Since Motorola CEO Greg Brown conceded that he would consider spinning off the handset division, there has been speculation that the company’s other businesses would look for buyers, with their value boosted by the lack of the dragdown factor of the poorly performing phone business. Motorola’s networks business might be of interest to many of its competitors as the mobile infrastructure sector consolidates and becomes one of scale as much as technology, but currently much of the buzz is focused on the idea of a merger with Nortel, following an unsourced story in the Wall Street Journal last week that such talks were ongoing. Meanwhile, all the players are looking to reduce their costs and increase their volumes to compete with the massive market share and economies of scale of Ericsson, but this is tough at a time when operators are demanding accelerated delivery schedules for new technologies, notably LTE (see separate item). This will drive further consolidation, whether outright mergers or joint ventures in which resources for new development can be pooled, and the latest example is an alliance between Alcatel-Lucent and Japan’s NEC for LTE.
The need to make early impact in LTE and Mobile WiMAX is one element the logic behind a possible Motorola-Nortel deal. Both companies failed in UMTS but are strong in CDMA (together they would equal market leader Alcatel-Lucent in this sector), and both are highly dependent on stealing a march on the European vendors in WiMAX and LTE, in order to get back into the mobile carrier mainstream and position themselves better for 4G than they did for 3G. Strategically and technologically, then, there are harmonies, but this does not disguise the fact that tying together two companies with the same problems just doubles the problems. The strongest mutual market, CDMA, is one with a finite life and that will face ever decreasing margins, although there would be some benefit in a combined assault on migrating the CDMA base to LTE or WiMAX. Although Motorola has made a strong early showing in WiMAX, this is a market whose eventual scale is still uncertain, and in which Nortel, despite some strong technological advances, has yet to score major customer deals. And in LTE both face the huge challenge of taking on the big three Europeans, plus the rapidly developing Chinese duo, with no base in UMTS ‘ the natural early market for LTE.
It is likely that both companies need to be acquired, but although they are known to have talked many times over the past decade about possible merger, it has never looked like a worse idea than it does now. Instead, they should seek separate buyers, and ones that could exploit the strengths that both still have ‘ such as Motorola’s in broadband wireless and early IMS, and Nortel’s in unified communications and IP systems. We have tipped Huawei to take Motorola, and there is still strong logic to that. In theory the Chinese major could be a good parent for Nortel too, but even in its damaged state, the company is so important to the Canadian economy that it would be likely to be heavily protected by the government from acquisition by a Chinese player. Cisco has always looked like a neat partner for Nortel because of its shift towards carrier markets (as witnessed by its Navini purchase) and the synergies in carrier IP systems and enterprise networks (in the latter, Nortel has the valuable unified communications alliance with Microsoft, which has been woefully under-exploited so far). However, there are also rumors that Cisco would buy the WiMAX product line from Motorola, as well as its enterprise networking business based around Symbol, leaving the cellular networks product lines for another acquirer ‘ perhaps Ericsson, whose protestations of being shy of major takeovers are probably disingenuous.
Meanwhile, Alcatel-Lucent continues to struggle with its own merger, as evinced by another set of poor financial results, but undaunted, continues to make further industry alliances to boost its scale and reach, and reduce the time and cost of entering new markets. It has formed a joint venture with NEC to develop LTE products, and may extend the remit to other technologies too – one may be WiMAX, where both vendors compete, but neither have made strong progress, and they mentioned CDMA, optical, IP routing and IMS as other possible areas of collaboration.
