Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 July 2007

GSMA calls for global harmonization on 900MHz 3G

The fight for more spectrum for broadband wireless services continues to escalate, with the debates over 700MHz rules ongoing in the US, and the 900MHz band now increasingly the focus of lobbying by the GSM/UMTS community.

Last week, the GSM Association (GSMA) released some studies designed to bring pressure on regulators to reserve 900MHz spectrum globally for 3G mobile broadband alone. The logic was both compelling and complex, and was based on two reports that claimed that as many as 300m more people in Asia, Europe and Africa could enjoy access to mobile broadband if this spectrum was reserved and coordinated in those regions.

The idea is that 900MHz – which is being used or trialled for 3G in some areas, such as Finland and France, where regulators are friendly to the idea – would create a first layer for HSDPA, and then in cities and dense urban areas the 2.1GHz band would also be brought into play. The greater range of radio waves in the lower spectrum band and their ability to provide better coverage inside buildings would enable operators to achieve far broader 3G coverage at lower cost, particularly in rural areas. One of the studies, by UK researcher Ovum, claims to show that a 3G network in the 900MHz band would achieve up to 40% greater coverage than a 3G network in the 2.1GHz band, for the same capital expenditure.

‘National governments need to coordinate their spectrum policies to enable the widespread roll-out of HSPA in the 900MHz band,’ said Tom Phillips, chief government and regulatory affairo of the GSMA. ‘Such coordination would make HSPA at 900MHz a cost effective way to provide valuable broadband services to the many people untouched by the high speed internet revolution that has swept through the developed world.’

Ovum forecasts that, if the Asia-Pacific region alone were to adopt this practise, then it could lead to 450m people in the region using 3G by 2012, whereas if 3G were restricted to 2.1GHz alone, there would be just 200m people adopting 3G.

A second report, from RTT, talks about how supporting multiple spectra across a phonemaker’s entire portfolio drives up the pricing on handsets, the most expensive part of any network. The study attempts to quantify the increase in costs for a cellular network caused by spectrum fragmentation and argues that lower manufacturer runs can put as much as 50% on the cost of a handset. The RF component of a handset, the main piece that varies with each piece of spectrum, makes up just 7% of the total bill of materials, but prices soar by far more than that in specialist bands, partly because of the cost of design, says RTT. Other issues are that most handsets need five or six radios in order to roam effectively, and this figure would stop rising if the 900MHz option were universally adopted; and the higher costs of running small design runs with little hope of volume.

In light of these findings, the GSMA has called on regulators and vendors to plan together for the coordinated refarming of 900/1800MHz spectrum, which is widely used for GSM in Europe, Asia and Africa, and for the availability of affordable handsets. Such global planning would give investors confidence in UMTS/HSPA. The Association argues that there should be no differentiation between the different GSM bands (900/1800/1900MHz) to avoid any distortion of competition among GSM operators. The same benefits would also be achieved by refarming 850MHz spectrum (widely used in the US and Latin America).

Meanwhile, across the Atlantic, there are new twists and turns in the often vicious debate over the valuable 700MHz spectrum that will be auctioned in late 2007 or early 2008. The FCC should decide on rules for the auction next month.

The main debates are over how the public safety and commercial elements of the band will be managed and integrated. Some spectrum has been set aside purely for public safety, and there are various proposals to use additional bands for a combination of the two services. Among the proposals facing the FCC are rival suggestions from Cyren Call and Frontline Wireless, to set part of the upcoming 700MHz allocation aside for a combined commercial/public safety model; Google’s recent outlining of a scheme that would auction bandwidth on an on-demand basis, to stimulate smaller providers with innovative services; and the Virgin-backed Wireless Founders Coalition for Innovation, a coalition of wireless leaders calling for the creation of a nationwide ‘open access’ wireless network that could bypass the cellcos’ spectrum.

The largest of those cellcos, AT&T, disclosed last week that it is considering bidding for a national commercial/public safety license at the upcoming auction, while emergency systems giant Northrop Grumman told the FCC that an open access shared network, along the well backed lines proposed by Frontline Wireless, would not compromise first responder communications. The idea is that commercial services would give way to emergency use when required, and a single operator would manage the whole system, receiving one of the national licenses on favorable terms in return.

Frontline has powerful backing, but of course its aim to remove at least one of the national licenses from cellco hands does not go down well with the operators. Verizon Wireless last week released a study that it had commissioned from Criterion Economics – which also received industry funding to criticize Cyren Call’s own 700MHz public safety proposal, as well as public funding for rural wireless providers. The Verizon report predicts that public safety agencies might have to pay up to $9bn over six years to the winning bidder for a national /first responder license. Reed Hundt, vice chairman of Frontline and a former FCC chairman, then challenged Verizon’s CEO to debate the matter before the FCC itself. ‘Now that Verizon is hiring teams of surrogates to attack Frontline, we have to recognize Frontline is taken seriously by the most powerful telephone companies in the world,’ said Hundt. ‘What is really important is not Frontline, but homeland security. We invite Ivan Seidenberg, Verizon’s CEO, to meet in Washington any one of Frontline’s partners to debate the merits of Frontline’s plan to build a national public safety network versus Verizon’s plan”

AT&T is on record at the FCC as opposing open access conditions on 700MHz licenses. Like industry body the CTIA, it argues this would deter bidders. However, it seems it may not be wholly opposed to the hybrid idea, if it can use it to win a major license. In a story posted on the Center for Public Integrity’s web site, AT&T senior VP Robert Quinn wrote: ‘It’s a different business model for us, but one that we’d be looking at. If, in the end, that spectrum is attached to public safety, and for example there’s a wholesale requirement, we’ll take a look at it.” The company reiterated its official stance and said Quinn’s post did not represent the corporate view.