Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 May 2015

Europe’s first 700 MHz auction kicks off in Germany

The first European auction of spectrum in the 700 MHz band – the second digital dividend – started on Wednesday, in the region’s largest market, Germany.

However, any hopes of it ushering in new competition were dashed a while back, when it emerged that the only participants would be the three incumbent players (Deutsche Telekom/T-Mobile, Vodafone and the enlarged O2). This may also prevent it turning into a prolonged process with inflated prices, like the recent US AWS-3 sale.

The three MNOs will bid for a total of 270 MHz of spectrum, including 2×30 MHz in the dividend band, and the rest in the 900 MHz, 1.5 GHz and 1.8 GHz bands.

Germany is earmarking the new spectrum particularly to improve rural broadband services, an objective which was also very important in its 800 MHz auction. In that process, it attached coverage conditions to some licences and insisted that operators built their first LTE800 networks in rural areas. With 700 MHz in play as well, the government believes it can achieve near-ubiquitous mobile broadband availability. To that end, BNetza is applying stringent deployment requirements this time too. Winners must provide broadband coverage to at least 98% of households nationwide, with average data rates of at least 10Mbps; and they must guarantee mobile broadband coverage along national motorways and major railways. All this must happen within three years of winning the licences, which will last until 2031.

Regulator BNetza said the 700 MHz frequencies will be available to use on a phased basis, from 2017, as they are vacated by current broadcaster incumbents, although the precise band plan for Europe’s 700 MHz networks has yet to be worked out by CEPT, the European standards agency. Many operators want it to be as close as possible to the Asia-Pacific band plan, which is already being adopted in various Asian and Latin American LTE projects, as that would deliver a significant global device ecosystem. However, issues of interference with broadcasting may enforce a somewhat different plan, though it may be close enough to enable devices with global capabilities (except in north America, which has a completely different plan).

There is also debate over proposals, backed by Qualcomm and others, to earmark a 2×3 MHz sub-section specifically for machine-to-machine usage, and the emerging LTE-MTC low power standard. Qualcomm and others believe that would help LTE operators be competitive in M2M markets such as smart cities, but others – including many carriers – want all spectrum to be usage-neutral and to have the freedom to deploy whatever seems most appropriate.

As for the details of the auction, in 700 MHz, there will be lots of 2×5 MHz with minimum bids based on the fees set in 2013 (€75m per lot). In the 900 MHz and 1.8 GHz GSM bands (in which current licences expire soon), the regulator has set a cap of 2×15 MHz per provider (three blocks) with a minimum bid of €75m for the 900 MHz band, €37.5m for 1.8 GHz and €18.75m for 1.5 GHz.

Despite the small number of bidders, the Treasury is hopeful of higher takings than in the first digital dividend auction, in 2010, which yielded €4.385bn in total and €3.58bn from the 800 MHz licences. Analysts at Commerzbank are forecasting a figure of €4.5bn for the 800 MHz licences this time.