Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 November 2012

EU supports 3G refarming, but does not help with fragmentation

The European Union has taken its latest steps to free up more spectrum for LTE, and in a harmonized way across its member states. It is allowing for the 2.1GHz 3G band to be refarmed for 4G, a move it previously supported for both GSM bands, 900MHz and 1.8GHz. However, while it is mandating that national governments amend their laws to allow 2.1GHz refarming by June 30 2014, that is only one step towards unified LTE services across the Union.

The GSM bands highlight how new EU rules do not necessarily avoid fragmentation, currently the bugbear of the LTE technology. The large number of bands in which LTE services run, even at this early stage, makes it hard for the device ecosystem to coalesce around common combinations of frequencies, which is essential to affordable smartphone economics. And the situation will get worse as consumers start to look for LTE roaming abroad or even within countries (as seen in the US, where there is no interoperability between devices in different areas of the 700MHz band as harnessed by Verizon, AT&T and many rural providers).

In the EU, the situation is more harmonized, although many operators are part of multinational groups which will be looking for roaming services and for the economies of scale from global handset purchasing. And there are still obstacles. Although 2.6GHz and 800MHz are being rolled out for LTE in all the countries, they are being auctioned at different rates, and in some markets some carriers have not been able to obtain 800MHz licences. Then there are the two GSM bands, which are being adopted for LTE with different degrees of enthusiasm. The 1.8GHz spectrum is rapidly becoming a major candidate to be a global LTE frequency, since it offers a good balance of coverage and capacity, and many devices are being launched to support it, even the iPhone 5 (which ignored the 2.6GHz and 800MHz frequencies).

In the UK, where the auctions of new spectrum have been delayed until early next year. Everything Everywhere has gained a headstart by launching LTE ahead of rivals in its 1.8GHz spectrum, despite the complications of refarming occupied bands and effecting a gradual migration from 2G to 4G. This is complex compared to using virgin bands like 2.6GHz, or vacated ones like mobile 800MHz, but avoids the cost of buying new frequencies at auction, and in EE’s case, gives it valuable breathing time as it is the only current 1.8GHz owner. Vodafone and O2 UK have 900MHz GSM spectrum instead and this is currently less attractive for LTE refarming because there are fewer operators taking this route ‘ most of them are in the Middle East ‘ and therefore fewer devices, not to mention the lower capacity available in this low frequency, to support parallel GSM and LTE.

So allowing a band to be used for LTE does not guarantee that operators will leap, and in the case of 2.1GHz, many expect to carry on expanding and upgrading HSPA(+) for years as an adjunct to LTE ‘ often keeping the 4G technology mainly for urban hotzones and rural applications, while HSPA remains the wide area workhorse. However, at least the EU has given carriers another spectrum option, insisting that the 2.1GHz band must be able to be refarmed for 4G by mid-2014.

The EU’s executive arm, the European Commission, said on Monday that its latest move would free up an extra 120MHz for 4G, making a total of about 1,000MHz for LTE ‘ twice the amount available in the US. It will also help the EU reach its broadband coverage goals, where everyone gets at least 30Mbps by 2020.

‘This extra spectrum for 4G in Europe means we can better meet the changing and growing demand for broadband,’ Digital Agenda commissioner Neelie Kroes said in a statement. ‘I want to see member states acting swiftly to change existing licences. We all win from faster wireless connections in Europe.’

The affected spectrum is in 1920-1980MHz, paired with 2110-2170MHz. There is also some unpaired spectrum in the same region (at 1900-1920MHz and 2010-2025MHz) which is not being used by any operator, but may also be opened up for TD-LTE. Cellcos gained TDD allocations in the 3G band but despite the best efforts of IPWireless and its TD-CDMA technology, and proposals to harness the unpaired frequencies for mobile TV, this spectrum went unused.

TD-LTE is becoming a far more mainstream standard than its 3G predecessors and achieving uptake around the world ‘ especially in Asia and at Clearwire ‘ and a device ecosystem. European operators are expressing rising interest in TDD technology, though mainly as a second wave option to boost capacity when their initial LTE networks are hitting capacity. The unpaired frequencies in 1.9GHz/2.1GHz have too little capacity to support full TD-LTE roll-out, but could be added to a pot of spectrum using carrier aggregation techniques as included in the LTE-Advanced standard ‘ as AT&T is doing with the TDD 700MHz spectrum it acquired from Qualcomm, which it is adding to its FDD network.

“Such an initiative will aim at ensuring efficient use of the unpaired bands that is most beneficial from an economic, social and environmental point of view,” said the Commission, which may include applications other than terrestrial mobile broadband.

The latest ruling is part of the over-arching EU Radio Spectrum Policy Programme (RSPP), which is being driven by a series of concrete deadlines from the Commission. Adopted in March, the RSPP’s main objectives to 2020 include ensuring that at least 1,200 MHz of spectrum is available for wireless broadband, supporting spectrum trading throughout the EU in all harmonized bands, and encouraging spectrum sharing. Under the original rulings, member states were required to liberalize 800MHz, 900MHz, 1.8GHz, 2.5GHz-2.69GHz and 3.4GHz-3.8GHz for mobile broadband services by the end of 2012. The Commission, along with member states, has pledged by mid-2013 to set out a plan for establishing an inventory to assess efficient spectrum use in the 400MHz to 6GHz range.