Europe’s move to the second digital dividend is gathering pace, and by contrast with earlier LTE allocations, this one is being led by the biggest economies. Germany has concluded its 700 MHz spectrum auction, raising an impressive €5.08bn (across four bands) after a heated contest lasting for 16 days.
However, only €1bn ($1.14bn) of that total was actually for the 700 MHz licences, with 1.8 GHz spectrum attracting higher bids (1.8 GHz is more plentiful and is usable now). That makes France’s reserve price of almost €2.5bn, for its own 700 MHz auction later this year, seem ambitious, especially as ongoing consolidation may lead to a less intense competition for the airwaves in France than in Germany.
There, the auction ended on June 19 after 181 rounds, with Vodafone emerging as the biggest spender. It bid a total of €2.1bn across all four bands involved in the sale – 700 MHz, 900 MHz, 1.5 GHz and 1.8 GHz. Deutsche Telekom and Telefonica O2 will spend €1.8bn and €1.2bn respectively.
Vodafone gained 2 x 25MHz in the 1.8 GHz band, which saw intense bidding, according to auction specialists at Coleago Consulting. It helped drive up the total revenues by upping its bids in the 1.8 GHz band at a late stage.
The company said it would use its new assets to enhance its LTE network and “increase data capacity and speed on 4G, while improving voice quality on GSM services”, though of course, deployment in 700 MHz will have to wait until the spectrum is cleared of its current incumbents, the broadcasters. Their TV licences expire next year.
As well as its new assets in 1.8 GHz – the spectrum which is currently most popular for deploying LTE around the world, as operators start to refarm GSM frequencies in the band – Vodafone acquired 2 x 10 MHz in each of the sub-1 GHz bands. Deutsche Telekom gained 2 x 15 MHz in the 900 MHz and the 1.8 GHz bands, and 2 x 10 MHz in 700 MHz. Both these operators also bought 1 x 20 MHz in the unpaired 1.5 GHz band. Telefonica O2 passed on the 1.5 GHz spectrum but won 2 x 10 MHz in each of the other three bands on offer.
Meanwhile, French regulator Arcep announced plans for its own 700 MHz auction, to be held late this year, and said the spectrum would be “freed up progressively across the country” between April 2016 and June 2019. It has also issued draft decisions on the licensing procedures, following a consultation process which takes account of government and commercial priorities for 4G expansion, including regional development, promoting investment, and preserving “fair and effective competition”.
The reserve price is almost €2.5bn for the whole 700 MHz band and licences will include coverage obligations “as strong as those attached to the 800 MHz band”, especially when it comes to trains and subways, and rural areas, where Arcep’s goal is to “improve the quality of 4G services in these areas over time and to prepare for the potential development of 5G services on these bands”.
The regulator will offer six blocks of 2 x 5 MHz each and will put a cap of three blocks on any one bidder. No operator will be allowed to own more than 2 x 30 MHz of sub-1 GHz spectrum in total, across the 700 MHz, 800 MHz and 900 MHz bands combined.
However, if Altice (or Iliad) does acquire Bouygues Telecom (see separate item), the target figure could prove over-optimistic. Arcep’s proposals are clearly based on the assumption that France will still have four MNOs at the end of 2015, and contain numerous scenarios in which four players compete for licences – some of which net sums way above the reserve, even topping €3bn. The regulator’s proposed auction process is structured so that contenders reduce the number of spectrum blocks for which they are bidding as prices rise. When the total number of blocks attracting bids falls to six the auction will end, but that will happen more quickly, and therefore at a lower price level, with three bidders than four. Conversely, if Bouygues were contracted to a buyer but had not completed the merger, the two companies could bid separately – and would promptly break spectrum caps once they were combined.