One by one, the big names in the 5G and IoT worlds are backing away from cloud hosting, and therefore from any shot at an end-to-end offering for distributed or industrial cloud services. AT&T and Verizon, for instance, gave up on the idea of competing with AWS and Azure and have been forming strategic partnerships with them instead – which may not stop the cloud giants from reaching further and further down into their world of connectivity (via shared spectrum) and networks-on-demand.
Now the same is seen in the Industrial IoT, where the giant of this space, GE, has shifted its Predix platform away from being a GE-hosted PaaS (platform-as-a-service) to one that can be spun up in private clouds, or public ones like AWS. The combination of GE Digital and Predix were meant to be an easy win for the industrial giant, able to trade on its brand name to create a cloud-based IoT platform that its customers, partners and even competitors would flock to.
But this has not been the case so far, partly because the IIoT itself is so immature and many companies have taken only small steps so far. However, a win with the Dubai Electricity and Water Authority (DEWA) is a sign that Predix may be close to turning a corner now that the burden of competing with AWS is over.
Under former GE CEO Jeff Immelt, who retired last October, GE Digital acquired ServiceMax ($915m) and Meridium ($495m) in 2016, to get the ball rolling, and started building data centers for Predix. However, GE’s falling market value began putting pressure on GE Digital, and so spending was apparently reined in and the shift away from its own cloud initiated.
Speaking to ComputerWorld, GE Digital’s CEO Bill Ruh said: “We realized very early on that being in the data center cloud business didn’t make any sense, because you’re in an arms race with Amazon and Microsoft and Google, who are spending billions and billions of dollars on data centers that you can’t and shouldn’t produce.”
Immelt’s replacement, John Flannery, said in November that GE Digital would become far more focused on a smaller group of applications, and now, three years into the project, he aims to double Predix’s 2017 revenues this year, to reach $1bn. According to Ruh, the new strategy is to pitch Predix at GE’s core customers, for specific applications (such as analytics or predictive maintenance), rather than trying to sell a platform on which to build their own capabilities.
Ruh added that this allowed GE engineers to focus on these chosen applications, rather than building out data centers. “We found ourselves focusing on two application areas – asset performance management and service automation – and really holding ourselves true to those areas. That’s proven to be really effective, because we’re really the leaders in those areas.”
Currently, the oil & gas, energy, and Industrial sectors are the largest customers for Predix. BP and EDF are active users, and a more recent partnership with SIG Holdings, a Swiss food packaging firm, saw Predix used in around 400 factories.
The new DEWA signing is a continuation of this pattern, with the authority looking to improve efficiency in its generation division. To this end, Predix is going to be integrated into its power plants, which will funnel data to the cloud-based Predix analytics system. Predictive maintenance, using AI-based analytics to spot in advance when an appliance or machine needs servicing, is the main objective here.
The retreat from the cloud will form the same kind of cautionary tale for other IIoT and PaaS players as the US telcos’ did to other operators.
Last year, AWS and AT&T announced the latest partnership in the increasingly multi-faceted alliance which has emerged since the latter gave up pretensions to be in Amazon’s cloud market – and which looks like a blueprint for how cloud and telco companies may carve up the IoT and enterprise 5G segments between them (at least, if the telco is one as powerful and as focused on software platforms and 5G as AT&T).
The two companies announced a landmark deal in October 2016, to cooperate in offering enterprise telecoms services, agreeing to integrate their respective networking and cloud capabilities. This goes well beyond existing work to connect devices to the cloud, and optimize those links – they will also cooperate on preconfiguring sensors and devices for efficiency in the IoT, and working on overall platform security and threat management.
Telcos used to dismiss the huge webscale businesses and argue that private or hybrid cloud providers would deliver greater value and optimized experience. But the economics of the giants are too great to resist – their costs, but also their ability to invest heavily in essential enablers like security. However, the public cloud majors still lack the ability to look deeply into the networks, so alliances with operators will hold significant value for them, especially in the IoT with its vast numbers of connections and sensors.
