The frenzy surrounding the anticipated Google phone (see inset) is reaching new heights, partly to fill the void left by the appearance of the iPhone, but mainly because the search giant is rightly perceived to be one of the most potentially disruptive forces in the emerging mobile internet. But the excitement about the device entirely misses the point. As a device maker per se, like Apple, Google’s brand and publicity machine will guarantee it profile, but like Apple, it will lack the supply chain, channels or market expertise to become a major player. This is irrelevant. Google has no more desire to be a phonemaker than it has to be a wireless operator, except insofar as these activities drive its real ambition, to ensure that the mobile internet is built around its particular advertising and content model, with all that entails, such as open, low cost access and the collapse of walled gardens. Google does want to take on Nokia, but not in handsets; just as it does want to disrupt AT&T, but not by providing a head-to-head service, rather using its Wi-Fi initiatives and potential spectrum acquisitions to support new providers that support the model.
This raises the really important question about the ‘G-phone’, now that we can more or less assume such a device will debut soon. This is not about its design ‘ Google certainly has the R&D weight and the partners to deliver a platform that ticks all the mobile internet boxes, such as touchscreens, Wi-Fi, Linux, advanced browsers and widget interfaces. It will score over the iPhone and Nokia N Series in some areas, lose in others, but will basically turn in an exciting handset that will be a powerful publicity driver for its wider models. But the real question is how such a product will be distributed. To push its ‘four points’ for a modern mobile network ‘ open access, open devices, open services and open networks ‘ Google needs to use the G-phone to draw attention to services and networks based on its new model, just as it plans to use any spectrum it might acquire in the 700MHz auction. Although the giant has numerous deals with major cellcos for its search and other internet services, collaborating with the carriers, while it may accelerate their inevitable progress towards open internet approaches, also props up their power, derived from the ownership of spectrum.
To reduce the power of the main cellcos and stimulate new services, whether in license-exempt bands or new bandwidth such as 700MHz, Google needs to get more radical with its handset, keeping it away from the traditional operators, using it to boost interest in new and unlicensed services, and even offering it for free (CEO Eric Schmidt has called in the past for mobile devices to be free). This would be a major investment and risk if Google really wanted to be a handset player, since it would be cutting off the best route to market, the cellcos with their huge user control and marketing impact. It would be throwing its device into the fray with hundreds of other low cost Wi-Fi products, would have to take on all the brand building and marketing itself, and would even attract the attentions of Nokia, itself seeking to establish leadership in open access devices in order to reduce the power of the carriers over its revenue models.
But if Google sees the handset primarily as a loss leader and a marketing tool, it represents ‘ like purchasing spectrum – an expensive but effective way to speed up the shift towards a Google-style wireless market. The more quickly such an environment evolves at the expense of walled gardens, the sooner the search company will be able to expand into the mobile sector and leverage its existing strengths (advertising and services, not devices and networks) to offer a full suite of internet services to the wireless base. The time factor is becoming increasingly critical. Nokia is building its own case for being the company that shapes the mobile internet in its own image, and basing its arguments on its superior expertise in mobility ‘ an approach for which Google badly needs a convincing argument. Also, despite its deep pockets, Google looks set to make major financial investments in moves that are mainly designed to stimulate its chosen business model ‘ but it also needs to start seeing some returns on this strategy in the near term. In particular, if it buys 700MHz spectrum, it needs to have convinced the market of its preferred wholesaling approach sufficiently that it attracts strong and lucrative new providers to offer open services on its network. The same goes for the handset ‘ it needs to sell in its own right, but more importantly it needs to drive increased usage of internet services that support Google adverts and services and so generate hard revenue.
Of course, another source of speculation has been that Google would also create its own operating system and a full software platform to drive its mobile services efficiently, integrate with its search engine and take on Symbian/Series 60, Windows and even other variants of Linux (the Google OS, it is assumed, would be Linux/Java-based). It seems unlikely that this full product will debut on an initial G-Phone, although elements such as a browser could be in the first release. Again, Google has to make some strategic decisions ‘ control the software platform and go head-to-head with Nokia in this battle, or go fully open source in keeping with its open credentials?
The eventual platform is likely, like the handset (and the rumors about both are clearly, in some cases, getting confused) to support low cost but web optimized multimedia phones, in line with the overall Google strategy of getting the mass market to use the mobile web, and therefore its services. Of course, others are chasing the same goal of pushing smartphone functionality downmarket, most notably Texas Instruments on the processor side, Nokia and Symbian, and some of the Linux vendors. An integrated device/software offering from Google would line up against Nokia’s Series 60 phones and Qualcomm’s chip-to-applications platforms, among others, but presumably the software would also be licensed for other devices, to conform to the Google model, with its own G-Phone primarily a showcase. Among many acquisitions and R&D projects Google has carried out in the mobile arena over the past few years, the most significant to the anticipated software release would be Android, a start-up purchased in 2005. Some white label handset makers are said already to have created prototypes using the Google software, which could be sold at around $100 and would be geared to carriers with ad-driven models, offering low cost or free calls. The most prominent is currently the US’ Virgin Mobile, which in July said that 330,000 of its 4.8m subscribers had agreed to view ads in exchange for free calling minutes.
