It was a far cry from the record £22bn the UK raised from its 3G auction in 2000, during the telecoms bubble. By contrast, the LTE auction fell short of expectations, netting £2.34bn ($3.6bn), significantly lower than the £3.5bn the government had anticipated.
A total of 250MHz of spectrum was auctioned over the past few weeks in a secret process. It was divided between the 800MHz digital dividend and the 2.6GHz band. All four cellcos acquired new frequencies as did a BT subsidiary, Niche Spectrum Ventures. Two other bidders, MLL Telecom and a unit of PCCW, failed to win spectrum.
Ed Richards, CEO of regulator Ofcom, said in a statement: ‘This is a positive outcome for competition in the UK, which will lead to faster and more widespread mobile broadband, and substantial benefits for consumers and businesses across the country. We are confident that the UK will be among the most competitive markets in the world for 4G services.’
Telefonica O2 has the heaviest obligations attached to its licence. It acquired the 2x10MHz in the 800MHz band which was assigned a coverage mandate ‘ to support indoor reception for at least 98% of the UK population (99% outdoors expected), and at least 95% of the population of each of the UK nations, by the end of 2017 at the latest.
Vodafone also got 2x10MHz in 800MHz, though with no obligations. These two operators were particularly keen to get spectrum in the sub-1GHz band, which is ideal for broad coverage and indoor penetration. During the long-drawn out regulatory and legal battles which led up to the auction, the other cellcos, EE and 3UK, argued that Vodafone and O2 should be limited in acquiring 800MHz frequencies, since they have sub-1GHz GSM spectrum (in 900MHz), which could be refarmed in future for LTE.
However, EE later became the focus of ‘unfair disadvantage’ claims when it was allowed to roll out 4G ahead of its rivals, in its own 1.8GHz GSM spectrum, a more common option for refarming than 900MHz. 3UK, which only has 2.1GHz frequencies, will be able to deploy LTE1800 too as EE is required to divest 25% of its holdings to the fourth cellco. EE gained a smaller amount of 800MHz (2x5MHz), which it will likely use to complement 1.8GHz for rural coverage, and 3UK gained the same amount, leaving it still spectrally disadvantaged compared to its rivals ‘ it will have less 800MHz than Vodafone or O2, less 1.8GHz than EE, and did not acquire any 2.6GHz frequencies.
Nor did the Hutchison unit pursue the strategy adopted by its sister operators in Scandinavia and Italy, of boosting its spectrum coffers by snapping up the undervalued unpaired (TDD) licences in the 2.6GHz band. It was expected to have taken the same stand in the UK in order to gain low cost, data-intensive capacity, but in fact, Vodafone bought the 25MHz block in the TDD 2.6GHz band, along with 2x20MHz of FDD spectrum in the same band. The rest of the unpaired frequencies (a 20MHz block) went to the BT subsidiary, predictably enough, given that the wireline incumbent had indicated it would chase high frequency bands only, to support non-retail business models. NSV also got 2x15MHz of FDD 2.6GHz licences. O2, like 3UK, passed on 2.6GHz altogether, while EE obtained the biggest amount (2x35MHz).
Overall, Vodafone was the biggest spender, laying out £790.76m, followed by EE on £588.87m and O2 on £550m. 3UK spent £225M and NSV £186.47m.
There is a final stage in the process to determine where in the respective bands each winner’s spectrum will be located (the ‘assignment stage’).
The income from the auction bucked a general upwards trend for European LTE spectrum prices ‘ the recent Dutch sale came in well above expectations. This reflects the economic downturn and the UK cellcos’ caution, in a fiercely competitive market, about overspending as they did in 3G. They have focused their attentions heavily on HSPA+ expansion and refarming to limit their requirement for new spectrum, and in the end, the presence of three potential new entrants in the bidding did not, as some had forecast, push prices up significantly.
Another factor behind operators’ caution, of course, is the uncertainty over how far they can generate additional revenues from their investment in spectrum and new networks (which should start rolling out this summer). Victor Basta, managing director of M&A specialist Magister Advisors, commented: ‘The disappointing revenues from the 4G auction, well below government forecasts, are a reflection of the challenges that mobile operators face in growing revenues from their users in the social media age. Mobile operators increasingly find themselves in a role that is about supporting end users’ social networking habits, with little, if any, commercial benefit. Social networking has effectively turning mobile network operators into digital drug mules.’