No financial details of the terms of the venture were released, but it expects to produce trial equipment this year and commercial deployments in 2009. NEC – whose president Kaoru Yano co-chaired the announcement at the Mobile World Congress with AlcaLu chief Pat Russo ‘ brings to the party the undoubted benefit of its close relationship with Japanese operator NTT DoCoMo. Although DoCoMo has said that it does not want to move ahead of the LTE standard as it did in UMTS ‘ where it rolled out its FOMA service so early that it was based on a pre-standard, largely DoCoMo-devised, implementation ‘ it has been one of the most active operators in trialling and defining pre-LTE systems, and has massive influence on the standards processes through its own R&D and through operator forums. NEC has been one of the vendors taking part in DoCoMo’s early trials of LTE technology and will have learned a great deal from that experience, as well as being in a strong position to take some of the carrier’s contracts from 2009. For its part, AlcaLu has been taking part in LTE trials with Verizon Wireless, which together with its partner Vodafone and DoCoMo, is likely to be the most influential early carrier in LTE. The key focus is on FDD, despite the recent focus on TDD modes by Ericsson and the Chinese.
Both company chiefs moved to quell certain speculation arising from the tie-up. Yano said it would not affect NEC’s current relationship with Nokia Siemens for UMTS, while Russo denied that this was the first step in a spin-off of the wireless business, which is dragging down financials of the whole group. The Franco-American company posted a huge loss for Q4 2007 and offered a gloomy outlook for growth in 2008.
One of the shocks was a €2.5bn impairment charge in the fourth quarter, almost entirely down to a revaluation of the CDMA business, in which Lucent is the market leader. In the light of Verizon Wireless’ decision to move to LTE at the 4G stage, and other carrier defections from CDMA, there is now a slowdown in this sector and it is unlikely to have a next generation business of its own. Alcatel-Lucent lost €2.58bn in the fourth quarter, after taking the €2.52bn charge. On an adjusted basis, net loss narrowed to €48m, from €618m last year. Revenue rose 18% to €5.23bn, reflecting a strengthening of the firm’s position in optics and broadband. For the full year, though, revenues were down 2.5% to €17.79 billion ($25.8 billion), compared with pro forma numbers for the previous year (the revenues Alcatel-Lucent would have generated as a combined company for the whole of 2006). Without the one-time charges, the net loss for 2007 was €443m ($643m), compared with a pro forma net income for 2006 of €522m ($757m).
All this has revived criticisms that Alcatel overpaid for Lucent, in a merger that valued the US company at about $13bn at the time. Russo responded: ‘The market valuations for our whole industry have changed since the merger was announced two years ago. This is an adjustment based on our long term view of the business.’ However, she remained cautious about revenue growth in 2008, pointing to the impact of global credit squeeze on telco spending. She forecast that the telecoms equipment market would be flat to slightly higher if the effects of currency fluctuations were factored in, or slightly down if currencies were not adjusted.
AT&T expands HSPA:
AT&T has responded to the accelerated plans of Verizon Wireless to move towards LTE by bringing its own LTE timescales forward, from 2011 to 2009, and by stepping up its roll-out plans for UMTS/HSPA data services. This is proving a much needed boost for the beleaguered Alcatel-Lucent, which is to provide Node B equipment for the network expansion and upgrade plan.
The French company told online newsletter Unstrung that the distributed nature of its Node B offering was key to the win, giving the operator greater flexibility in deployment.
‘One of the big challenges for operators is being able to place their base stations. There are regulatory issues and zoning issues involved,’ spokesperson Kurt Steinert said. ‘With distributed Node B you don’t have to have all the components in the same place – they could be up to a kilometer apart.’
Lucent was one of three suppliers chosen for UMTS by Cingular, as AT&T Mobility was then called, along with Siemens and Ericsson. Recently there has been speculation that the cellco would reduce its dependence on AlcaLu, so this latest deal will be a major relief for the merged vendor.
ZTE and Motorola?
ZTE appeared to put itself in the frame to bid for Motorola’s handset business when it said it was looking to increase its share of the world cellphone market, and that it was
in talks about deepening its relationship with Motorola through ‘wider cooperation’. ZTE has a target of entering the top five phonemakers within three years, something that will almost certainly require acquisition, but it is uncertain whether it could afford the estimated $9bn-$12bn price tag for Motorola’s phone unit.