Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 April 2018

Ericsson remains too reliant on 5G despite some Q1 improvements

There were signs of improvement in Ericsson’s latest quarterly results, but its over-reliance on 5G materializing quickly remains worrying – especially just days after the head of arch-rival Huawei had downplayed the significance of 5G for short term growth.

The statements from the two companies’ chiefs certainly took different tones about the new mobile network. At Ericsson, CEO Börje Ekholm said in a statement about the first quarter 2018 results: “Looking ahead, we expect the rapidly increasing focus on 5G to continue, with initial business discussions focusing on enhanced mobile broadband. We continue to work closely with customers to define the optimal business models to enable them to tap into new revenue streams and capture the full value of 5G.”

Over in Shenzhen, at Huawei’s annual global analyst summit, rotating chairman Eric Xu said consumers would see “no fundamental difference” between 5G and LTE for a long time to come, given the strength and continuing evolution of 4G. However, he said vendors and operators would continue to invest in 5G. “If you are not good at 5G, customers won’t buy from you even for 4G,” he said. As for MNOs, “if one says, ‘I have a 5G-enabled network’, the rest really have to launch 5G even if it’s just for branding or marketing purposes.”

The rather sceptical approach from the industry’s largest vendor highlights the concern that Ericsson is pinning too many hopes on a short term uptick in its core networks business, driven by 5G, especially since Ekholm has reversed his predecessor’s efforts to diversify the business, and has retrenched to traditional mobile equipment activities.

However, the aggressive cost cutting and the tighter focus are delivering some benefits, even though sales are still in decline. In Q118, sales fell 9% year-on-year to SEK43.4bn ($5.14bn – though only down 2% at constant currency). But gross margin was up sharply, from 16% a year ago to 34% (40% in Networks), and that is an endorsement of Ekholm’s decision to prioritize profitability over sales growth (although excluding one-off items, the leap was less dramatic, from 31% a year ago to 36%).

In the Networks business, sales fell 9.5% year-on-year from SEK31.6bn to SEK28.6bn (but were down 2% year-on-year at constant currency). The fall was blamed on lower LTE investments in mainland China and the completion of some large projects in south east Asia last year. On the bright side, the company said there was “momentum” in north America and that investments in R&D were starting to pay off, while gross margin had improved across hardware and services. The star of this business unit, as in the past few quarters, was the Ericsson Radio System (ERS), the company’s “5G-ready” platform which allows operators to buy an LTE network now and upgrade it in software to 5G at the appropriate time, as well as swapping various 5G-related enhancements, such as Massive MIMO, in when required (even before the radio upgrade).

There may have been slim pickings in terms of good news, but the stock markets were cheered anyway and Ericsson’s shares rose in Stockholm on the announcement. The start of visible impact of cost-cutting on margins, and the greater robustness of the critical Networks unit, were the main reasons to be cheerful. Other main units – digital services and managed services, in particular – declined.

But both these areas of hope may prove tougher to improve in the coming quarters. Cost cutting will inevitably be a game of diminishing returns after a few high impact quarters. Ericsson’s target is to reduce annual costs by SEK10bn ($1.2bn) by the middle of this year. It says it has already made savings of SEK8.5bn ($1bn) across a 12-month period, though these are not all visible in the quarterly results yet. And the RAN market is not expected to see sharp growth, even if 5G does live up to Ericsson’s hopes. The vendor said it expects the RAN equipment market to fall by 2% this year, but to show a compound annual growth rate of 2% between 2018 and 2022.

“The improvements in the quarter are encouraging,” Ekholm said. “However, more work remains to be done. We have confidence in the strategic direction laid out and remain fully committed to our long term targets.”

R&D spending rose from SEK31.6bn ($3.8bn) in 2016 to SEK37.9bn ($4.5bn) last year, and Ericsson today said it had recruited another 500 engineers for its 5G business despite losing about 3,000 jobs elsewhere.

Ekholm said: “A cornerstone in our strategy is to invest in R&D for both technology leadership and cost leadership, which will allow us to generate higher gross margins. We continue to increase our R&D investments in Networks to lead in 5G. In Digital Services we continue to increase investments into our new cloud-native portfolio as well as changing our ways of working for better R&D efficiency. In Managed Services we continue to focus on machine intelligence, automation and analytics to further enhance user experience, improve efficiency and better manage the increasingly complex networks of tomorrow.”

The digital services business reported sales of SEK7.7bn ($910m), down from SEK8.4bn ($1bn) a year earlier, but narrowed its operating loss from SEK8.8bn ($1bn) to SEK2bn ($240m).

The managed services unit reversed a year-ago operating loss of SEK1.7bn ($200m) to turn in a profit of SEK100m ($12m) on sales which fell about 8%, to SEK5.5bn ($650m).