Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 July 2007

Ericsson-TI alliance sets out the new pattern of the handset silicon industry

Critics of Texas Instruments claim that the company has taken its eye off the ball in its crucial handset chip business recently, ceding a series of market firsts (and now its market lead, according to iSuppli) to Qualcomm, and relying too heavily on its close alliance with Nokia, even as the Finnish giant explicitly moves to broaden its own ecosystem and work with a wider range of suppliers. Last week saw the start of the TI kickback against such accusations, as it took a decisive move into the full handset reference platform space, another area where it has previously lagged behind Qualcomm and even Freescale. It has attracted the support of Ericsson, which is itself putting new fire under its handset reference design activities, moving its once-obscure Mobile Platforms unit further towards the center of its growth strategy.

The two giants will co-develop solutions for handsets, initially for HSDPA, with future projects on HSUPA and LTE. These will be complete reference designs to enable OEMS to bring advanced devices to market more quickly and cheaply, and to customize them more easily for different operators’ requirements. Once an approach more commonly offered to mid-tier ODMs, full platforms are now being adopted by the major handset makers too, as they respond to operator pressure to update cellphones more quickly and easily, and support functions such as user customized devices ‘ all of which means differentiating through software rather than hardware. While TI has not gone as far as Qualcomm in seeking to support those software activities along with its chips (Qualcomm has put its Brew and UIone software technologies at the heart of its expansion plan), it does need to regain momentum in open handset platforms, making the Ericsson deal highly significant.

The products the pair will create will be based on TI’s OMAP applications processors and Ericsson Mobile Platforms’ low power 3G modems, and will be operating system-neutral and geared to high end and midrange multimedia handsets, currently the fastest growing sector of the market for Qualcomm, and an area where TI needs to snatch back the initiative (see separate item). The integrated modem and apps processor will be the heart of a pre-verified and tested reference design, which will go through the Ericsson Mobile Platforms IOT interoperability testing process. The operating systems directly supported will be Symbian Series 60, as used by Nokia and others; Symbian with the UIQ interface technology, the main platform for Ericsson’s joint venture with Sony; Windows Mobile; and various flavours of Mobile Linux. Ericsson brings a stable model protocol stack and proven RF technology to the deal, according to the head of the Mobile Platforms group, Robert Puskaric. This technology is installed in 40m W-CDMA devices, while OMAP processors have shipped in 100m handsets.

Ericsson claims there is no conflict of interest in creating open platforms that could potentially offer advantages to Sony Ericsson’s competitors ‘ given that most of that competitive advantage now comes from software. Handsets based on the HSDPA platform should be available in the second half of 2008.

The agreement highlights the shift in the long-established relationship between TI and Nokia, whose former resemblance to Siamese twins is fading. For the past two years, Nokia has been broadening its supply chain and becoming less reliant on TI, which depends on the Finnish company for about 15% of its revenue (see Wireless Watch September 16 2005). Nokia has been working with a broad range of semiconductor providers, aiming to lower its costs by introducing more suppliers and more competition into its supply line, but also to create a best of breed composite platform that will, it believes, be harder for the Intel PC-centric mobile model to challenge. It has created a powerful ecosystem around itself, with RF Micro Devices and STMicro the most reliant on its favors (the former, at one stage, took a massive 38% of its revenues from Nokia, though it is now in recovery mode, spreading its wings into the wireless IP sector and starting to bounce back from a decline in sales to Motorola). Other key, and growing, suppliers to Nokia are Infineon and Skyworks.

Of course, TI is at least safe from losing any business at this premier customer to Qualcomm, given the history between the CDMA giant and Nokia ‘ even before the current legal battles, the Finnish giant arguably shot itself in the foot in the CDMA handset market by adamantly refusing to buy any silicon from Qualcomm, instead going through successive failed attempts to create an alternative source in collaboration with TI and STMicro. However, Qualcomm is certainly starting to encroach on TI’s natural habitat, and has trumped the DSP supremo on various occasions, with earlier and better execution in advanced HSDPA, and with a more decisive move to platforms. In the battle between these two, Motorola ‘ despite its own troubles and currently reduced buying power ‘ remains the key target, especially since the end of its special relationship with Freescale. Nokia excludes Qualcomm, while Samsung is a less useful barometer because of its own chip activities and its heavy involvement in CDMA.

Last November, Qualcomm struck first in the tussle for post-Freescale Moto, and confirmed its ability to compete at the highest level outside its native CDMA territory, when it announced that it would provide Motorola with UMTS chips and work with it on future 3G phones. Motorola will use Qualcomm’s single-chip solution to lower its costs and drive 3G into broader consumer markets and emerging economies, expanding a relationship that had focused in the past almost entirely on CDMA, and dealing a blow to former Motorola chip unit Freescale.

