Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 July 2008

Hedge fund looks to create mobile satellite powerhouse with Inmarsat bid

US hedge fund Harbinger Capital has hatched an ambitious plan to become the largest player in the US mobile satellite market, just as that is emerging out of its niches in emergency response and remote access, and attracting the attention of the mobile broadband sector. The fund says it plans to launch a takeover bid for UK-based Inmarsat, which provides global mobile satellite services (MSS), a prey that would fit alongside its holding in north American player SkyTerra, the parent of MSV and MSV Canada. These are pioneers of hybrid satellite/terrestrial systems for mobile broadband, widely seen as the brightest hope for a new profit model for the often depressed mobile satellite sector. However, Harbinger could face a wait of up to 18 months to clear regulatory hurdles before it can even officially make a bid.

Harbinger already holds almost 29% of Inmarsat and 48% of SkyTerra, and these two companies signed a deal in January to work together, allowing the UK giant to leverage MSV’s license for ATC (Advanced Terrestrial Component), which permits hybrid terrestrial/satellite services. ATC opens up various new options for mobile satellite providers, enabling them to partner with radio network operators, for instance to support mobile broadband services in cities using a terrestrial network, with lower costs than satellite and standard handsets, but then providing remote access or emergency response applications with MSS, an added value that could appeal to deep pocketed partners such as cellcos, broadband ISPs or satellite TV companies.

To fulfil this promise of hybrid services, consolidation of the various players in the US will be necessary to generate convincing economics, especially as the three holders of ATC rights are fairly small ‘ these all gained additional 2GHz S-band spectrum with ATC permits in 2006. Apart from MSV, which is owned by SkyTerra, the other two are ICO, part of the Craig McCaw empire and a partner of his more famous outfit Clearwire; and Terrestar, in which Harbinger has also invested funds, but whose premier partner and backer is satellite TV giant EchoStar (see Wireless Watch February 19 2008). Terrestar gained access to 1.5GHz L-band spectrum through this deal, as did MSV through its Inmarsat alliance. Apart from the ATC/MSS specialists, there are also three global satellite players active in the US ‘ Inmarsat itself, Iridium (with no apparent hybrid ambitions) and GlobalStar. The last of these has gained limited rights to run hybrid services in its own bands.

So there is a race for MSS operators to sign partners with channels to market, complementary services and additional capacity, in which Terrestar has probably scored the most points because of EchoStar. But the Inmarsat/MSV combination is attractive too, and claims to have been in talks with three national wireless carriers about possible partnerships under which it would lease satellite capacity to cellcos, with ATC enabling this to be done using smaller, standard devices rather than expensive and bulky satphones. Inmarsat is moving into the mobile satellite voice market for the first time from 2009 and its ATC partnership with MSV is important to this, improving the economics. The company has long stayed away from the commercial minefield of satellite phone services, but now believes that combining these with terrestrial wireless networks will finally deliver the business model that has eluded other ventures. Inmarsat’s killer weapon, it claims, is its new generation fleet of BGAN broadband satellites, which are geosynchronous and deployed at half the cost of traditional low earth orbit (LEO) satellites.

All this makes it clear why Harbinger wants to gain control of the whole Inmarsat/SkyTerra venture in north America, not to mention Inmarsat’s global operators, which have been turning round rapidly under well regarded CEO Andy Sukawaty after the dark MSS days of the turn of the decade. But Harbinger may find it hard to net Inmarsat, since it could wait as long as 18 months for US regulatory approval even to mount a bid for the £2.1bn ($4.18bn) group. If Harbinger did make a successful bid for Inmarsat, it says it would also seek to increase its SkyTerra holding to around 60%. However, although Inmarsat is UK-based, its single largest customer is the US government, so any potential bidder would need approval from the FCC, which took a full 16 months to clear the recent merger of satellite radio players Sirius and XM. There could also be antitrust issues, although the improving health of Iridium and Globalstar, plus Terrestar’s strong partnerships, might mitigate these concerns. Nevertheless, if a rival bidder without existing satellite assets emerged to counter Harbinger, it might have an easier regulatory passage ‘ and a rival bid could well materialize, given that Inmarsat is the best positioned of the mobile satellite firms, with its new fleet and its ATC alliance and, unlike most rivals, it is profitable.

These strengths mean Inmarsat has no need to seem over-eager about the possible takeover. In its statement, it said it was ‘highly confident’ of its standalone prospects, though noted it would ‘maintain a constructive relationship’ with Harbinger and SkyTerra through review process, assuming a bid goes ahead. It is not, however, a party to the master agreement though a spokesperson said: ‘We are not against an offer from SkyTerra/Harbinger and we are not against them trying to pre-clear regulatory hurdles. ‘ We will monitor the regulatory process to ensure that it doesn’t affect our business as an independent company. We will look at an offer if one emerges.’

SkyTerra has far more to gain, and waxed lyrical in its own statements about a deal that would enable it to access Inmarsat spectrum to provide ‘ubiquitous wireless coverage’ in the US and Canada. ‘The combination of SkyTerra and Inmarsat makes a great deal of strategic and operational sense. It would greatly enhance spectrum efficiency and North American L-Band spectrum while providing a foundation for innovation in the global mobile satellite industry,’ said CEO Alexander Good.

Meanwhile, Harbinger agreed to provide $500m of debt financing to fund SkyTerra’s business plan up to the third quarter of 2010. ‘Obtaining this financing is a significant milestone for SkyTerra and MSV,’ said Good. ‘We have obtained committed financing for our period of greatest financial need ‘ through the launch of our MSV-1 satellite to the time we expect to launch MSV-2. We now look forward to bringing to market the advanced services we believe will set a high water mark for the MSS/ATC industry, and extend the marketplace for satellite services far beyond their historical bounds. This revolutionary satellite system is expected to provide service for at least 15 years and will ring in the era of integrated satellite-terrestrial networks.’