The latest IPR battle has erupted between Google and BT, with the search giant suing the UK telco for allegedly infringing four of its patents.
Google has filed suit in the US over four broad patents in the areas of internet telephony and quality of service. Three of them came its way with the portfolio of patents it bought from IBM, while a fourth originated with Fujitsu. It says BT has used them without consent in its wholesale quality of service products and OneVoice unified communications platform, and is seeking damages.
There is also a UK action, though the details of that have not emerged, though a source at BT told GigaOm that it was a response to the lawsuit the telco filed in late 2011 against Google. That case is said to be due for mediation soon, and so the retaliatory action may be designed to strengthen the search firm’s bargaining power.
Google said in a statement that it sees ‘litigation as a last resort’ but is defending itself against both that 2011 suit and BT’s ‘arming of patent trolls’. The latter remark, according to GigaOM, refers to another case in which a licensing group called Suffolk Technologies sued Google and AOL in 2012, citing a BT patent.
Another troll, Steelhead Licensing, has used patents formerly held by BT to sue several Android device makers, including Google’s Motorola Mobility, as well as Apple, RIM and several US carriers. BT insists it gains no revenue from the Steelhead IPR.
Such cases highlight the rise of trolls in the wireless IPR arena, and large companies’ use of shell companies to offload their patents and attack rivals from while hiding behind specialist units. Google has even complained to the European Union about the latter practice, citing Microsoft and Nokia.