Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 April 2018

FCC underwhelms with first mmWave auction plans

In the US, the FCC has kicked off the process of preparing for this year’s 5G spectrum auction. The regulator will seek public comments on procedures for two separate auctions, one to start on November 14 in the 28 GHz band, followed by the 24 GHz band sale, which will commence immediately after the first one is concluded.

FCC chair Ajit Pai said in a statement: “It may not be flashy, but this is a vital step toward promoting US innovation in 5G wireless services, the Internet of Things, and many technological firsts in these previously underused, high band frequencies.”

Together, the auctions will offer 1.55 GHz of spectrum across about 6,000 geographic licence regions. Two 425 MHz blocks in the 28 GHz band will be offered on a county basis, while seven 100 MHz blocks in the 24 GHz band will be allocated by Partial Economic Area. The much-vaunted 28 GHz sale will help put this millimeter wave band on the global agenda at next year’s World Radio Conference (the ITU has, so far, identified 26 GHz, but not 28 GHz, as a proposed 5G global allocation). However, in fact, the 28 GHz licences only cover 23.7% of the US population (and 61% of the geographic area, in 47% of counties), according to Spectrum Financial Partners (though AT&T and Verizon, and some smaller firms, already own further 28 GHz spectrum which has been commercially available since LMDS licences were sold late in the last century).

The proposal is that the two auctions should have separate application and bidding processes, and the FCC is asking for comment on whether they should include additional conditions, such as a “prohibition on certain communications”.

Some of the details are already up for discussion, including the minimum opening bid prices. In the 24 GHz auction proposal, these are a full 188 times lower than the minimum opening bid prices for the recent 600 MHz incentive auction, indicating how the US regulator still values sub-1 GHz spectrum far more highly than higher band options.

According to Spectrum Financial Partners: “The FCC plans to begin bidding for all 700 MHz of the 24 GHz band at $438m. This compares with opening bids for the 600 MHz auction ($1,174m for each 10 MHz block) in the ratio of 117.4/(438/700)= 187.6 or about 188 times higher opening prices per MHz for 600 MHz spectrum than for 24 GHz spectrum.”

However, the FCC is helping to address a large area of uncertainty amid the excitement about mmWave worldwide – the likely pricing of this high band spectrum. The best indicator so far has been Verizon’s purchase of Straight Path’s 28 GHz licences for $3.1bn last year.

Because of the relatively limited availability of 28 GHz, operators like T-Mobile have been lobbying for the FCC to auction spectrum in several mmWave bands – for instance, 28 GHz, 24 GHz, 37 GHz, 39 GHz and 47 GHz – at the same time so that MNOs can get more national allocations, and make more informed decisions about the pricing and geographical availability of mmWave spectrum as a whole.

The 24 GHz auction, at least, will offer spectrum on a near-nationwide basis, rather than being heavily geared to rural areas like 28 GHz.

Meanwhile, AT&T and Verizon are already forging ahead with 5G tests and deployments in their 28 GHz and 39 GHz spectrum acquired via a series of acquisitions. AT&T plans to make 5G commercial services available for fixed wireless in 12 markets before the end of the year, and promises to add mobile access from 2020. Verizon is using a pre-standard implementation of 5G NR and has a stronger focus on fixed wireless as a business case in its own right, rather than a testing ground for mobile 5G – as it looks to expand out of its relatively small wireline territory using 5G.

Dave Wolter, an assistant VP for radio technology at AT&T Labs, recently talked to reporters about the 5G tests so far, which are using a device like a ‘hockey puck’. “Depending on the vendor, the pucks use 400 or 800 MHz channels, and in all cases we see gigabit-type data rates that are pretty reliable,” he said. “We see some rain fade, but weather has not been as big a factor as some thought because the links are short – about 100-300 meters – and even the farthest links still get a Gbit/second with probably more possible when you have line of sight.”

AT&T is also conducting simulations in the sub-6 GHz bands which mainstream handsets are expected to use, and which will be vital to mobile services. Its scientists are also investigating the potential to use dynamic spectrum sharing between LTE and 5G, and to add bands which have not yet been approved by regulators, in the expanding sub-6 GHz testbed.

Separately, AT&T is contributing to work on 3GPP Release 16 standards for using 5G for backhaul.