Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 April 2006

Freescale discards its own UWB Forum to sharpen its market focus

UltraWideBand (UWB) has suffered more than any other recent technology initiative from the in-fighting and bureaucracy of standards committees. The IEEE attempt to create a UWB-based standard for fast short range networks, 802.15.3a, became stalemated and led to the formation of two breakaway groups, the WiMedia Alliance and the UWB Forum. Now Freescale, the founder and leading light of the latter, is pulling out of its own Forum, saying that it needs to streamline its efforts on winning in the market, and not be ‘defocused with concerns such as regulations, certification, interoperability and common signaling schemes’, as Freescale’s UWB director Martin Rofheart put it in an interview.

This in effect means the end of the UWB Forum, and leaves its technology, Direct Sequence UWB, the preserve of one major company, Freescale itself, with no further pretense at being a de facto industry standard. Motorola, the co-founder of the UWB Forum, with its former subsidiary Freescale and Pulse~Link, is also said to be quitting.

It will be interesting to see what Pulse~Link, which is heavily focused on UWB for high definition television in-home networks, will do next, although its technology is sufficiently differentiated to make an impact on its own, either directly or after acquisition by a wireless or consumer electronics player. The company said it would remain in the Forum with the 100 or so other members, mainly small players. The single-minded focus of Freescale on wireless USB seems to sideline Pulse~Link, but may also give it the freedom to approach new partners with more interest in the HDTV market.

The only way for Freescale to achieve a de facto standard position now will be by winning customers, not industry supporters, and the chipmaker is focusing almost entirely, in the short term at least, on a wireless replacement for USB. The WiMedia Alliance, which is led by Intel and Texas Instruments and contains many heavy hitters from the radio and consumer electronics worlds, has created Wireless USB with the USB Alliance. However, Freescale claims its own alternative, Cable-Free USB, is a more immediate and low cost option as it does not require new hardware.

The debate shows up the differences in objective between Intel and Freescale. Intel’s primary objective is to drive PC upgrades as it did by incorporating Wi-Fi into the laptop and as it hopes to do again with WiMAX, reducing the average time between notebook refreshes. Therefore, WiMedia will require new drivers and hardware, and so will only work with the newest PCs, encouraging new purchase. By contrast, CableFree USB works with existing USB hardware and drivers, since Freescale’s aim is to generate a mass market for itself in the actual UWB chips, which Intel has dismissed as a low margin sideline compared to boosting processor sales (it is possible it will not manufacture WiMedia chips itself at all).

Whether Freescale can get market share in the wireless USB space will presumably determine whether it continues in the UWB market at all. It is showing determination at least to give it a shot, despite the heavy support for WiMedia. “We don’t think anything else matters for UWB more than our approach with [Cable Free] USB 2.0. We’re showing our hand: the battle for UWB is on. We’re pulling out of every effort not related to it,’ Rofheart told EETimes. After that, the next priorities will be battling to win support for a wireless version of the 1394 FireWireless interconnect, heavily used by Apple ‘ and so raising interesting possibilities of a UWB-based wireless connection for the iPod. Another near term effort will be focused on HDMI (High Definition Multimedia Interface), said Freescale.