Chris Leslie, the shadow chief secretary to the Treasury, raised political concerns about the low prices, telling the BBC: ‘It’s extremely worrying that the Chancellor’s entire budgetary strategy seems to be based on numbers that were significantly overestimated.’
The auction marks the return of BT to the mobile market, after it spun out its wireless arm, Cellnet (now O2) in 2002, widely seen, with hindsight, as a misstep since so much value shifted to the mobile-only players after that date. However, BT is not re-entering the mobile mainstream but instead plans to ‘provide its business and consumer customers with an enhanced range of mobile broadband services, building on its existing strength in Wi-Fi’. CEO Ian Livingston said in a statement: ‘We are pleased to have secured this spectrum. We have said that we do not intend to build a national mobile network. Instead, this spectrum will complement our existing strategy of delivering a range of services using fixed and wireless broadband. We want our customers to enjoy the best possible connections wherever they are and this spectrum, together with our investment in fibre broadband, will help us achieve that.’
MLL Telecom CEO Gary Marven said the firm was ‘naturally disappointed not to have won any allocated spectrum. The auction process has helped us analyze different markets and opened up a number of opportunities that we are pursuing. MLL Telecom will continue to support our mobile operating customers, build networks in remote areas and help the public sector with their networks while driving new areas such as connecting the growing number of small cell deployments.’
Meanwhile, the day before the news of the auction results broke, EE announced full year results which may have increased the caution of UK carriers about investing in LTE. Its figures do not show a company which has fully capitalized on its LTE headstart, including a full year net loss of £191m, considerably up on 2011’s £104m. The firm did not give any details about uptake of its LTE service.
Despite the bleak headline figure, EE insisted ‘the group remains well placed to make good progress towards delivering its 2013 goals’ and said in its statement that it had ‘made progress, executing on its business strategy while maintaining commercial momentum against a backdrop of macroeconomic weakness, regulatory pressures and a highly competitive environment’.
Revenue for the year was down 1.9% to £6.66bn. Within that, mobile service revenue was £5.95bn, down 2.6% year-on-year, a decline the carrier blamed on regulatory cuts to mobile termination rates (MTR). This was partly offset by growth in the contract customer base ‘ up from 48% to 52% of the total base across the year, with 750,000 postpaid net adds – and without the impact of the MTR changes, service revenue would have been up by 2.7%. It noted that 78% of contract customers now use smartphones, up from 69% at the end of 2011. Dividends paid to EE’s parent firms, Deutsche Telekom and France Telecom, totalled £734m.
At the end of last year, the company’s LTE network covered 43% of the UK population in 18 towns and cities, and its fiber passed 11m premises. EE is targeting 55% LTE coverage across 65 towns and cities by June, around the time when rivals like Vodafone, O2 and 3UK are likely to be rolling out their own 4G services, assuming they win spectrum in the current auction of 2.6GHz and 800MHz spectrum.
There was no information on how many customers had moved to the 4G plans, which were initially criticized for their high rates, and for confusion around EE’s three brands ‘ the legacy Orange and T-Mobile names are retained for 2G and 3G services, but the LTE offering is labelled ‘EE’. Most of the firm’s stores have also been rebranded. However, the firm maintained it was ‘critical for the group to maintain and develop its three brands’. It was keen to present its losses as the result of a transitional, even transformational, year, when it invested heavily in the new network and brands.
Some were surprised EE did not announce LTE figures, though the operator said it was mute so as not to impact the auction proceedings. But Ovum principal analyst Steven Hartley told MobileWorld: ‘It is what the results don’t say that seems most telling … Experience suggests that phrases such as ‘solid early 4G momentum’ cover all manner of sins. That doesn’t make it a disaster, just not necessarily fully optimizing its monopoly position.’
In the fourth quarter, EE’s revenue was down 2.8% year-on-year to £1.67bn while ARPU slid 1.6% to £18.60 per month, despite the LTE premium (about 10% higher ARPU when TMo and Orange clients migrate to LTE, says EE) and the rise in higher-paying postpaid users. The cellco gained 201,000 new contract customers in Q4 but lost 239,000 net prepaid customers, adding up to a 2.6% decline in its base. For 2012 as a whole, capex increased by 6.9% to £606m.