Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 March 2013

Galaxy S4 ‘ smartphone at a mobile crossroads

Galaxy S4 ‘ smartphone at a mobile crossroads

Significance: Samsung has achieved an almost Apple-like ability to generate hype about its major product launches, and it even chose a favorite Apple venue, New York’s Radio City Music Hall, to unveil the Galaxy S4. However, while the reviewers and bloggers analyzed the handset’s actual features in forensic detail, this really is not just another handset. Not because it shifts the design goalposts as Apple once did, but because its epitomizes the crossroads at which the main mobile platforms vendors find themselves. The S4 shows Samsung creating a full software and services platform, under its ‘S’ label, which runs on Android, but almost entirely obscures that fact ‘ with profound implications for Google’s future strategies. Samsung is also likely to bring ‘S’ to its upcoming new operating system, Tizen, potentially creating a counterweight to Android/Google ‘ something it is in a unique position to do because of its control over its supply chain, shared only by Apple (and not, as delays to the HTC One highlight, by other Android OEMs). Meanwhile, Samsung has moved on from being a hardware product to being confident about software and user experience, and that throws down a new gauntlet to Apple, whose previously unchallenged mobile user interface is starting to look tired.

Google replaces Android with ‘S’ in its user experience

The big theme among the major mobile platform makers over recent months has been the harmonized user experience, spanning smartphones, tablets, televisions and cars. But of course, designing a UI and developer framework that really does work well across those different screen sizes and user behaviors is very tough.

Microsoft has made a bold attempt with its Metro UI, and there are signs that it will converge Windows Phone entirely with Windows 8 ‘ but its platform remains a niche one, and very much an acquired taste for most users and developers. Of course the traditional Windows experience had to go and move to a touch-based system, but Microsoft took a huge gamble which has not immediately paid off ‘ Windows Phone and Windows RT sales appear, so far, to be slow, while the conventional PC space supported by Windows 8 Pro may face its first ever quarter of double-digit decline, according to some forecasts.

Apple has the same risks. It has held back from converging its Mac and iDevice operating systems and from delivering a full TV experience. Its caution is understandable, given the powerful grip of its current mobile OS, but it is in danger of falling into the trap made famous by Henry Ford, of listening to customers and delivering just a ‘faster horse’ instead of a car. Sacrilegious as it may sound, people are starting to whisper that iOS looks tired and the recent launch of the Samsung Galaxy 4S, and even the HTC One, just reminded reviewers that the Apple platform had delivered no fundamental changes for years.

By contrast, the Samsung and HTC devices sported a range of software enhancements and user interfaces that looked fresh and somewhat un-Android like. That, of course, is Google’s nightmare. It may be pushing Android towards new products like tablets and HTML5-enabled cars, especially if it converges the mobile system with Chrome OS (see Wireless Watch March 14 2013), but it lacks the control to ensure that the multiscreen experience remains consistent among different OEMs. So a Samsung phone and TV may, in future, look very similar, but they may look nothing like a Nexus phone or TV ‘ which significantly reduces Google’s control and its ability to push its services and revenue generators to the fore.

In future, there may be even greater challenges from the web-oriented emerging platforms for organizations like Firefox, Baidu and Russia’s Yandex, but for now, Samsung is the main concern for Google’s vision of a unified Android experience. It has been trying to assert that by delivering its own hardware, the expanding Nexus range, but even though Samsung makes Nexus devices, it also feels free to create its own flavors of Android on its other devices, notably Galaxy. Samsung needs to differentiate itself, and increasingly that is done in software as well as hardware, and since it has the lion’s share of the Android device market, its interpretations of Android, and its choice of homescreen apps, get far greater visibility than Google’s.

Google’s dilemma ‘ encourage the vast expansion of Android via openness, or close it down around its own user experience ‘ is made even worse when Samsung starts to promote alternative operating systems. The Korean firm has always been non-dogmatic when it comes to platforms and has usually supported anything with even a small amount of market share, but its behavior has become more threatening to Google recently. First it developed its own OS, baidu ‘ a sign that the firm was placing more of its vast R&D resources into software rather than relying on Google and Microsoft. Now it is reportedly merging that into the open source, Linux-based system Tizen and plans to launch smartphones running that system this year. The move may be partly posturing, to assert itself against Google, but if it puts any real weight behind Tizen, it could fracture the open source, Linux mobile market which Android has monopolized for the past few years ‘ and put itself in a strong position to lead the gradual shift to ‘thin’ HTML5 gadgets attached to the cloud.

