Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 December 2020

Ericsson warns of profit hit from Q1 as a result of Samsung patent dispute

Unlike some years, 2020 has not seen a high level of large patent disputes in the cellular industry, but Ericsson may be setting the tone for 2021, filing a lawsuit against Samsung in Texas, and claiming that operating income of between $120m and $177m per quarter are at stake.

The two vendors last clashed in the patent courts in 2012, but settled their differences two years later. This time, Ericsson is accusing Samsung – which is increasingly contending for a place at the top table in the 5G RAN market – of “violating contractual commitments to negotiate in good faith” on the renewal of certain patent licences.

The lawsuit was filed in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Texas. It arose when negotiations over renewing a global cross-licensing agreement for both firms’ essential patents came to a stalemate. Ericsson accuses its rival of violating contractual commitments to negotiate on licence patents on a FRAND (fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory) basis, while Ericsson claims to have upheld its side of that mutual commitment. FRAND terms, governed by French law, are at the basis of all patent licensing norms, but can be rather vaguely defined in legal terms.

The Swedish firm warned that several licence renewal negotiations “may delay the payment of IP royalties if they extend beyond the expiry of existing licences into an unlicensed period.” Those delays, combined with legal costs, could impact quarterly operating income by between SEK1bn ($120m) and SEK1.5bn ($177m), starting from the first quarter of 2021, warned Ericsson.

Janardan Menon, an analyst at Liberum, told Reuters that royalties from Ericsson’s patent portfolio are expected to bring in about one-third of its forecast operating profit for 2021, of SEK29bn ($3.4bn). The lawsuit could reduce that figure by 20% per quarter, he estimates. That sent Ericsson’s share price down by 7%, though if the case is settled, and the licences renewed, in reasonably short order, unpaid royalty fees will be recovered.

Ericsson says it initiated negotiations for a new licence in January 2019, and this included a balancing payment from Samsung to Ericsson, “reflecting the parties’ relative sales and the value of Ericsson’s essential patents as compared to Samsung’s,” the complaint says. It claims that both parties “understood that Samsung would owe Ericsson a substantial balancing payment”.

Ericsson says it has more than 54,000 patents worldwide, many essential, and reinvests many of the royalty fees back into its annual R&D spend of $4bn to $5bn, which in turn helps contribute to future standards.

“It has become clear Samsung had no intention of negotiating in good faith towards concluding an agreement with Ericsson on FRAND terms and conditions,” instead insisting on a below-fair royalty payment, the complaint continues. That also effectively deprives Ericsson of its right to an equal global licence for Samsung’s essential patents on FRAND terms.

“Without 4G and 5G technology and Ericsson’s inventions incorporated therein, smartphones and other mobile devices would not be able to provide the constant on-the-go access to video, streaming media, and gaming that consumers expect today,” Ericsson wrote in its complaint.

A Samsung spokesperson said the company would review the complaint and “determine an appropriate response”.

Ericsson also said in its statement that operating income could also be affected next year by other factors unrelated to Samsung, notably “current geopolitical conditions impacting handset sales volumes, as is the shift from 4G to 5G handsets”.