FCC chairman Kevin Martin came out last week and told a US newspaper just what he has in mind for the 700MHz spectrum auction in late 2008, talking about an open network
which lets any wireless device connect to it, and which places no limits on the services that can be offered across it. In other words, he wants a pure mobile web, where customers can download any broadband application, and have no restrictions on the content that is
served. Though this fits with the broad vision of how mobile and converged services will inevitably evolve round the world, to support the internet model, it was a shock to hear the currently, fairly cautious and operator-friendly, FCC taking such a bold line, and Martin predictably sparked a storm of controversy.
Operators both traditional and disruptive, and their technology suppliers, see 700MHz bands in the US as beachfront spectrum for extending multimedia services even in sparsely populated areas, because of its support for large cells, and the auction is set to be one of the most hotly contested, and potentially expensive, of recent times. But the prices the carriers are prepared to pay will depend on the conditions the FCC places on the licenses, and on how the ongoing debate over public safety provisions is resolved (some of the band has already been set aside for public safety, but several groups, most notably one led by Frontline Wireless and backed by the internet lobby, are advocating a national network that would be leased for commercial purposes, but with safety activities taking priority when required).
Martin’s ideas fall short of the fully wholesale model advocated by Frontline Wireless, Google and others ‘ this would split spectrum ownership entirely from service delivery and could lead to future innovations such as short lease or ‘on-demand’ access to bandwidth for more flexible operator models than are possible with the current system. However, the chairman certainly went further than many had expected of him, pointing to level of open access on two 11MHz in the 700MHz band. In addition, the proposal sets aside a separate national 10MHz block for bidding that would require the winning bidder to work with public safety on adjacent frequencies to improve emergency response communications. Since it does not require wholesaling the two 11MHz chunks, Martin could win some carrier support for the compromise.
The chairman’s proposals outline a flat rate, open IP architecture where devices will need only the most cursory adherence to the air interface, but where applications are pure IP, and most services are delivered over the web. If the chairman gets his way, this would accelerate the end of the cellular walled garden, and offer a form of wireless network neutrality at least
in this spectrum. The likely winner of such a bid would almost certainly use an OFDMA network, which is perhaps best suited for IP packet delivery, and that suggests WiMAX now, though LTE could possibly be sufficiently defined by the time of the auction. More important than the access network, such a framework would more easily support new entrants in a challenge to the incumbent telcos.
Martin gave a passing nod to the idea that no downloadable software should be illegal, or should be able to harm the network, but apart from that hinted that there would be no restrictions allowed by the operator on applications ‘ a far cry from the issues surrounding the iPhone, just launched.
This would not only create a challenge for bidders, and give the whip hand to device makers and software suppliers, but in giving way to a period of wireless innovation along the lines of the first days of the internet, it would put huge competitive pressure on existing services
which are not regulated in this way, to follow suit. In Europe we have already seen what one rogue player (for instance 3 Group) can do when it offers flat rate broadband, forcing other, larger players to follow in its footsteps or lose customers. Much the same would happen here.
Martin described the auction as providing the elusive ‘third pipe’ to the home and said he was concerned that overseas network customers were benefiting from greater innovation and thought it was time the US public got the same treatment. He specifically referred to the idea
of US operators stripping Wi-Fi out of handsets that were designed to work with it, and locking phones so they only work with one network, a criticism that has been levied at the Apple iPhone as hackers try to find the code that ties it to the AT&T network, so that ‘gray’ imports of iPhones can be sold all over the world.
Predictably, both sides of the debate used the high profile iPhone to support their arguments, although Verizon Wireless was trying to have it both ways, arguing against any rules that would favour a new group of carriers, but also taking a potshot at the closed approach represented by AT&T’s iPhone. Steven Zipperstein, Verizon Wireless’ general counsel, said: “Reports of special rules for any company or segment of the hi-tech industry that would tip the balance in their favor and circumvent a true auction are problematic’ Consumer choice would be the casualty of policies that mandate that all companies do the same thing the same way’ The launch of Apple’s iPhone, which works only on a competitor’s second generation network, continues to represent the ‘walled garden’ approach that has others calling for open access.”
Meanwhile, Steve Largent, CEO of the cellcos’ industry body, the CTIA, said: “Crafting special rules for a company with a market cap of $170bn to address problems that don’t exist in our competitive market makes absolutely no sense whatsoever.”