The FCC’s plans to improve public safety communications through a public-private partnership system in 700MHz are in disarray following the collapse of the leading contender to run the operation, Frontline Wireless. This leaves uncertainty as to who will bid for Block D of the spectrum ‘ which carries public safety requirements – in the imminent auctions, arousing fears of a bitter blow to a flagship policy of FCC chief Kevin Martin. It also gives weight to the argument that, for all the talk of innovative business models in 700MHz, in fact it will fall in the end to the usual suspects, with Verizon and AT&T the most likely to pick up Block D.
Frontline was set up in 2007 and addressed the upcoming 700MHz auction with a suggested approach almost as radical and much discussed as Google’s open networks ideas for Block C (the area where the FCC has imposed somewhat diluted open access requirements on winners). Frontline aimed to build a network in partnership with public safety agencies ‘ and unlike other likely bidders in this block, actually put these together ‘ in which emergency response would have priority, with remaining capacity used for a commercial wholesale network designed to support smaller and innovative providers. This would achieve two goals dear to Martin’s heart ‘ stimulate new competition, especially in rural and underserved areas, and increase overall public safety capacity (there is also a portion of 700MHz set aside for public safety only).
Frontline was controversial from the start, with opponents arguing that, by playing the public safety card (the reserve price for Block D is far less than for other blocks because of the safety obligations), the start-up was trying to get its hands on cheap spectrum and even bypass the full auction process. Despite this, the organization ‘ co-founded by former FCC chairman Reed Hundt, a great campaigner for a more flexible telecoms model in the US ‘ attracted some of Silicon Valley’s most successful investors, including James Barksdale of Netscape fame and John Doerr, the legendary VC from Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers.
Despite this, Frontline has failed to line up sufficient funding to bid in the auction. It had raised the $128m needed as a deposit, with backing from some phone companies and regional wireless providers as well as the original VCs, but sources said it could not get close to the $1.3bn reserve price for Block D, or any further sums needed to top potential competitive bids from deep pocketed companies like Verizon and AT&T, which have been hostile to the idea of having a new competitor supporting open access. One proposal, sources said, was to create an alliance with the major cablecos, which are looking for ways to add wireless to their fixed broadband services, but apparently talks with Comcast and Time Warner Cable collapsed over investor nervousness, especially after the disappointing performance of the cablecos’ venture with Sprint Nextel.
Verizon and AT&T are now in pole position to get Block D, although there are doubts over whether they will be prepared to negotiate with public safety agencies in order to build the advanced network for first responders that is mandated. Much will probably depend on how successful they are in gaining licenses for a decent price in other parts of the band.
Another bidder in Block D will be mobile satellite player Terrestar (FCC rules require that satellite capacity be built into to at least one handset operating in the D Block). Terrestar’s plan is not dissimilar from Frontline’s, to combine terrestrial/satellite services for public safety and commercial use with a wholesale model to support emerging smaller operators. Terrestar recently chose Nokia Siemens to supply it with its first all-IP system, the basis for a planned wide range of consumer, business and public safety services using its hybrid spectrum rights across north America (see Wireless Watch September 10 2007).
However, despite the low reserve price, there is now a real possibility that no bidders will come forward in Block D. ‘With the recent press reports regarding Frontline’s implosion as a viable bidder, concerns among FCC and public safety officials are growing over the fate of the D Block and the success of the auction itself. If the reserve price for the D Block is not met, it can be re-auctioned with or without the same rules,’ Jessica Zufolo, a telecom analyst at Medley Global Advisors, told RCRnews.
‘The Public Safety Spectrum Trust thinks it is important for the FCC to continue to do all that it can to advance the public/private partnership concept intended to build a nationwide broadband network for public safety,’ said Harlin McEwen, chairman of the non-profit group licensed to work with a commercial winner of the D Block. ‘While it would not be appropriate for the PSST to comment on any potential bidder’s strategy, we want to restate our enthusiasm for and commitment to what the FCC has done.’
