The forthcoming auctions of 700MHz spectrum in the US are becoming an incredibly complex and politically fraught issue, as debates over the public safety allocations within the band heat up. While some spectrum is set aside specifically for public safety, two organizations – Cyren Call and Frontline Wireless – are also arguing that they should run hybrid emergency/commercial networks to boost overall safety capacity. In return, however, they would expect guaranteed or low cost access to licenses, something that the Wall Street Journal attacked in an editorial last week, arguing they were merely trying to bypass the auction process under the guise of helping public safety initiatives.
Whatever the rights and wrongs, Frontline is forging ahead. Some of Silicon Valley’s most successful investors – including James Barksdale of Netscape fame and John Doerr – have joined Frontline, and investment group set up and headed by former FCC chairman Reed Hundt, to bid for the spectrum. Frontline Wireless is pushing a technology that, it says, would allow the spectrum to be used for both wireless Internet and public safety emergency communications.
“I think we’re starved for spectrum for digital applications in this country,” Doerr said in the article. “The idea that we can have one or more great new digital networks is very exciting.” Doerr said the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development last year ranked the US twelth in the world last year in broadband penetration.
The CTIA, the mobile phone industry’s trade group, opposes Frontline’s proposal, wary of a new competitor for its members, while Google supports it as another potential channel for its search engines and adverts.
The auction could take place as early as this fall and is expected to bring in upwards of $30bn.