Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 January 2013

For once, Nokia pulls out good news while Apple comes under pressure

Just as the quarterly reporting season was looking highly predictable, Nokia delivered surprise good news, sending its battered stock soaring for once, even as Apple’s continued to suffer, dropping below the $500 level only months after many were seeing it go up to top $1,000.

Of course, the two firms’ values are still a galaxy apart, but their role reversal, in terms of this week’s headlines at least, points to a new unpredictability in the mobile device market, driven by the emergence of new form factors and web behaviors. The phase which started with the launch of the iPhone in 2007 is coming to a close, and the user experience and geographic reach of smartphones is changing again, to accommodate trends from large screens to entry level prices. That is not to say Apple cannot lead the next wave too, but it needs to innovate more quickly, while Nokia may see some new opportunities of its own.

The Finnish firm saw its shares leap by over 20% on Thursday as it issued revised guidance for Q412, saying its mobile devices business has exceeded expectations and hit underlying profitability earlier than anticipated.

Even allowing for Nokia’s habitual caution when providing outlooks, the prospect of better-than-expected quarterly results ‘ to be announced on January 24 ‘ was welcome after many quarters of doom and gloom. The largest unit, Devices & Services, is estimated by Nokia to have made $5.1bn in net sales in Q412, with device volumes of 86.3m. Hardly enough to worry Samsung and Apple, and indeed a sharp year-on-year drop, but sufficiently ahead of company and analyst forecasts to raise hopes that the vendor has hit the bottom.

In addition, it had positive outlook for its Nokia Siemens joint venture ‘ which was the surprise star of the Q312 figures ‘ and said operating expenses at Devices & Services were lower than expected, indicating the success of the ongoing cost cutting exercise. The unit’s non-IFRS operating margin is likely to be between breakeven and plus 2%, better than previous guidance of between minus 2% and minus 10%. The quarter will also gain from a $65m patent payment from RIM.

The devices figure breaks down to sales of 15.9m smartphones. Almost two-thirds are in the important Asha range, which crosses the category of entry level smartphone and featurephone, offering full-touch devices and web capabilities to emerging market users. Asha shipped 9.3m units, while Lumia sold 4.4m and the ageing Symbian family 2.2m. The rapid decline of the legacy platform ‘ which has happened more quickly than Nokia initially planned for ‘ is the main factor behind the year-on-year decline in units, down from 113.5m total in Q411. In that period, Nokia made $7.9bn in net sales from devices.

Nokia executives said supply constraints had held back the growth of Lumia, the Windows Phone flagship range. Nokia had supply constraints with the high end Lumia 920 in the fourth quarter, especially with AT&T and operators in Italy and Germany, CEO Stephen Elop said on a conference call, and warned that issue could persist in the current quarter. ‘The success of the 920 has been primarily capped by the supply situation,’ he said. Meanwhile, the featurephone business, Mobile Phones, is set to deliver volumes of 70.3m (excluding Asha).

In a statement, Elop called the fourth quarter a “solid” one for Nokia, saying the company is “focused on priorities’.

Some analysts were more enthusiastic. ‘This clearly shows Nokia is making good progress with consumers,’ said Robert Jakobsen of Jyske Bank in Denmark, while another regional analyst, Louis Landeman of Danske Bank in Sweden, told Bloomberg: ‘This is clearly very positive news from Nokia as it both shows that the company’s new Lumia product launches are performing well and that the NSN networks business has gained good momentum. The company’s restructuring programs are reducing costs faster than expected.’

Nokia used to be the lead handset vendor in China, until it was overtaken by Samsung, and the decline of its Symbian and Series 40 cellphones in the country were a major factor in some of last year’s poor results. Apple is equally aware of the power of China, now the world’s largest smartphone market, to make or break a company’s quarter. Its CEO Tim Cook predicted, during his high profile trip to woo Chinese partners last week, that the country would overtake the US as the top market for Apple too, even though it has remained one of the most US-centric of the major international brands. Faster growth in China and other emerging markets may soon become urgent, as question marks over the iPhone maker’s future expansion, which dogged its share price before the holiday, persist in the new year.

According to The Wall Street Journal, Apple is reducing orders for iPhone 5 components, suggesting that, despite strong initial sales, continuing demand is not quite as strong as anticipated. With speculation about an ‘iPhone nano’ and even ‘iPhone 6’ already swirling, this also highlights the downside of the perennial fascination with Apple’s plans ‘ the early stage at which the public becomes convinced it must wait for the next device, even before that has been launched.

Whatever the underlying factors, the WSJ report says Apple cut its orders for iPhone 5 displays for the first quarter by about half the original targeted level, and reduced deals for other screen sizes too. This adds to the unusual negativity about Apple from some analysts at the end of 2012. For instance, UBS’s Steven Milunovich reduced his iPhone forecasts last month, by 5m units in each of the first three quarters of 2013, and also trimmed iPad estimates by 2m per quarter.

This is why it is urgent for Apple to win more Chinese sales, especially netting the largest operator, China Mobile, at last. Cook held talks with the carrier’s chairman, Xi Guohua, during his visit to Beijing. The two firms have danced round one another for years, but several rounds of talks have reportedly foundered on a range of issues including control of the user interface and app store, and the level of subsidies. China Mobile executives recently said that the obstacles were about the business case, not the cellco’s unique TD-SCDMA 3G technology ‘ though some analysts still think the talks will mainly focus on supporting the TD-LTE 4G network, currently in very extensive customer trials.

