Miami-based alternative operator GlobeTel (GTE) has generated huge headlines and stock price boosts through its adventures in WiMAX, stratellites and other emerging technologies, but now it is facing a class action lawsuit over its claims of a $600m deal to build one of the world’s largest WiMAX networks, in Russia. The dispute highlights the risks of investing in early movers in attractive but as yet undisciplined new telecoms markets, and the difficulty of assessing the real progress of emerging technologies, amid a welter of hype and speculative projects with very uncertain outcomes.
GlobeTel faces action from New York law firm Sarraf Gentile on behalf of investors who bought shares in the operator between December 30 2005 and April 11 this year. According to the complaint, GlobeTel issued several statements during that period touting a deal with a Moscow-based company named Internafta to install wireless networks in Russia’s 30 largest cities. ‘The complaint alleges, however, that the Russian deal, like so many of GTE’s other business ventures, was in reality a sham,” the law firm said.
When GlobeTel announced the deal at the end of last year, it sparked a near doubling of its stock value, despite early suspicions that Internafta, and the contract, might not be rock solid. The announcement was also pounced upon by the WiMAX and Wi-Fi communities as one of the largest endorsements yet of their technology for large city networks, in a nation that promises one of the highest growth rates for telecoms in the world and, with its highly urbanized population combined with low broadband build-out rates, offers a golden opportunity for metro broadband wireless.
Despite promising payments as early as January, GlobeTel has since issued a number of statements offering various reasons for delays, difficulties and complexities – and admitted in March that it was still awaiting an initial deposit. Under the agreement outlined at the turn of the year, Internafta was to pay $600m for Wi-Fi and WiMAX systems to be installed as metrozones, starting in Moscow and St Petersburg. GlobeTel would build and manage the networks and retain a 50% share, and all 30 locations would be covered by mid-2008, the company promised.
“It is beyond exciting to be able to bring this level of connectivity to Russia,” said GlobeTel CEO Tim Huff at the time. “Russia will, quickly and at a relatively modest cost, have a wireless infrastructure that will rival any in the industrialized world.’
The proposed system also promised to be the first major opportunity for the technology for which GlobeTel is most famous, stratellites. These high altitude airships were developed by Sanswire, which GlobeTel acquired, to provide satellite-style backhaul, particularly for rural areas, at lower cost than fully blown satellites. In June 2005 it also acquired HotZone Wireless, developer of extended range Wi-Fi and WiMAX metrozone systems that would use Sanswire for backhaul and claimed to be the only outdoor products supporting Wi-Fi, WiMAX, DECT and cordless PHS on one network. The key product, HotZone 4010, was to have been the centrepiece of the Russian build-out. The combination of stratellite and radio technologies could cover areas up to 120,000 square miles, claimed HotZone last year.
Now, according to Sarraf Gentile, even the stratellite deals are in doubt. A deal between GlobeTel Sanswire and a consortium called Sanswire Australia to launch stratellites over the country in 2005 yielded no results. Subsequently, GlobeTel bought Consolidated Global Investments (CGI) – the listing vehicle of failed carrier Advantel – with the intention of relaunching the firm as an Asian hub based in Perth. Instead, GlobeTel sold its shares in the firm back to its minority Australian partner last year and revealed that CGI’s only substantial asset was stock in GlobeTel – the trading profits from which had partially been used to purchase licensing agreements from GlobeTel.
The GlobeTel/Internafta saga is the latest in a series of setbacks for the company’s investors. In February, it cancelled a play to launch a prepaid calling card with Mexico’s Banco Azteca; and several 2004 deals to launch remittance services backed by SMS, in countries including Russia, India and the Philippines, have been either canned or severely delayed.