The European Commission surprised nobody when it revealed, in a draft recommendation, that it would almost certainly support DVB-H as the mobile TV standard for the EU. The document said that DVB-H was the ‘strongest contender’ to be the basis of European systems.
Since the EU helped fund the development of DVB-H to the tune of €40m via support for Nokia, the major contributor and flag waver for the technology, it was hardly surprising that it is set to favour its homegrown system and promote it as the only standard in the region. More controversial is the general approach of the EU, in heavily backing technologies from European vendors, and seeking to get the Union nations to mandate a single standard. Although this approach was highly successful in GSM, establishing western Europe as the leader of the mobile world, it worked far less effectively in 3G, where many blame the insistence on a single standard, UMTS, for the failures in the model.
In forthcoming major auctions such as the 2.5GHz ‘3G expansion band’, the EU is veering far more strongly towards technology neutrality, allowing operators to select the system that they believe will best support their business cases. While some national regulators will be less flexible, there has been some surprise that, in mobile TV, the Commission is not setting a more hands-off approach.
The Commission claims that the other main standards, T-DMB, as used in South Korea, and Qualcomm’s MediaFLO, which looks set to sweep the board in the US, are less prevalent, and insists a a single standard is necessary to avoid ‘market fragmentation’. It now plans to add DVB-H to the list of standards published in its official journal. ‘This implies that [EU member countries] will be required to encourage the use of DVB-H for the provision of terrestrial mobile television services,’ the document says. This hard line will disappoint backers of other standards, notably Qualcomm, which has some European trials, notably with satellite broadcaster Sky. However, the US chipmaker has prepared for such a situation, focusing heavily on its own DVB-H developments and on its Universal Broadcast Modem product, which will support most mobile TV platforms.
South Korea has also lobbied the Commission to consider T-DMB, in which Samsung is the major patent holder, although the UK’s BBC and some European universities have also been important contributors. The Commission estimates mobile television will generate global sales of €4bn to €5bn, or about $5bn to $7bn, by 2009.
Some operators will also be disappointed that they are unlikely to be able to make a free choice of systems, although DVB-H is already in a powerful position to win European business, especially as it will quickly and fairly cheaply be incorporated into a wide range of handsets, given the driving force of Nokia and other backers like Sony Ericsson. The carriers will not be surprised by the Commission’s stance, although some will continue to lobby their national regulators to take a more flexible view. The EC Commissioner with responsibility for telecoms, Viviane Reding, said in March that a single standard should be chosen. ‘I know that competition among different standards can, for some time, be a good way to let the market identify the best solution. But, we have been waiting for too long. The opportunities are slipping away. It is time to break the deadlock,’ she said at a conference.
The Commission is expected to publish its final decision and plans in mid-July.
Rethink Research recently published a major report,’Mobile TV: Global Standards Review and Forecast for Infrastructure and Handsets 2007 – 2011′, in association with Multimedia Research Group. This tracks and analyzes all the current and pending trial and services, forecasts uptake patterns in all regions, and explores the technology and spectrum options worldwide, in a 175-page publication. For an executive summary or more information, please contact Linda Elisha on [email protected].