of the major headaches of LTE, because of the fragmentation of the available spectrum. The problem is magnified in Japan, where band plans are often outside the global norm, requiring specialized equipment and increasing cost. NTT Docomo often goes as far as to develop infrastructure elements itself, or in partnership with a supplier, as seen in its new antenna moves. For the spectrum challenge, it has created a five-band LTE antenna inhouse, looking to add its newly acquired 700MHz spectrum to its existing 3G and 4G bands over the coming couple of years.

It followed that up with news that it had successfully connected an active antenna to a commercial LTE base station. Such demonstrations are important because AAS technology is in its infancy and many carriers remain nervous of deploying it, despite its ability to reduce the cost and complexity of rolling out multiband 2G/3G/LTE systems. The evolution of the active antenna will soon allow cellcos to take several steps forward in network terms, pushing distributed RAN and HetNet ideas to new limits. It is a very new approach in standardized terms ‘ the 3GPP only set up an AAS study group in mid-2011. Most immediately, AAS promises to enable operators to squeeze more life and performance out of their macrocells before they have to build up capacity with new investments in small cell meshes. Looking ahead, it will also be a key enabler of HetNet.

Cell site architectures are evolving rapidly to respond to cellcos’ need to support high data rates and loads; to run 2G, 3G and 4G networks in parallel; and to cope with multiple frequency bands. These challenges have driven significant changes in the radio architecture, notably with the increasing distribution of the RAN. The digital, baseband portion of the large radio unit has been split from the analog RF element, the remote radio unit (RRU) and this RRU located closer to the antenna, linked back to the baseband by fiber. In evolving architectures, baseband processing is virtualized in a shared resource, perhaps in the cloud (in Cloud-RAN). Then the next stage has been the full integration of the radio and antenna, as in products such as Ericsson’s AIR. With AAS, the radio functionality is also distributed along the antenna elements, reducing footprint and power and increasing flexibility in network design.

Docomo’s antenna was jointly developed by Japanese antenna maker Dengyo Kosaku and Ubidyne of Germany, the latter a pioneer in active antenna chips, and a platform that allows radios to be distributed along the antenna to reduce power. Dengyo had contracted Ubidyne to adapt its existing 700MHz active antenna platform for 800MHz LTE, 3GPP band 19 requirements, along with the integration of an operator defined CPRI interface and full RF system testing. The complete 800MHz AAS system is expected to be deployed with a major regional network operator in 2013, said the Japanese company. Dengyo developed an advanced antenna housing, while Ubidyne implemented the operator proprietary CPRI interface. This is based on a Ubidyne specific framework that supports fast adoption of CPRI integration.

‘Since Japanese domestic frequency bands are different to the rest of the world, an off-the-shelf 800MHz LTE active antenna solution was not available to Dengyo,’ said Michael Fr’nkle, CEO of Ubidyne. ‘By working with Ubidyne, Dengyo was able to expand its range of passive antennas with a field-ready, industry leading active antenna solution for live network operator trials in just seven months.’

Tests of Ubidyne’s LTE 700MHz embedded radio technology have shown double throughput at the cell edge together with reduced output power of the terminal and an increase of over 40% cell capacity with the same output power, says the vendor. These highlight some of the benefits of AAS for cellcos. Others include reduced site footprint and cost, and maintenance or installation bills; built-in redundancy because the radio functions are distributed among multiple elements; and support for multiple, even non-contiguous bands.

The most important aspects for future, complex HetNets concern flexible RF and beamforming. Because RF components like power amplifiers and transceivers ‘ conventionally part of the base station ‘ are integrated with the antenna in AAS, the signals from each antenna element can be separately shaped and steered. This allows for flexibility in RF planning, to maximize capacity and coverage, and so reduce cost and potentially site numbers. With independent baseband control of individual carriers on each antenna element, operators using three or four carriers can tune each one independently, perhaps to meet high peak data rates by reducing interference. Or tuning can be done by air interfaces sharing the same frequency, an important issue where carriers are gradually refarming a 2G band for 3G or 4G. For instance, W-CDMA at 900MHz could be tilted to deliver more focused coverage than GSM at 900MHz. Where cellcos are sharing a RAN, AAS can tilt signals for individual operators, allocating resources independently to meet the needs of each partner.