Apple has iPhone deals with the other two Chinese operators, China Unicom and China Telecom, and Cook said the iPad mini would turn up in the country’s stores this month. But with its 707m subscribers, Mobile would be the real prize and a key ally in Apple’s bid to boost global market share against Samsung (the Chinese market leader); and to reverse the decline of its share in China, in the face of local players like Lenovo and ZTE. Cook is making his second visit to China in less than a year with these pressures in mind.

But while the operator may hold many of the best cards, it would benefit from an iPhone as it continues to struggle with the difficulties of having a one-carrier 3G technology. It has often complained of the shortage of affordable and high-impact devices compared to its rivals with their more standard networks, and although it has almost two-thirds of the mobile base in China, its rate of conversion from 2G to higher ARPU 3G has been slower than those at Unicom and Telecom.

Apple will open more retail shops in China, which will eventually become the company’s biggest market, Cook told local journalists. The company will also lure consumers, and address operators’ rising irritation with subsidies, by offering instalment payments on iPhones and iPads. Apple will now allow customers to pay CNY300 ($48) or more upfront and then spread the rest of the cost over 12 months interest-free. For longer payment terms, interest charges will apply ‘ 6.5% for 18 months and 8.5% for 24 months. The plans are supported by the the Merchants Bank credit card provider.

Such strategies could be powerful in a country where the iPhone 5’s prices start at CNY5288 ($850) ‘ equivalent to about six weeks’ pay for the average urban worker – and the iPad at CNY3688. Apple’s operator partners, China Unicom and China Telecom, do subsidize the iPhone for contract users, but the majority of users are on prepaid deals.

Premium device costs not only squeeze market share, when Apple is up against rivals with a wider variety of price points, but also encourage the grey market, already a major source of smuggled or counterfeit iDevices in China. Many operators are starting to offer instalment plans to reduce their reliance on subsidies and grow their prepaid bases, and vendors will see the attraction of this approach too. In Apple’s case, it allows it to retain the high price, and associated brand value, of its products while still making it easier for people on moderate incomes to buy. Later in the year, many expect the vendor to launch a lower cost ‘iPhone mini’ to penetrate more deeply into emerging economies.

‘There is an enormous midrange consumer market that they are not tapping into,’ Mark Natkin of Beijing-based Marbridge Consulting told Bloomberg. ‘They’re trying to figure out how to make products more accessible to that market segment. This is a good step in that direction.’ While financing is a traditional route to extend the reach of a premium product once the high income consumers are saturated, it is unusual in China and Apple will be an early mover in consumer credit there.

Apple actually already offers customers financing options in some other markets, notably Brazil, Singapore and, in a limited time offer, the US. Users of the online store in Brazil can pay in 12 instalments with American Express, MasterCard or Visa, and in Singapore, there is a 12-month interest-free plan on purchases of at least S$668 ($545) with a Citibank credit card.

Such tactics will become increasingly important as smartphone growth moves towards emerging markets, and Apple could also do with regaining some cachet among younger customers. The iPhone is no longer the device of choice among teenagers, the group all handset makers chase in order to achieve ‘cool’ and to achieve brand loyalty at an early age, according to a study by Buzz Marketing. This says teens now crave a Samsung Galaxy device or even a Microsoft Surface tablet. Buzz Marketing’s Tina Wells told Forbes: “Teens are telling us Apple is done. Apple has done a great job of embracing Gen X and older (millennials), but I don’t think they are connecting with millennial kids.”

One way that many supporters want Apple to connect with younger users and emerging economies is to bring out the long-rumored smaller iPhone. The latest reports of this device have gathered pace since the start of the new year, but the vendor’s SVP of global marketing, Phil Schiller, told a Chinese newspaper: ‘A cheaper iPhone? Not for us.’ He said in an interview with the Shanghai Evening News: ‘More people are using smartphones in China, some manufacturers are beginning to develop low cost smartphones to replace featurephones, but this is not within Apple’s product development direction.’ He said market share was not Apple’s primary metric, and was merely a ‘by-product’ of selling the best products (at a premium).

Of course, steering clear of a featurephone replacement does not mean Apple will not release a somewhat smaller, cheaper smartphone for the midmarket, which would risk the dilution of its brand value, but would, conversely, enable it to keep the larger iPhone in the premium range while still appealing to new markets. This will be a difficult balance, but one Apple has already achieved with the iPod nano and Shuffle, and the iPad mini. And many believe the firm cannot continue to grow with its one-model-per-year strategy for smartphones, in the face of Samsung’s multifaceted challenge. And of course, under Steve Jobs, the supplier had a tradition of writing off product rumors and then launching the same form factors later.

And many analysts remain insistent that Apple needs a smaller iPhone. Gene Munster of Piper Jaffray said in a recent research note that a $199 model could provide tens of millions of new unit sales, writing: “We believe the opportunity for Apple is too large to miss as the low end market is growing significantly faster than the high end smartphone market.’

He said in another note: ‘We note that the cheapest iPhone, the iPhone 4, currently costs $450 off-contract and more in many countries where additional taxes are levied. We note that an off-contract iPhone 4 is about $490 in China and $750 in Brazil, thus the sub-$199 price would be a significant discount. Historically, we believe lower priced products have had a measurable positive impact on overall revenue (iPad Mini, iPod Nano).”