Such announcements are indications that consumer behaviour is changing and many are ready to buy into new mobile approaches once a truly usable mobile internet emerges. This has not really happened yet, and neither Google nor Nokia will deliver one on first attempt, but they are helping to accelerate the shift to real mobile web, and in so doing, setting up one of the major stand-offs of recent times in the wireless market.
Mobile payments:
Google has applied for a patent for a mobile payment system, indicating once again the breadth of the search company’s ambitions ‘ like Nokia, it wants to control the whole range of core platforms underlying mobile internet services, with advertising, location, voice, content delivery and payments being among the most vital.
Google applied for the patent in February, and the US Patent and Trademark Office published the application last week. The document describes an SMS-based payment system, called GPay, which would send an SMS from the purchaser to the GPay system, which would then debit the user’s account and credit the store, and confirm this to the store in another SMS.
This is not unusual in itself, and resembles other m-payment systems such as eBay’s mobile PayPal or facilities in some specifically mobile platforms like Obopay. However, existing systems are mainly geared to downloaded purchases such as ringtones, but Google wants to extend the experience to stores and other non-online locations, even though previous attempts at mobile payments for non-digital items have largely failed. Google would probably look to change this by incentivizing merchants to use the method, by offering discounted advertising ‘ and approach it already uses with its Google Checkout online payment platform. The mobile version of this was launched in May but only works with WAP sites.
The G-Phone?
The latest inside track on the G-phone indicates that it will be ‘simpler and less flashy’ than the iPhone and its emulators, but will come with a Qwerty keyboard and an innovative interface featuring horizontal scrolling ‘ to maximize access to features despite small screen space ‘ and 3D animated on-screen buttons. The implication is that the handset will be positioned as low cost (or even free, if Google chooses to be really disruptive) and easily usable, in line with the aim of rapidly boosting user uptake of the mobile internet and driving Google services and adverts. However, it should be well branded and quirky enough to have consumer appeal. According to various reports, the device will sport mobile Linux (variant undisclosed) and Java UI and applications, plus a specially designed browser. There are likely to be three to five models, and it is rumoured that the manufacturer is Taiwan’s HTC, ironically best known for being Microsoft’s chief handset partner for Windows Mobile.
Google’s four demands:
Google said in July that, if the FCC acceded to its conditions for a 22MHz chunk of the 700MHz spectrum to be auctioned in the US early next year, it would pledge at least $4.6bn as a bid. Although the FCC backed off two of them, Google may still bid, and anyway, its four points neatly illustrate its vision for the mobile internet:
Open applications, with consumers able to download and use any software applications, content, or services they desire unrestricted by the operator
Open devices – consumers should be able to use whichever communications device and wireless network they prefer
Open services, allowing third parties to acquire wireless services from a 700MHz wholesaler on ‘reasonably non-discriminatory commercial terms’
Open networks, enabling all service providers to be able to interconnect at any technically feasible point in a 700MHz licensee’s network.
The timeline of gPhone speculation:
Web site SearchEngineLand has been down memory lane and put together a handy list of the main events that have fuelled the fire of gPhone speculation for the past three years:
December 2004 – Google VP Urs Hoelzle said mobile growth was being stalled because of too much fragmentation of devices, and the need for a common platform.
August 2005 – Google purchased Android, a start-up focused on making mobile software and rumoured to be developing an OS.
January 2006 – Google gained a patent to make CDMA data transfers happen at a faster speed.
November 2006 – CEO Eric Schmidt told Reuters: “Your mobile phone should be free” with ads subsidizing the cost, though denied Google itself would give away phones.
December 2006 ‘ Newspapers reported that Google was talking with Orange about a ‘Google phone’ made by HTC, though rumors mainly focused on a branding deal.
January 2007 ‘ Google signed a bundling deal with Samsung, but the resulting ‘Switch’ phone aroused talk of dual branding and a Samsung-made gPhone.
February 2007- Google was among several companies working on a wireless device that could use white spaces in TV spectrum, and avoid interference. This project has given rise to test devices shown to the FCC.
March 2007 – Google’s chief in Spain and Portugal confirmed that the company was working on some type of wireless device.
March 2007 Google said in a statement that there was no phone coming, but the company was staying software focused, sparking talk of the new OS.
March 2007 ‘ Google was said by the UK press to be in talks with O2 about a gPhone, and hiring the team that created T-Mobile’s popular Sidekick.
March 2007 ‘ Google announced more mobile-related patents.
April 2007 ‘ DigiTimes reported that HTC would make the gPhone, using TI processors and with built-in search and Gmail. Orange was said to be the first carrier.
May 2007 – Google started lobbying the FCC over conditions for 700MHz auction.
May 2007: Google was said to be about to strike a deal with O2 to become an online-only MVNO in the UK, offering handsets with preloaded Google apps.
July 2007 ‘ Google delivers its set of conditions on 700MHz to the FCC.
July 2007 ‘ Google caused a stir by being present at an MVNO show.
July 2007 – Google & Sprint partnered to create a new mobile internet service on the latter’s WiMAX network.
August 2007 ‘ Google reported by the Wall Street Journal to be talking to US carriers about a phone designed to run its applications, through a set of standard specifications, and about the new OS.
August 2007: The FCC rejects the Google-Microsoft prototype for use in white space spectrum.
August 2007 ‘ The gPhone was reported to be due to launch in India in the first week of September.
August 2007 ‘ new rumors that HTC would make the gPhone, and this time it was expected to debut in the first quarter of 2008.