Google and Microsoft may recently have decided they need to ‘do an Apple’ and deliver integrated hardware and software, but their hardware track record is minimal and their software platforms are starting to age. By contrast Samsung, currently the most powerful mobile hardware player in the world, is not only modernizing Android off its own bat, but introducing a second string too.

There were some signs of the much discussed Samsung-Google rift in the launch of the Galaxy S4 last week ‘ or at least, of Samsung gaining confidence in its ability to launch a whole platform, not just devices. Of course, Samsung is in the place Apple enjoyed a couple of years ago, where it could launch a yogurt carton on a piece of string, call it Galaxy and have a hit on its hands. But it will also know, from the Apple story, that this is a dangerous moment. Unquestioning love quickly turns to disappointment. And a fresh user experience is the best, if the most difficult, way to avoid that fate.

Any device can be the ‘next big thing’ based on a combination of slick marketing and eye-catching features. But a user experience which becomes addictive and underpins all a customer’s activities creates real loyalty, or even lock-in. Until now, Samsung’s experience has not been sufficiently different to prevent a Galaxy customer taking his or her applications to an HTC phone next time, but now it is clearly aiming to change that.

Attendees at the S4 launch noted that there was no specific mention at all of Google or Android (though the specs indicated that the handset would run Android 4.2.2 or JellyBean, the newest iteration). Samsung had plenty of software and services to talk about, but all of these ride above the OS and are heavily branded with its ‘S’ trademark (S-Drive, S-Translator and so on, many direct substitutes for Google offerings). This is the world often visualized, pre-Android, by Google ‘ the OS becoming hidden and largely irrelevant; a full platform of web services layered on top; increasingly with processing carried out in the browser and the cloud. It’s just that Samsung is using Android as the underpinnings, though in future, it could port these offerings wholesale to Tizen (or any other OS that takes its fancy, except Windows Phone, where Microsoft controls the experience).

Samsung has not played around with Android quite as much as Amazon, which has also shown the potential to create a Google-free experience while still tapping into the huge Android software ecosystem. But it is claiming that its own services are superior even to those embedded into the OS by Google ‘ because they are integrated into the hardware and harness its capabilities directly. In other words, it has stolen the integrated hardware/software mantra of Apple, without even bothering to develop its own OS (yet).

This strategy means that Samsung has no need to take the risk of abandoning Android, which may well remain dominant for years to come while the new breed of web-based OSs and user behaviors find their feet. But it is leaving the Android name behind and building a full platform of apps, services and content stores, which in time can span different screens and devices, and potentially different OSs. Given that it already has various rather fragmented media hubs and content shops, a branded app store, like Amazon’s for Kindle Fire, cannot be far behind.

“We wanted to talk about the Samsung experience,” Ryan Bidan, US director of marketing and the cheerleader of the launch event in New York, told CNet. “While Android is important, in the context of this conversation, we didn’t feel it was relevant.” That is a crushing remark for Google to hear from its biggest OEM, though one it has never treated with the favour it has shown at various times to Motorola and HTC.

The Korean giant just does not have the malleability of those more challenged device makers, and that has become very clear since Galaxy S4 made its debut. Just as Google has tried to address Android’s greatest weakness, its fragmentation, by imposing a common UE on its partners, now Samsung wants to do the same ‘ by making its own ‘S’ platform the default, supported by its huge market share (over 30% of all smartphones in 2012 and over half of Androids) and $11bn marketing budget.

Among the specifics of the software platform, Samsung has been investing heavily in improving its once-clunky TouchWiz user interface and has moved on from a firm making cosmetic changes, but basically being a hardware innovator. Features include AirView, which enables a user to interact with the phone by just hovering a finger over the display, and AirBrowse, another gesture function which enables calls to be answered and photos browsed using a wave of the hand. The most hyped software addition has been Smart Pause, which uses facial recognition (though falls just short of eye tracking) to detect when a user is looking at the screen and pause content if they look away.

Samsung is also highlighting the fashionable area of smartphone as health monitor, including a range of custom applications under the S-Health label, imcluding integrated pedometer, and optional heart rate monitor or pedometer band. Other software includes text reading, via optical character recognition, and language translation.

On the hardware front, consistently the area where Samsung’s vast resources genuinely outdo Apple, most of the changes had been well leaked. The eight-core processor, the super-high resolution screen, the 13-megapixel camera with associated imaging gimmickry ‘ all these were present and correct, and playing to Samsung’s strengths. Perhaps not quite the ‘quantum leap’ which the head of Samsung’s mobile business, JK Shin, proclaimed at the event at New York’s Radio City Music Hall (previously an Apple venue), but certainly impressive enough not to dash any but the wildest hopes.

