Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 September 2005

German convergence accelerates, setting key trends for Europe

Germany is not only one of Europe’s top three telecoms markets, but also one of the most competitive, and as fixed-mobile convergence starts to become a reality in some countries, it is providing the region’s most interesting indications of how this trend may work out in reality. The key dilemmas facing mobile and converged operators are epitomized in Germany, as incumbent Deutsche Telekom, with its mobile unit T-Mobile, defend their home ground against Vodafone, O2, E-Plus, and a growing line-up of virtual operators and start-ups. In particular, the big players are starting to address in earnest the questions of how to ensure that convergence and bundled services increase, rather than eat into, profitability; how to handle the crash of voice prices and the introduction of VoIP; and how to retain control of the broadband market, especially as it mobilizes, in the face of new challenges.

The decisions of the large players in Germany will be closely watched by operators elsewhere and, in many ways, will anticipate trends that will start to affect the whole of Europe and other regions too. The German telecoms market was worth €64.5bn in 2004, with mobile services just lagging fixed line on €22.1bn and €23bn respectively, a ranking that should reverse this year. In terms of minutes of use, fixed line use was 10 times greater than mobile, indicating the high tariffs that are customary in Germany, though being rapidly eroded. In 2004, Vodafone maintained a narrow market lead over T-Mobile in revenue terms, while 02 and E-Plus were about one-third of the size.

Deutsche Telekom may have been slower to go public with its fixed-mobile, all-IP convergence plans than British Telecom, but it is better positioned to capitalize on this trend, since it owns a successful mobile operator as well as a fixed line broadband provider, T-Com. These units will increasingly come together, so that bundles of fixed and mobile services, and the fabled triple play of voice, video and data, can be offered ‘ with flexible options for customers that will give them savings over buying the current separate services, but with increased margin for the operator, based on better customer retention, an increase in the average number of services delivered to each subscriber, and the efficiencies of running an integrated platform with economies such as a single billing and customer management system.

One of the first steps in the complex roadmap that will take DT to convergence is T-Mobile’s mobile@home service, which mirrors its UK counterpart’s Fusion service in allowing the cellphone to act as a single handset, supporting fixed network rates when at home or, under some tariffs, in the office. The cellphone links to the fixed network using Wi-Fi, in T-Mobile’s case (BT is currently using Bluetooth). The service should be commercially launched in the first quarter of 2006.

It is surprising that DT was not first into this game, since Germany is one of the countries being most dramatically affected by the trend to substitute fixed lines with mobile altogether. With Vodafone Germany boasting significantly higher net additions to its service in 2004 than T-Mobile, clearly not all this substitution is merely moving users from one department of DT to another. Mobile@home, and other upcoming services, will aim to stem that tide, and take advantage of DT’s unique advantage of owning both a fixed and mobile network. This is a bonus not enjoyed by BT, and one that puts it in a weaker position, despite its early and creative adoption of a converged all-IP route, than DT and France Telecom. BT, unless it acquires a cellular carrier or gains the spectrum to launch national mobile services using another technology like WiMAX, remains at the mercy of its MVNO (mobile virtual network operator) partnership with Vodafone. While Vodafone has similar challenges, since its lack of a fixed network is starting to look like a disadvantage in the converged world, rather than the liberation it once was, this alliance will always be an uneasy one, with the two UK giants’ interests increasingly starting to conflict.

Mobile@home is only the tip of the convergence iceberg for the German incumbent. It has a complex vision, articulated piecemeal over the past two years, of creating an all-IP system using a patchwork of different technologies, according to application, pricing/service expectation and terrain, to deliver a wide range of highly targeted services coordinated by an IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS).

T-Mobile has been one of the most advanced of the major cellular carriers in embracing a multi-network strategy, with its high profile use of Wi-Fi hotspots, especially in the US, to add value to its service bundles and offer broadband wireless in the pre-3G era. It is also looking to use true broadband wireless technologies to extend coverage in rural areas, the US and eastern European economies, where it may not be obliged to instal UMTS, and has announced roll-out of IPWireless UMTS TDD in the Czech Republic and trials of Flarion Flash-OFDM (now a Qualcomm technology) in the Netherlands.

Last year, T-Mobile’s CEO Rene Obermann outlined plans for integrated voice and data services working seamlessly across GSM, GPRS, W-CDMA and Wi-Fi, and possibly other networks in the future. The cellco formed an alliance with Cisco and Intel to start to create true convergence, rather than the superficial convergence of cellular and Wi-Fi that it currently offers at the level of branding and billing.