Just two months later, TI hit back, forming a close alliance with Motorola that not only reassured investors that it could cope with a potential distancing from Nokia, but also sent aggressive signals to Marvell and Freescale in the high end cellphone processor market (see Wireless Watch February 5 2007). This deal saw Motorola muscling in on the ‘special relationship’ between TI and Nokia, which has helped define the handset market for so long; and TI getting serious about WiMAX, a technology where it can certainly steal a march on Qualcomm, at least until the latter makes up its mind about its own 802.16 strategy (if any). TI is to create customized chips for Motorola for upcoming 3G handsets, to be available from next year, and will supply WiMAX handset chips, also from 2008. It will develop custom WiMAX chipsets, including baseband DSPs and analog/RF components, as well as offering process, foundry and design expertise. Perhaps most importantly, it will provide products built around the OMAP-2, OMAP-3 and OMAP-Vox apps processors, and its affordable platform, eCosto, currently for GSM/GPRS but planned for future 3G models. This will be brand new revenue – TI has supplied lower end chips to Motorola for years, but has been largely excluded from high margin products like application processors by the company’s former links to Freescale.

Such deals reflect the increasing intensity of the Qualcomm-TI battle, as both companies face the prospect of having to reduce their reliance on elements of their business model they had long taken for granted (IPR revenues in the former’s case, Nokia’s unswerving support in the latter’s). They also show the need for the leading chipmakers to consolidate their position rapidly as the handset market increasingly falls into the hands of the largest players, and as integrated platforms take the place of composite, vendor-specific designs based on components from many sources. Such developments will make tier two and three suppliers of RF front ends, basebands or applications processors, which cannot offer an integrated platform directly or via an alliance, highly vulnerable. They will even put stress on some of the major handset chip vendors, in particular Infineon and Freescale, given the decline of the latter’s sales to Motorola, (which last year accounted for over 25% of its business, notwithstanding the company’s growth in some other markets such as automotive). Both companies have followed Qualcomm down the platforms route in a bid to bolster their position, and Freescale made major announcements in this respect at its recent Technology Forum, but is likely to become more dependent on markets where it can take a clearer lead, including the emerging home automation sector.

One winner in the new handset map will surely be Ericsson, which is skilfully turning the trends towards integrated platforms and supplier consolidation to its own advantage, maximizing the reach of its RF technologies and its IPR. In doing so, it will be striking another blow at the IPR dominance of Qualcomm, a war in which the Swedish company has so far been less active than Nokia, but in which it will be just as willing to harness its alliances with TI in order to put pressure on the common enemy.

Texas Instruments’ figures:

Texas Instruments saw a fall in demand across its product lines in the second quarter, which helped cause a 7% drop in revenue, year-on-year, to $3.42bn. Net income crashed from $2.4bn to $610m, though this was partly because of a windfall from the sale of TI’s sensors business, for $1.65bn, in the year-ago quarter.

TI said it expects revenue in the third quarter to reach $3.49bn-$3.79bn.

The European chipmakers:

Infineon saw its net loss widen in its third quarter, but this was largely down to poor performance at its memory chip unit Qimonda, while its wireless activities showed signs of recovery. The pre-tax operating loss at the unit shrank to €34m from a loss of €61m in the year-earlier quarter, as sales came in at €259m, below the €266m booked in the same quarter a year ago but a 9% improvement from the second quarter of fiscal 2007.

STMicroelectronics suffered a heavy loss in the second quarter on charges related to the contribution of its flash memory business to a joint venture, and revenue fell from the year-ago quarter but improved sequentially on strong contributions from its wireless and digital consumer markets. The Swiss company reported a net loss of $758m, or 84 cents per share, in the quarter, compared with net income of $168m, or 18 cents per share, in the second quarter of 2006. Revenue rose 6 % from the first quarter but fell 3% from the second quarter of 2006 to $2.42bn, matching average analyst estimates. It also signed an agreement with IBM to collaborate on the development of next generation semiconductor process technology, in order to share cost and risk. The deal covers 32nm and 22nm CMOS processes and ‘design enablement and advanced research adapted to the manufacturing of 300-millimeter silicon wafers.’.

NXP Semiconductors, the spin-out from Philips, warned that the chip market remains soft and said it anticipates only single-digit sequential growth in sales for the third quarter. It announced second quarter sales of €1.14bn, almost the same as for the previous quarter, and a 4.6% drop over the year-ago period. Profits for the second quarter were €7m compared to €64m in the second quarter of 2006 and €3m in the first quarter of 2007. NXP said it was expanding its efforts in developing Wireless USB and will invest € 90m over the next five years in R&D in this technology.