Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 March 2013

HTC versus Samsung is a battle of supply chain control

Success in mass consumer devices has always relied on a balance between supply chain and cost efficiencies, versus hardware innovation ‘ which usually incurs added costs. HTC has come up against the dark side of this dilemma with its new flagship HTC One, which is delayed in some markets because of reported component shortages. The Taiwanese vendor made considerable innovations to make One stand out from the Android crowd, but these have come at a price – not just the cost of customized parts, but the difficulty of getting suppliers to focus on them if they do not promise massive volumes.

By contrast, Samsung has tightening control of its chain, with many of the most innovative components coming from its own sister firms, and even when it buys outside, its huge sales guarantee it will be first in the queue for capacity. That gives the firm a bit more latitude to introduce new hardware features, even at extra cost, while preserving a decent margin, and avoiding the disaster of significant delays or shortages to a critical product.

Indeed, a teardown by IHS iSuppli finds that the new Galaxy S4 is 15% more expensive, in bill of materials terms, than its predecessor, with BOM of $236. The main contributors are upgraded display, sensors, processor and memory (though most of those parts come from Samsung operating companies, and about 65% of the total).

The main additional cost lies in the AMOLED 1920×1080 display, which costs $75, $10 more than the S3’s. This indicates how the screen is becoming one of the biggest differentiators in hardware for phone buyers along with some of the elements highlighted by the HTC One, such as the camera.

Indeed, the vendor’s ‘ultrapixel’camera technology is both one of the most striking elements of the recently launched product and the one in shortest supply, along with the metal frame. That means the One will be delayed for several weeks in some markets, meaning it will have to go head-to-head with the Samsung Galaxy S4 juggernaut, hitting the shelves at a similar time instead of getting a headstart.

This indicates the dilemma that faces device makers ‘ they need to differentiate their products, but unusual features increase their exposure to component shortages. This is particularly true of companies which do not have the same volumes, and therefore the same influence over suppliers, as Samsung or Apple. According to The Wall Street Journal, HTC is no longer considered a top tier customer by some members of its supply chain, even as it is looking for fairly rarefied parts ‘ the ultrapixel camera uses sensors with larger pixels for greater performance in low light, while the metal frame is HTC’s own new design.

After successive quarters of falling handset sales, suppliers’ confidence in HTC’s future volumes may be dented, which can lead them to prioritize parts for guaranteed winners like Samsung. A unnamed company executive told the WSJ: ‘The company has a problem managing its component suppliers as it has changed its order forecasts drastically and frequently following last year’s unexpected slump in shipments.’

Jasmine Lu of Morgan Stanley recently wrote in a client note: ‘Innovation becomes a risky strategy without scale: Weak February sales imply 1Q revenues might hit the low bar owing to weaker than anticipated sell-in strength, restrained by critical component supply (ie actuator for its new ‘ultrapixel’ cameras’) on our checks. This affirms our view that it is a bold move for HTC to use tailor-made components for its new HTC One, causing low yield at the initial stage of ramp-up.’