Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 May 2015

Drones and satellite bands – everything on the table for US mobile broadband

The US is looking well beyond traditional cellular frequency bands and backhaul options in its hunt for new mobile broadband spectrum. As it prepares to open up the 3.5 GHz band and, next year, auction the 600 MHz broadcast spectrum, the FCC is also engaged in projects ranging from satellite bands to drones.

Google, of course, has been testing drones – as well as tethered balloons and other mechanisms – to support broader wireless broadband delivery. This month, it has supported an FCC proposal to authorize the study of high-altitude platform stations (HAPS) to deliver broadband. These stations are 20-50 kilometers above ground – high enough to cover large areas, but low enough to support dense coverage and low latency.

The definition could encompass the drones which Google is developing, the firm argues. These circle at about 20 kilometers up, to maintain coverage of a constant service area on the ground, and since they are nominally ‘fixed’, they could be considered as HAPS, goes the argument.

Google’s director or communications law, Austin Schlick, met FCC legal advisors on May 15, according to a filing, to discuss the investment, by the search giants and others, in unmanned aerial systems (UAS) for delivering broadband to the underserved, and for disaster relief (since HAPS are located above weather incidents and are resilient to storms beneath them).

While tests of unmanned aircraft at high altitudes for broadband service are a new phenomenon, high altitude base stations have been studied by the ITU for two decades and are defined, in Article 1.66A of the Radio Regulations, as “a station located on an object at an altitude of 20 to 50 km and at a specified, nominal, fixed point relative to the Earth”. But the economics will only work if more flexible geographic and spectral definitions are adopted, and Google thinks lightweight drones, nominally operating from a fixed position, are a strong solution. It is pushing the FCC to adopt the proposed HAPS study and to include drones in that.

Meanwhile, another way to increase wireless broadband capacity is to harness the underused mobile satellite (MSS) bands. This was a pet project of the FCC until the LightSquared project, to build a national wholesale LTE network in MSS frequencies, foundered on claims of interference with GPS systems. However, Dish Network is planning an LTE roll-out, some of it in different MSS frequencies (now called AWS-4, and a safe distance from GPS), and more radically, satellite operator Globalstar has been lobbying the FCC since 2012 for the right to use a WiFi-like technology, terrestrial low power service (TLPS).

Services running TPLS could use WiFi devices, but in a private licensed band with none of the interference risks of the usual, unlicensed WiFi spectrum. Globalstar has proposed hosting services for third parties, including carriers looking to add capacity to mobile networks, and other service providers (Globalstar’s test and R&D partner is Amazon).

The idea received a boost last week when a partner in Ignition Partners, an early stage venture capital firm, expressed support in a filing with the FCC. “New entrants into any competitive sector of the communications industry are typically vital to the pace of development while slower moving incumbents attempt to limit available offerings and prevent anything truly innovative or disruptive like TLPS,” wrote Adrian Smith.

“We see the same thing happening by incumbents attempting to ‘commoditize’ unlicensed offerings. In a world of limited spectrum supply, operators on existing usable bands will likely only provide increased resistance to efforts to free up spectrum for its higher and best use. With TLPS, situated at the edge of a critical band in 2.4 GHz which has been the backbone of the nation’s and the world’s wireless operations, we can benefit from an operator actively pushing to use its spectrum more intensively for terrestrial broadband. This is exactly the type of policy the Commission should be setting.”

Smith has track record to back up his arguments, having held positions at British Telecom Research Laboratories, Nextlink, AT&T Wireless and McCaw Cellular. Ignition Partners’ founders include Steve Hooper, who worked closely with Craig McCaw – the father of the US mobile networks via McCaw Cellular, and the founder of Clearwire – for 18 years and was CEO of every major McCaw Company except Nextel.

Globalstar’s long term investors have been supportive of TLPS but some WiFi groups are urging the FCC not to authorize the technology in the 2473-2495 MHz band, saying tests have not proved that the system will behave as a ‘good neighbor’ to WiFi and Bluetooth in 2.4 GHz. One opponent, Greg Gerst of Gerst Capital, recently wrote in a filing that TLPS has undergone basic “customer level” demonstrations but nothing approaching engineering “system testing”. “As a former engineer and manager of wireless communication system development and test organizations, I understand the difference between a product ‘demonstration’ and system level product ‘test’,” Gerst wrote in the filing.

However, one WiFi player, aggregator iPass, has submitted its own filing in support of Globalstar. It says the FCC’s proposed rules would deliver enormous benefits to iPass’ network and its customers by adding channel capacity at a time when there is rising congestion in 2.4 GHz.