Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 February 2013

Featurephone transition, not cutting edge features, dominate handset debate

Nothing highlighted the challenges facing smartphone makers in general, and Nokia more than any, like the announcements of Kenyan cellco Safaricom during the MWC conference. The operator said it was phasing out featurephones altogether and would now only sell smartphones, albeit many of them being sub-$100 models. And it announced deals to sell Nokia’s Lumia Windows Phone handsets, including an exclusive for the high end 920. While many analysts think Safaricom is jumping the gun by moving away from featurephones ‘ still more than half of the global base, at least until the end of 2013 ‘ so early, in an emerging economy, the decision shows how urgently handset providers must drive down smartphone prices and convert their installed base.

There are many debates about how quickly featurephones are giving way to their smart cousins (and how far the ‘smart featurephone’ category will prove to have long term life). IDC said this week that global shipments of smartphones would overtake those of featurephones for the first time this year. It forecast that OEMs would ship 918.6m smartphones in 2013, which would be 50.1% of the handset total. Meanwhile, researchers at Nielsen was more cautious, saying in its 2013 Mobile Consumer Report that only 10% of Indian customers currently have a smartphone, and just 19% in Turkey, 36% in Brazil and 37% in Russia.

Whatever the figures, device makers like Nokia face a very dangerous moment when their users make the transition to a smartphone. The Finnish firm has a strong base in Kenya, bolstered by sterling efforts to provide localized content and applications, an activity often neglected by Apple and others. But the fact remains that when customers move away from low end handsets, it only has a new platform, Windows Phone, to offer, with significantly less brand recognition and fewer apps than Android. In addition, there are very few low cost Windows Phone devices, from Nokia or anyone else, further reducing the ecosystem and awareness in emerging markets. The company has been driving down Lumia costs, but the new entry level, the 520, announced at MWC, is still priced at $184.

So while Nokia appeals to the growing Kenyan middle class with its Lumia deals, and fights to drive down the cost of its entry level WP8 offerings, it is saddled with an OS that is nowhere near to Android in affordability or choice of handsets and software. The Finnish firm’s real bridge builder between featurephones and smartphones is Asha ‘ technically in the former category because it has a closed OS, Series 40, but in reality supporting most common web behaviors highly efficiently via its browser, which carries out much of its processing in the cloud to reduce the burden on low end connections or phones. Asha increasingly delivers an experience that is better than that of a cheap Android product (though without all the apps of course), and at a sub-$50 price.

Provided Safaricom classes Asha as a smartphone, it will still have a good bridge product to entice lower budget users into the world of the mobile web and separate data plans. If it does not have Asha, or a similar range, it may be moving prematurely away from featurephones. The carrier’s director for corporate affairs, Nzioka Waita, says the aim is to spur demand for digital content in Kenya and reverse a recent decline in ARPU ‘ now at $5 a month, and expected to fall to $4m within a couple of years if operators do not take drastic action to counterweigh the decline in voice revenue. Safaricom is certainly the right cellco to lead that action, given its 66% market share in a country that still has plenty of mobile growth potential ‘ Ovum forecasts the number of connections will rise from 28m in 2011 (2m of them on 3G) to 35m in 2017.

The huge market for featurephone conversion was a preoccupation of all the handset makers in Barcelona, though of course, the non-attendance of Apple meant there were no updates on how that firm will strike the delicate balance between tapping into the mass market and preserving its margins and brand value. Others ‘ Samsung, LG, Nokia and the Chinese vendors ‘ have no qualms about turning out low cost devices. But they have difficult balances too – how far they participate in a price war, and how they differentiate the various products within their broad portfolios, with the ‘smart device’ term now spanning a huge range from $50 Android phone to super-tablet.

For the first time, the MWC show was less about the top end of that range and more about the mass market. Of course there was excitement generated around some flagship device launches, such as the HTC One and the Samsung Galaxy Note 8, and some forward looking technologies, like 4K support in an LG Optimus G. And Samsung managed to steal the headlines, Apple-style, merely by announcing the date for the presumed launch of the Galaxy 4S on March 14. However, most of the high end gadgetry has moved to January’s Consumer Electronics Show, and MWC was far more about how the entire gamut of handsets would best support operator business requirements.

Nokia, even in its dark days, very much sees MWC as its home, and it managed to elicit sighs of nostalgia when it launched the Nokia 150, a €15 handset with a 1.5-inch screen and several weeks of battery life in standby. This was the Nokia we knew and loved (and it was surprising how many people were carrying low end Nokia phones to offset the inevitable dying of the smartphone battery halfway through a day at MWC). But the 150 was also a serious signal that Nokia would reverse the decline in its fortunes in emerging markets it once dominated, notably China, not only with Asha and lower cost Lumias, but by pushing down into the super-budget area against the Chinese and Taiwanese ODMs.

The vendor did not have a showstopper like last year’s PureView, but its executives were high profile in pushing Lumia and Asha. CEO Stephen Elop emphasized that Nokia is now differentiating in almost every key component of the handset (which is essential, given that Windows Phone is so far behind in platform terms). He particularly highlighted the PureView 41-mp camera and surrounding imaging technology, wireless charging, the newly reworked music streaming services, touchscreens sensitive enough to work with gloved fingers, and localized content.

It was also noticeable that, along with innovating in hardware, Nokia is more aggressive about competing on the software front. It already signalled this last year when it morphed arguably its most valuable asset, the Navteq mapping technology, into an open cloud-based service called Nokia Here. It will now build on that OS-neutral move and plans to open up all its location services and its augmented reality suite to other mobile platforms and to third party developers. ‘By gaining scale, we can increase the quality and quantity of the data we receive,’ Elop told the conference audience. By expanding the underlying data and the applications in its web platforms, Nokia has the chance to push its brand beyond its own market ‘ a goal also pursued by some large cellcos ‘ and to hedge against continuing sidelining in hardware.

And many of its software and apps efforts will be focused on the emerging markets. Elop identified three key challenges in connecting the next billion users, and it was noticeable that he was not predicting any near term end to the featurephone, perhaps because he knows Asha has a better chance than Lumia of filling the gaping hole left by the accelerated decline of Symbian in the midmarket. The three essentials will be to provide affordable content and data; to deliver an app economy for featurephones (by which he means semi-smart handsets like Asha); and to enable effective content discovery. His goal is to channel Nokia’s high end expertise in these three areas for lower end devices and users. In particular, this strategy revolves around attractively designed ‘smart featurephones’; the cloud-based Nokia Express browser, which enables a full web experience on a low end system; and the Nokia Life suite apps in education, agriculture, entertainment and productivity, all heavily tailored to local emerging markets.

All this suggests that Nokia is, after many years of missing the zeitgeist, back in the industry’s mobile sweet spot, as handset growth shifts to the areas where it still shines. It has assorted technologies which play well to the expansion in demand for mass market smartphones or webphones, efficient web services, and strong multimedia technology. But none is tied inherently to Windows Phone, and as we have said before, that remains its most difficult space. Asha and the OS-independent location and AR platforms are far more obvious winners in the featurephone migration than Lumia, despite the focus at MWC on lower end, yet attractive, models like 520 and 720. With Lumia Nokia will always be chasing a segment where the rules are set by Apple and Google, while with Asha it will see Samsung and other rivals chasing after it.