As LTE roll-outs cover a rising number of bands and air interfaces, AAS architectures will evolve from single-band arrays to more complex combinations of active and passive antenna arrays. Typically, the active elements will be used to deploy new 4G services while the passive equipment will support legacy networks. Also, a carrier will often add AAS to support a new frequency band, alongside the traditional passive equipment in the existing frequencies. They will also increasingly come in wideband configurations which can support virtually the whole LTE spectrum range.

Another important evolving technology associated with AAS is 3D beamforming. Since the radios are distributed along the antenna, they can carry out different types of beamforming compared to their monolithic cousins, including splitting a sector vertically rather than horizontally, which allows transmit and receive activities to be separated. That gives a cellco new efficiency options, such as turning up the receive element to get a better signal from the edge of the cell, while keeping transmit low to reduce interference with an adjacent cell. This can be significant for uplink performance and for delivering more consistent quality of experience throughout a macrocell, whereas in conventional antennas, the carrier has to make a difficult trade-off between signal strength/coverage and interference. Coverage can also be extended to higher vertical planes such as tall buildings, without altering transmit power (because the amount of energy delivered by the base station is more concentrated on the target user).

None of this will move from early adopters into the carrier mainstream, however, without the economics and reassurances of standardization. The most significant element of Docomo’s test with the Ubidyne technology was that it connected its antenna to its base station via an interface based on ORI, the emerging standard which carriers hope will lower costs and allow them to implement multivendor networks (for this reason, some major base station OEMs have not been over-supportive of ORI, as they cling to the old lock-ins). Currently active antennas and base stations need to be made by the same vendor because of the lack of a standard interface between the elements.

ORI is an ETSI specification already supported in Docomo’s heavily customized base stations, but winning NGMN backing is an important step to seeing it universally adopted by BTS vendors. The Japanese carrier said ORI will allow it to install active antennas quickly and inexpensively without having to set up new base stations. It also said it would submit the results of its test to the 3GPP to contribute to the standardization of future active antennas.

ORI has won backing from the operator driven NGMN Alliance, which has just published a white paper called ‘Recommendation for Base Station Antenna Standards’. This addresses four main topics – recommendations on standards for electrical and mechanical parameters; detailed methodologies for the analysis, calculation, and validation of antenna specifications; guidance on best practices used in measurements for design validation and in production testing; and recommendations on applying existing environmental and reliability standards to base station antennas.

Kevin Linehan, CTO for antenna systems at CommScope, was the project lead. He said: ‘The NGMN is an excellent forum for facilitating the kind of expert collaboration that was needed to generate an industry consensus on a topic as complex and network critical as antenna performance. We believe that the adoption of these guidelines will provide significant benefits to wireless operators and their customers.’

Active antennas remain rare in commercial roll-outs as yet though they are increasingly prominent in vendors’ portfolios as the trend to distributed RANs takes off. Nokia Siemens was an early mover, working on experimental deployments with Vodafone back in 2009, and supporting AAS in its Flexi platform. Huawei was involved in a UK roll-out last year and CommScope and Ubidyne conducted a trial with an unnamed US cellco in 700MHz in late 2011. All the large OEMs have AAS programs, supported by the antenna makers such as CommScope and Kathrein, and technology enablers like Ubidyne. On top of all this work, standardization, rising acceptance of distributed RAN concepts, and the need to squeeze greater efficiencies out of existing cells will all accelerate adoption from late 2013.

And even before active antennas are actually deployed by more than a handful of carriers, their remit is changing. Cellcos do want to use them to enhance the performance of their conventional macrocells and microcells, but they are also asking whether AAS could ease the path to HetNets that combine cells of all sizes in different spectrum bands and layers of capacity. To create HetNets, the first step is effective network planning ‘ finding usage hotspots in which to install small cells, harnessing active antennas to improve the rate and range of larger sites. The next step is to create ‘adaptive’ networks, in which cells ‘breathe’ in and out according to the number and type of users at any one time. This requires the signal effectively to follow the user around, and architectures such as Nokia Siemens’ Liquid Network aim to shift resources, from cell site to core and backhaul, dynamically where they are needed.

Combining flexible active antennas with self-organizing network (SON) techniques can contribute to this goal, since it allows more precise and dynamic steering of the beam, to focus capacity exactly where it is needed. SON promises to enable the optimization of AAS parameters according to real world traffic patterns, location and user demand. That will eventually result in automated ‘user-tracking beamforming’, in which the beam follows the user around and allocates the most appropriate resources. Ultimately, many cells will be created from a single antenna.