France Telecom is seeking to buy back full control of Orange, in a move that is widely seen as part of the trend for operators to reintegrate their wired and wireless operations to maximize profits.
This pattern is a reversal of the thinking of the telecoms boom, when operators looked to distance their mobile units to compete freely and adopt distinctive management strategies ‘ some, like BT, spinning them off completely.
The French telco is offering minority shareholders in Orange, which control 13.6% of the company, 11 shares for each 25 Orange stocks. This will give them a 12% stake in FT. The bid has an implied value of €7bn and puts an 18% premium on Orange’s closing price on Friday, which rose 12% to €9.47 on news of the FT offer. This is still three eurocents below the price offered to investors during the flotation of February 2001.
Although the FT bid reflects broader patterns in the telecoms world, it is also specific to the company. New CEO Thierry Breton is keen to make his mark by reversing what he sees as the excessive decentralization of the group. The company is financially healthier following a state-backed €15bn rights issue but is still heavily debt-ridden, to the tune of €49.3bn, and Orange’s strong cashflow is attractive. By fully consolidating Orange on its balance sheet, FT could also take advantage of massive deferred tax credits that the mobile unit gained because of heavy losses on investment. These benefits amount to $2bn over the next three years.
And some European telcos have no plans to follow FT’s lead. Deutsche Telekom still seems bent on floating off T-Mobile at some stage, while analysts do not believe Telecom Italia could afford to buy full control of its mobile arm.
In the first half, Orange saw operating profit rise by 68% to €2.09bn.
The purchase of the rest of Orange was made possible by recent changes in French law, which allow FT to buy the rest of the operator, and in theory its internet unit Wanadoo, even though these moves dilute the French state’s stake in FT. This must still remain above 50%, although the government is seeking to change this rule too as its holding in FT is its most valuable monetizable asset.