Initially, real steps are modest. T-Mobile is looking at common pricing plans for multi-network services and at offerings that are still heavily based on laptops or PDAs. Under its agreement with Cisco and Intel, it will carry out a three-month trial with groups of users in Germany, the UK and the US, who will be given laptops or T-Mobile PDAs, using GPRS, Wi-Fi and, later this year, 3G.

Over at sister company T-Com, Alvarion is supplying the equipment for DT’s first public WiMAX trial, aimed at parts of Germany currently not covered by DSL. T-Com is using Alvarion’s WiMAX-ready BreezeMAX 3500 system for the trial, which is scheduled to run until March 2006 in Swisttal and St Augustin near Bonn. Siemens is serving as systems integrator and maintenance supplier.

Walter Raizner, CEO of T-Com, said earlier this year that the company would pilot two critical technologies this year, WiMAX and a DSL service offering up to 25Mbps downlink. The combination of these two would create a more powerful broadband offering with wider coverage, and Raizner is also looking for closer integration with the cellular division, T-Mobile. He said: ‘We will deploy new radio technologies in order to improve the availability of broadband lines. We have already tested WiMAX technology thoroughly in our labs.’

T-Com is not the only company looking to deploy WiMAX in Germany. While DT’s WiMAX interests are currently conventional, geared at extending broadband coverage to unreachable terrains, it may have to be more aggressive if trials by Vodafone and O2 are successful. The latter illustrates the opportunity afforded by WiMAX, though rarely discussed, to enable cellular-only carriers to enter the home and fixed markets. This will become increasingly important, as we have seen, once carriers provide fixed-mobile convergence services and wireline operators shift into wireless, whether through WiMAX, an MVNO or by owning a cellular operator outright. In the US, Sprint Nextel will seek to compensate for its lack of a last mile network by creating one in broadband wireless ‘ O2 and Vodafone could do the same, and this could be a far less expensive and risky option than buying up wireline assets (although there is a case that Vodafone, in particular, should start to move towards being a converged carrier by buying wireline telcos, possibly the reason for its unusual reluctance to sell its wireline unit in Germany, Arcor, acquired along with Mannesmann in 2000).

One reason for the mobile operators to move into the residential sector is to assure control of the converged voice services like mobile@home, rather than lose this to the fixed carriers. This is especially urgent in Germany, where voice competition is already among the toughest in the world and becoming even harder with the growth of VoIP and no-frills MVNOs, which are eating rapidly into the traditionally high mobile tariffs of the established carriers in the country. This year, all the major cellcos have cut rates and Vodafone has introduced a flat rate service at home to counter VoIP offerings. Most recently, KPN-owned E-Plus, the fourth mobile operator in the market, has announced a flat rate mobile phone service called BASE. This will offer free calls to fixed line phones and to other E-Plus subscribers for €25 a month. Calls to other networks are available for €0.25 a minute. BASE is targeted at subscribers with average or high use, including business customers.

This comes in the wake of Vodafone’s low cost, flat rate offering. The cellco believes it can use the heavy capacity and spectral efficiency of its 3G network to deliver voice at low costs that will be comparable with most quality phone-based VoIP services and also provide the key attraction of IP offerings, flat predictable rates. Such strategies could enable the cellcos to keep their 3G networks in play in the voice market, though seriously reducing the margins they originally expected to make on delivering voice minutes more efficiently. This will increase the pressure to increase revenue from high margin data services and to upgrade UMTS networks, or even launch parallel mobile television or WiMAX data systems, to offload some of this traffic and deliver even higher bandwidth applications.

‘We have to move fast,’ said incoming CEO of Vodafone Germany, Fritz Joussen at the launch of the flat rate voice service. ‘If we don’t, fixed line usage might move to broadband.’ The service is likely to be extended to other territories. In Germany, it is called ‘Vodafone ZuHause Zone’, and offers 1,000 minutes of local and national calling for a flat fee of €20 ($24) per month, with extra charges for calls to mobiles and international lines, when the user is at home or within adjacent cells, giving a normal range of two kilometers radius. Initially, the service will be offered as a separate subscription with a dedicated handset that only works in the home zone, but from the fourth quarter, it will be available as an optional add-on to existing mobile subscriptions and handsets.

All these activities reveal a combination of tactical moves and strategic thinking, both geared to dealing with two inexorable trends. Cellular carriers need to adjust to the rise of VoIP as a competitive tool of wireline and alternative carriers, one that is merely a stepping stone toward these providers usurping other markets traditionally the preserve of the cellco. Meanwhile, wireline operators need to guard against fixed-to-mobile substitution with their own wireless plans. This should put a combined carrier like DT in a strong position, that it can use, if it can move rapidly enough to integrate its politically diverse divisions, to score points against the cellular-only operators.