The new phone is slimmer (7.9 millimeters) and slightly lighter (130 grams) than its predecessor and has a slicker look. While some models will have the eight-core Exynos processor, US versions will sport only a quad-core CPU, but that comes with an integrated LTE modem. The 5-inch screen sports Full HD Super AMOLED technology with higher resolution than the iPhone 5’s, at 441ppi. There are 2Gbytes of memory; cameras at 13mp and 2mp; all flavors of Wi-Fi up to the new 802.11ac plus 42Mbps HSPA+ and Bluetooth 4.0; Category 3 LTE in FDD and TDD variants; with NFC and GPS. There is also an infrared blaster for controlling TV sets. The dual-camera function uses both camera sensors at the same time and provides eight ways to combine the images ‘ for instance, filming an event and inserting the user’s reaction into the images.

Of course, one of Samsung’s advantages is that it has the resources to keep its options open. Unlike Apple, Samsung will have other shots at impressing its public this year. There will be new Galaxy Notes and other high end handsets, but also new Windows and Chrome products and behind it all, the efficient supply chain and the massive distribution channels which will turn glitzy marketing into sales and profits. Like Apple ‘ and no other OEM ‘ Samsung utterly controls its supply chain and can outsell most of its other rivals combined with a single launch. Therefore it is far less risky for Samsung than for smaller firms to put its weight behind yet another platform, Tizen, especially now that it is successfully removing Android from users’ minds when they buy a Samsung device.

It will launch its first device with its new OS in September. Tizen is an open source Linux-based mobile OS, formed by merging two previous initiatives ‘ the operator-driven LiMO, and MeeGo, the Intel/Nokia development which was a casualty of Nokia’s decision to throw in its lot with Microsoft. Intel itself and Samsung are the major backers of Tizen and the Korean firm is thought to have merged elements of its homegrown bada OS into its implementation.

Bada enjoyed some success, especially in parts of Europe, on the Wave family of midrange handsets, but has only 1.3% of the total mobile OS market according to Bada. Now Tizen seems poised to be Samsung’s second string OS ‘ especially after its new co-CEO, and mobile chief, JK Shin said recently that it was seeing only ‘lackluster’ demand for its Windows Phone offerings, especially in Europe. Tizen fits into the trend for slimline mobile OSs geared to HTML5, streaming and cloud services. However, unlike rivals such as Firefox Mobile and Jolla Sailfish (also a MeeGo derivative), it is not making entry level smartphones its initial target. Instead, Samsung is believed to be launching it on a high end product, which could be seen as a shot across Google’s bows, reminding the search giant that Samsung is not entirely reliant on Android.

Samsung’s EVP of mobile, Lee Young Hee, told Bloomberg that a Tizen handset “in the high end category” would be out in August or September. The firm recently showed off a reference model running the OS. ‘The device will be the best product equipped with the best specifications,’ said Lee.

As seen in last week’s Galaxy S4 launch, Samsung’s great strength lies in its ability to mobilize huge numbers of operators and distribution channels round the world for its flagship products. It has already signed up NTT Docomo and Orange to launch its Tizen smartphones. The vendor also offers the Ativ line running Windows Phone 8 and a new Galaxy Note is expected soon. Of course, applications are always the barrier to challenges to Android or iOS, at least until the HTML5, online-only model really takes off among consumers. However, Chase Perrin of the Tizen Association told Bloomberg: ‘Android, among other mobile operating systems, is tightly controlled. As an open source software platform, Tizen is designed to make it easy to develop for a range of devices.’

More importantly, it may provide another OS to support the ‘S’ platform and apps, and one that hedges Samsung’s bets against possible aggression by Google over Android in future.

So what can Google do? One, make its own hardware/software platform, Nexus, so excellent and well marketed that it hits back against ‘S’. This is not impossible for a firm of Google’s weight, especially if it banishes the Korean firm from the Nexus family and effectively creates an anti-Samsung alliance of all the others, lending them its R&D and marketing weight in return for them adopting its user experience. That would not happen overnight, but it is a realistic strategy, especially if it also brings in Chrome.

However, it will be a long and expensive process and the Nexus family will lack the unity and focus of a single vendor. And Google will risk entirely alienating the biggest seller of Android – and potentially Chrome OS ‘ products. It is likely, at least in the short term while it evolves Nexus, to make significant concessions to try to get Samsung back in the fold and primarily focused on Android (as opposed to ‘S’). With the biggest smartphone maker riding such a powerful wave, however, it is not clear what those concessions could be.