We have all been increasingly beguiled by the vision of a new telecoms model where devices are untethered from networks and mobile web surfers can roam freely, with new all-IP technologies supporting a new breed of operators offering open low cost access and breaking down the walled gardens of the traditional cellcos. The first great experiment in making this dream a reality came with Wi-Fi, and the wide scale failure of the US metrozones has helped to inject a dose of sanity into the furore surrounding the ‘Google model’ of mobile broadband. And now, just as the cellcos were supposed to be losing their power, or forced to become bit pipes or open internet service providers, what do we see? Google, the champion of the new-look operators, working with Verizon. Microsoft saying it will not bid for 700MHz spectrum and it believes the future lies with working with the licensed cellcos. Laptop makers adopting embedded 3G+, as highlighted by the new Qualcomm Gobi chip, rather than the ‘PC technologies’ WiMAX and Wi-Fi. Apple and AT&T cashing in on a partnership based on an entirely retrograde closed approach.
Does all this mean the open mobile internet revolution will remain confined to niches or emerging markets, and the current licensed spectrum holders will remain supreme? To some extent, yes. This is not to say the cellos do not need to adapt to the new world. Already, operators like 3 are blazing the trail in opening up their portals and adopting internet business models. And converging pre-4G technologies, software defined radios and multimode devices, as well as open web services, will force the operators to support roaming, open access and other once unwelcome changes, and to include Wi-Fi and Linux in their mix. But it will remain true, at least for the medium term, that licensed spectrum networks will remain the most secure and robust basis for delivering high quality services, and the surest commercial model for operators, and will be required to support even the disruptive new web services (hence Clearwire’s moves to take licensed WiMAX into license-exempt metrozones, and Cisco’s enthusiasm for using WiMAX to add a high quality layer to address the limitations of unlicensed Wi-Fi as commercial broadband networks.
And until several generations of technology and spectrum policy have come and gone, the dominant interests in control of licensed spectrum (or even lightly licensed) will remain traditional telcos and cellcos. They have the lion’s share of existing allocations and are likely to continue to buy the majority of new licenses. The most likely challenge to this situation in the developed markets, especially the US, looked to come from cash-rich internet giants purchasing spectrum themselves to push a new business model in opposition to that of the cellcos. Sprint Nextel had already shown how, even in this situation, the established operators would not let the internet challengers in without a fight, planning to use its own licensed spectrum ‘ far more plentiful and useful than most disruptive companies could hope to get their hands on ‘ for its own open internet model. As in Wi-Fi and other PC/internet-inspired changes like flat rate data charges and unrestricted browsing, the telcos may not like having to adopt the changes that will dent their margins and customer control, but they will certainly prefer to adopt such changes themselves than let others reap the profits and market share.
In fact, the leading candidates to buy spectrum and kickstart an anti-cellco revolution are fading fast. Microsoft has said it will not bid in the upcoming 700MHz auction in the US, which because part of the bandwidth is mandated for open access is seen as an important testbed for new mobile models. Google, which had pledged to bid if the FCC adopted all its recommended rules (the FCC only approved a subset, letting Google off that hook) is now getting closer to, of all parties, Verizon Wireless. It launched its hugely hyped gPhone architecture this week, not as the basis for a whole new breed of unrestricted devices and operators, but as the heart of a collaboration with Verizon that could enable the second US cellco to counter the impact of the iPhone for AT&T, and the potential threat from Sprint’s open network plans. This may well be a more pragmatic way for Google to achieve its goals of broader uptake of mobile internet services (and therefore its advertising and other offerings) via an open internet model ‘ harnessing Verizon’s market weight rather than challenging it ‘ but it also leaves the whiphand clearly with the top three cellcos.
In his keynote at last week’s CTIA wireless event, Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer said the company’s mobile strengths lay in software and services, and success relied on working with major telcos, not alienating them by buying spectrum and setting up shop against them. “What would it buy us to buy a piece of spectrum – one piece of spectrum in one country? It would do a lot to alienate the telecom industry,” he said when questioned on the issue. “Terrible as it is to our competition, we don’t have plans to participate in spectrum auctions.”
At various times in the past, Microsoft has toyed with buying spectrum, and even invested at the turn of the century ‘ to the tune of $1bn – in broadband wireless operators that subsequently failed. Ballmer has made the clearest statement ever that Microsoft no longer sees its future in this direction, and believes the telcos are best suited to running wide area network services. “[Microsoft] may be broader in what we do than almost any company out there, but we think we have a core competence, and we think that the telecom industry and the service providers have a core competence,” he said, pointing to one of the key problems that has often doomed upstart operators to failure ‘ the complexity and expense of running a mobile network and business. “It takes a real expertise to set up networks, to invest in capital expenditure, to do the servicing of the networks, to provide the customer service 7 x 24,” he continued. “That is a core capability.”
While Intel, and possibly Cisco, remain possible bidders for spectrum, in order to accelerate uptake of the PC/internet technologies and services on which they depend, their task is looking increasingly hard, especially in the developed markets. It will not be helped by the growing enthusiasm of Intel’s natural allies, the PC makers, for embedding 3G wireless (something that may force the chip giant to revisit the HSPA chipset market that it abandoned when its proposed joint venture with Nokia failed earlier this year).
What is the incentive for a notebook maker to choose to embed a cellular option rather than WiMAX (Wi-Fi is a given in any specification)? One is that chips for HSPA and even Qualcomm’s Gobi ‘ whose multimode capabilities will be important for international travellers and in multi-network markets like the US ‘ are likely to appear in volume before Intel’s for WiMAX. Intel needs to accelerate its progress, or another laptop-oriented chipmaker needs to step into the breach to neutralize Gobi somewhat (an opportunity for Broadcom perhaps?) The other is that notebook makers generate more margin from the activation of a 3G laptop, via their deals with carriers, than they do from selling three or more non-3G products. This provides a clear incentive for the carriers ‘ protecting their 3G+ territories ‘ and the PC makers to strengthen their alliances, not dump them in favor of open access technologies. If the Google open model takes hold, there will be no more perks for device makers when their customers activate machines on a certain network ‘ unless, as is highly likely, ‘open’ operators like Sprint adopt a more closed model for WiMAX than they are currently planning. Ironically enough then, some PC vendors may be less enthusiastic about the PC-derived open access approach, provided they can muscle their way into a cellular model that was previously closed to them, by taking advantage of the increasing demand for wide area access in laptops, and the fact that, for now at least, the smartphone is no contender to the miniaturized PC in delivering a serious mobile internet experience. With a product like Gobi, the PC maker’s investment becomes even more secure since it can adopt a single chip that will work with nearly all the world’s 3G networks outside Japan (and possibly China). Qualcomm is also sure to exploit one of its key advantages in life ‘ the speed of response it can make because of its single-vendor control of its agenda. So Gobi is likely to gain support for new options such as AWS or 700MHz frequencies as these become commercially significant, whereas WiMAX has to go through an often tortuous profiling and certification process to adapt itself, in a fully standard form, to new bands.
All these examples show the cellular equipment makers and operators raising their game to adapt to the open mobile internet while keeping it firmly under their control ‘ and at least some of the apparently disruptive internet players are preferring to work with the cellcos to further their own aims, than against them. This will require the WiMAX community to step up its own activities to ensure that it offers a more attractive and commercially viable mobile internet solution for operators and device makers than 3G+ – and does this before the very similar LTE comes into play.
Full analysis of Google’s latest announcements will follow in the next issue of Wireless Watch.