Some observers are suggesting that, if nobody takes up the Block D plan, the FCC should look to other spectrum options for its safety network, in particular reviving the idea of using Sprint Nextel’s iDEN system, once its commercial users are transitioned to CDMA and/or Xohm WiMAX. Given the value that would attach to iDEN in any crisis over public safety spectrum, some investors are calling on new Sprint CEO Dan Hesse to go public on a date for moving iDEN subscribers to other networks.
Among the most prominent companies whose applications to bid for 700MHz licenses have been approved are Cox Communications (but not its usual spectrum hunting partners Comcast and Time Warner); Verizon Wireless and AT&T Mobility; Google; Qualcomm; smaller cellcos like Alltel, US Cellular, Leap and MetroPCS; Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen; Chevron USA; and EchoStar. Sprint Nextel, Clearwire, DirecTV and Mobile Satellite Ventures have all opted out, although MSV says it aims to be the satellite partner of choice for the Block D winner.
Approved applications:
Adams Telcom
Aeronet Wireless Broadband
AlasConnect
Aristotle
AWS Spectrum
Bayou Internet
BEK Communications Cooperative
Bend Cable Communications
Blanca Telephone Company
Blue Sky Cell
Bluegrass Wireless
Bresnan Communications
Broadband Wireless Unlimited
Budget Phone
Cavalier Wireless
Central Texas Telephone Investments
Chariton Valley Communication
Chester Telephone Company
Clearcom
COLI
Command Connect
Cricket Licensee 2007
Cross Telephone Company
CTC Telcom
Data-Max Wireless
Delmarva Broadband
Ellijay Telephone Company
Farmers Telecommunications Cooperative
Farmers Telephone Company
Fidelity Communications
Forum Communications
FTC Management Group
Glenwood Telephone Membership Corporation
Golden Belt Telephone Association
Google Airwaves
Grain Spectrum
Great American Broadband
GreenFly
H & B Communications
Horry Telephone Cooperative
Inland Cellular Telephone Company
IT&E Overseas
KeyOn Spectrum Holdings
Kinex Networking Solutions
Kingdom Telephone Company
Kurian, Thomas K
Lackawaxen Long Distance Company
Landover PCS Holdings
MAC Wireless
Manti Telephone Company
Medicine Park Telephone Company
Midwest AWS Limited Partnership
Miller, David
Mt. Vernnon.Net
TN3B Consortium
Mulberry Cooperative Telephone Company
NE Colorado Wireless Technologies
Neptuno Media
Northeast Missouri Rural Telephone Company
Northeast Nebraska Telephone Company
Northern Iowa Communications Partners
Panhandle Telecommunication Systems
Paul Bunyan Rural Telephone Cooperative
PBP Bidco
PCS Partners
Piedmont Rural Telephone Cooperative
Polar Communications Mutual Aid Corporation
Public Service Wireless Services
Red River Rural Telephone Association
Sandhill Communications
Siskiyou Telephone Company
Small Ventures USA
Spectrum Acquisitions
Star Telephone Membership
Swayzee Telephone
TCT West
Terra World Communications
The Chillicothe Telephone Company
The Tri-County Telephone Association
The World Company
Towerstream
Tri-Valley Communications
Triad 700
USA Choice Internet Services Company
Valley Telephone Cooperative
Van Buren Wireless
Vavasi NexGen
Vermont Telephone Company
Vulcan Spectrum
Washington County Rural Telephone Cooperative
West Wisconsin Telcom Cooperative
Wi
Wireless Communications Venture
Worldcall
WUE
Xpressweb Internet Services
A further 170 organizations had their applications ruled incomplete by the FCC, though many will still resubmit. These include cableco Advance/Newhouse, Alltel, AT&T Mobility, Cincinnati Bell Wireless, Cox Wireless, Lynch Wireless Broadband, MetroPCS, Qualcomm and Xanadoo.