AT&T has drawn a clear line between what it believes to be the natural territory of the new virtualized, software-driven telco – of which it is one of the world’s most advanced examples – and what must be entrusted to partners. Its hope, no doubt, is that the actual cloud platform will become the commodity, not the newly flexible and programmable telco network – though of course, both will be just conduits for high value applications, services and virtual network functions (VNFs).
The trick for telcos will be to ensure they deliver enough of those high value elements to justify their huge investments in infrastructure, a process in which they will sometimes be competing with their own IT and cloud partners. But at least they can support huge scalability and remove at least one area of high cost from their plans by working with cloud giants. They can then concentrate on optimizing performance in their networks, and on deploying services and connectivity close to the user or the IoT device, via low latency connections and edge nodes. AT&T has a significant open source initiative around the edge called Akraino, though this makes little reference to the telco driven ETSI Multi-access Edge Computing (MEC) – (see separate item).
It remains to be seen which operators strike the right balance between cloud and edge, and between inhouse and partner infrastructure and services. With its program to virtualize 75% of its network elements, and its early moves to offer commercial SDN-enabled network-on-demand services to enterprises, AT&T is looking stronger than any other western operator and may, unusually for a telco, be in a powerful position with regards to the balance of power with Amazon.
Certainly, there should be immediate benefits for its internal efficiency and for its enterprise customers, which are vital to the growth of its mobile and fixed line businesses. Clients immediately gain an end-to-end view of their platforms, including data from applications which will sit in the AWS cloud. That app data will provide an additional input to AT&T’s threat intelligence system, Threat Intellect, widening the security perimeter and saving customers from having to bring their own security to the applications layer. Through its alliance with AWS, AT&T will provide app layer security as a managed or unmanaged service.
AT&T said at the time that some customers had been using AT&T’s NetBond cloud connectivity service in conjunction with AWS but were looking for additional security and IoT functions for their cloud connections, which will be part of the new partnership’s deliverables.
“One of the things we hear a lot is ‘We need end-to-end visibility to what is happening to our ecosystem from a customer perspective, what is happening at the premise, what is happening in the network and what is happening in the cloud’,” a spokesperson said.
In IoT, AT&T will offer devices that are preconfigured to send sensor data to the AWS cloud for storage and analytics, making it quicker and easier to launch IoT services. This is an example of how operator and cloud platform providers can be complementary rather than competitive, with Amazon supporting data storage and analytics, and AT&T providing device and subscription management, connectivity and billing.
Of course, whether these alliances remain harmonious will partly depend on where enterprises and other customers assign most value in terms of the chain of functionality. It is noticeable that AT&T is surrendering a hefty portion of data analytics – usually seen as the activity with the greatest potential for monetization – to its new friend. If operators are squeezed out of the big data analytics game, they run the risk of being bitpipes and billing engines while cloud and webscale companies use the data the telco devices generate to increase their own value.
All this sees AT&T acknowledging a reality which most carriers will have to do too – that they are not in a position to compete with AWS and Azure directly in offering cloud services. Indeed, AT&T CEO Randall Stephenson said last year: “We said we are not going to compete in this commoditized cloud. Actually, the cloud is what’s being commoditized; it’s not the network.”
But the telco has highly valuable expertise in device connectivity and management, and in provisioning and monetizing large numbers of gadgets and consumers. Stephenson added: “We said what we need to do is ensure that our customers can get from their mobile handset, through the network, into the cloud and back out without ever touching the public Internet.”
So alliances like this one are sure to proliferate, though some telcos will be more successful than others in avoiding a bitpipe role in the cloud, and securing a significant role in the value chain when they join forces with Amazon, Microsoft or vertical market platforms like GE’s Industrial Internet Initiative (in which AT&T is also the primary carrier member).